KINGSTON, Jamaica. Ask an economist to design the ideal tax and the answer, more often than not, is a levy on the value of land alone. It cannot be moved offshore, it cannot be hidden from the tax office, and because nobody can manufacture more land, taxing it does not discourage anyone from working, saving or building. Most countries talk about such a tax. Very few have ever run one across a whole nation. Jamaica began moving to one in 1957 and has taxed every parcel on land value alone since its first island wide roll in 1974.

That is the surprise at the centre of this investigation. Jamaica already owns the policy that reformers in Detroit failed to pass and that Henry George made famous in 1879. What it has not done is use it. On the most recent figures published in the Government’s own public finance assessment, property tax brought in about J$9.3 billion in the 2023/24 financial year, roughly 0.3 per cent of national output on the GDP measure then in use. The average across rich democracies for annual property taxes is about 1 per cent.
Much of the gap is self inflicted. Jamaica valued its land five times between 1974 and 2013, an average of almost a decade between rolls, and the 2013 values were not used for tax until 2017. When Finance Minister Audley Shaw finally applied them, he told Parliament that compliance was around 57 per cent. The country now has roughly 900,000 parcels, and the National Land Agency, which began on 1 July 2026, is valuing them again in an exercise expected to take 20 months.
The Tax Economists Love
The argument is old. Adam Smith argued that ground rents were an especially proper subject of taxation, because the owner enjoys them without any care or attention of his own. In 1879 a San Francisco journalist named Henry George published Progress and Poverty, which proposed a single tax on land values to replace all others. It sold in the millions and launched a movement that reached Denmark, Australia and New Zealand.
The modern case is more measured but no less firm. The IMF’s John Norregaard, in 2013 research, found that recurrent property taxes yield about 1 per cent of GDP in advanced economies and only about 0.4 per cent in middle income countries, and described the gap as a large potential for enhanced use. OECD research has repeatedly ranked recurrent taxes on immovable property as the least damaging to long run growth. A tax confined to land goes further still: it falls only on the part of a property’s value that the owner did not create.
Norregaard also explained why governments shy away. The tax is transparent and hard to evade, which breeds popular resistance, and it arrives as a single visible bill rather than a quiet deduction from a payslip. Economists have called it the perfect tax; homeowners have called it the most hated. It also demands something poorer states often lack: a complete, current register of every parcel and its value.
A Short List of Countries That Tax the Ground
Taxing land separately from buildings is rarer than the textbooks suggest. Most of the world taxes land and buildings together, which means that a family that builds a second floor pays more, while a speculator holding an empty lot in the same street pays little. Only a handful of jurisdictions do what Jamaica does.
Estonia adopted a land only tax in 1993, two years after independence, as part of its post Soviet land reform. Buildings are not taxed at all. Municipalities set rates within national bands; for 2026 the Estonian Tax and Customs Board lists 0.1 to 1 per cent on residential land, a home tax incentive of up to €1,000 that each council can grant, and a cap on how fast any bill may rise. About 334,600 individuals and 35,700 companies are paying it this year.
Denmark has levied grundskyld, a municipal tax on land value, for more than a century. Its 2024 reform kept the land tax, capped municipal rates at 30 per mille, taxed only 80 per cent of the assessed land value and gave existing owners a permanent rebate so that new valuations would not cause bill shock. New South Wales charges land tax on land value only, but exempts the family home and charges investors 1.6 per cent above a threshold of A$1,075,000. Taiwan levies a progressive land value tax from 1 to 5.5 per cent, with a preferential 0.2 per cent rate for a family’s own home, alongside a separate tax on buildings.
| Jurisdiction | Since | What is taxed | Headline rates |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jamaica | 1957 | Unimproved value of every parcel, all parishes | J$1,000 flat up to J$400,000; then 0.5% rising to 0.9% at the margin |
| Estonia | 1993 | Land only; buildings exempt | 0.1% to 1% residential (2026); up to €1,000 home incentive |
| Denmark | Long standing; reformed 2024 | Land value (grundskyld), plus a separate tax on home value | Municipal rate capped at 30 per mille on 80% of land value |
| New South Wales | 1956 (current Act) | Land value; owner occupied homes exempt | 1.6% above A$1,075,000; 2% above A$6,571,000 |
| Taiwan | Post war land reform | Announced land value, plus separate building tax | 1% to 5.5%; 0.2% for own home |
| Harrisburg, Pennsylvania | 1975 | Split rate: land taxed more heavily than buildings | Land rate a multiple of building rate |
| Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania | 1913 to 2001 | Split rate, abandoned after a reassessment shock | Land taxed about 5.8 times buildings at the end |
| Hong Kong | Colonial era | Government owns the land and sells leases | Land premium 19.5% of revenue in 2018/19 |
The United States offers the cautionary tales. Pennsylvania has allowed cities to tax land at a higher rate than buildings since 1913. Pittsburgh did so for almost 90 years, ending with land taxed at about 5.77 times the rate on structures, then abandoned the system in 2001 after a countywide reassessment, following years of under assessment, sent land values soaring. In Harrisburg, which adopted a split rate in 1975, the count of vacant structures fell from more than 4,200 in 1982 to fewer than 500 by 2001, according to figures compiled by the policy publication Strong Towns, though researchers caution that many forces were at work. Detroit’s mayor proposed cutting homeowners’ bills by an average of 17 per cent through a land value tax in 2023; the Michigan legislature never passed the enabling law.
