Washed Out: Q3 2014 and the Summer Jamaica’s Beaches Disappeared Under a Tide of Sargassum

Briefing

• Sargassum arrived on Jamaica’s north coast beaches in unprecedented volumes from July 2014.
• Some Negril beaches were effectively inaccessible for weeks during peak inundation.
• The Jamaica Hotel and Tourist Association issued an emergency statement in August.
• Tourism ministry funded emergency beach raking operations at major resort beaches.
• First-time visitors who had booked on the basis of beach photography documented the mismatch on social media.

When the first significant sargassum accumulations appeared on Jamaica’s eastern beaches in late June and early July 2014, resort managers had no established protocol for dealing with them. The seaweed that had been appearing in small quantities on some Caribbean beaches since 2011 had, by 2014, grown in volume to the point where it was arriving in quantities that manual raking operations — the tool that resorts had used to manage ordinary levels of seaweed and marine debris — were simply insufficient to address. The mats were metres deep. The rakers could not keep pace. The smell of decomposing sargassum was reaching reception areas and pool decks.

At Negril, where the combination of the beach’s orientation and the prevailing current patterns produced some of the heaviest deposition, stretches of Seven Mile Beach spent weeks under sargassum accumulations that buried the sand. The beach itself — the physical beach, the sand — was invisible under the brown mats. Guests who had arrived at the resort on the basis of photographs that showed white sand and clear water were, instead, looking at a shore that bore no resemblance to what they had been sold. The social media documentation was immediate and extensive.

The Industry’s Emergency Response

The Jamaica Hotel and Tourist Association’s emergency statement in August 2014 acknowledged the crisis and announced a coordinated industry response: additional raking capacity, inter-resort cooperation on equipment sharing, and engagement with the government on emergency funding for beach management operations at the most severely affected sites. The Tourism Ministry responded with an emergency allocation that funded mechanical raking assistance at priority resort beaches. The response was well-intentioned and practically useful at the margins. It was also, by design, a response to the immediate crisis rather than a strategy for the structural challenge that crisis had revealed: Jamaica’s tourism product was substantially dependent on beach quality, and beach quality was now subject to a seasonal variable entirely outside Jamaica’s control.

The South Coast Dimension

While the crisis coverage focused almost entirely on the north coast resort belt, coastal communities on Jamaica’s south coast were experiencing sargassum impacts of a different kind. Fishers in Clarendon, St Elizabeth, and Manchester reported that sargassum accumulations in nearshore waters were entangling fishing gear, reducing visibility and consequently the catch, and creating conditions that made some traditional fishing grounds temporarily unusable. For communities dependent on fishing income, the economic impact was real and immediate, and it received virtually no coverage in the tourism industry’s crisis communications. The south coast fishers were experiencing the same phenomenon but in an entirely different economic relationship with the coast, and that relationship was invisible in the coverage that framed sargassum as a tourism problem.

Related: Property Market Analysis | Latest Jamaica News

Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomes Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com