How Jamaica Got Here
Jamaica’s choice was made in the dying years of colonial rule. Before 1957 the island taxed land and buildings together on owners’ own declarations of value. Later studies estimated that assessed values averaged less than a third of market value, with gross inconsistency between neighbours. A commission of inquiry chaired by Simon Bloomberg recommended in the 1940s that the tax fall on unimproved land value instead, partly in the belief that it would discourage owners from withholding land from use.
Parliament passed the Land Valuation Law in December 1956 and the work began the following June. It was slow. An IMF staff paper from 1967 noted that the revaluation was only about half finished seven and a half years later. The first complete island wide roll was not ready until 1974. The law requires the Commissioner of Land Valuations to value every parcel and, in principle, to repeat the exercise every five years.
Revenue was never the point, and it has rarely been the result. Since the Local Government reforms of 2016, 90 per cent of property tax collected in each parish is paid to that parish’s municipal corporation and the remaining 10 per cent to an equalisation fund. In 2023/24 property tax supplied about 46 per cent of everything the municipal corporations received from central sources. It pays for street lights, garbage collection, markets and parochial roads, which is why the gap matters on every street in the island.
Thirteen Years Between Rolls
The weakness is not the design but the clock. After the 1974 roll, Jamaica revalued in 1983, 1992, 2002 and 2013, gaps of nine, nine, ten and eleven years. Each delay stored up a shock. Between the 2002 and 2013 rolls, the unimproved value of Jamaica’s land rose from J$567 billion to about J$1.9 trillion, Mr Shaw told Parliament in April 2017, an increase of roughly 235 per cent and equivalent to about 130 per cent of GDP.
In April 2013, with the new roll not yet in use, the then government raised rates on the 2002 values to 1.5 and 2 per cent. When the new administration applied the 2013 roll in 2017, it first announced rates of 0.8 to 1.3 per cent, then cut them within weeks after a public outcry, to the 0.5 to 0.9 per cent schedule that still stands. Mr Shaw said 58 per cent of the 776,487 properties on the roll would see their bill fall or stay flat, while 6,848 properties valued above J$20 million faced increases averaging between 201 and 604 per cent. A bill to allow annual increases in land values between full revaluations was tabled in January 2017; bills are nonetheless still calculated on the 2013 roll.
Myth Check: What Jamaicans Actually Pay
Two numbers circulate widely and both mislead. The first is that property tax rates “vary by parish from 0.5 to 1.5 per cent”, a line repeated in coverage of the current revaluation. The schedule published by Tax Administration Jamaica, in force since April 2017, applies to all parishes alike. The second is that the current maximum rate is 1.3 per cent, a figure that comes from the schedule announced in March 2017 and withdrawn in April of that year.
Because the rates are graduated like income tax, the effective rate is far lower than the headline. A parcel with an unimproved value of J$10 million, the example used in one widely read report to suggest a bill of between J$50,000 and J$150,000, owes J$65,600 under the published schedule, an effective rate of about 0.66 per cent. A family plot valued at J$1.7 million pays J$8,050 a year. In 2017 the Government said 110,303 owners of land valued at J$400,000 or less would pay a flat J$1,000.
A third figure, the share of GDP, is also muddled. A 2018 CAPRI report put property tax at 0.3 per cent of GDP and 2 per cent of tax revenue, against an OECD average often quoted as 2.1 per cent of GDP. That OECD number appears to cover all property taxes, including stamp duties and inheritance taxes; the comparable average for annual property taxes is about 1 per cent. A 2026 CAPRI commentary gives 0.7 per cent for Jamaica in 2023. The transfers recorded in the Government’s own assessment support the lower figure for the annual land tax; broader definitions that add transfer tax and stamp duty produce higher ones.
The Collection Problem
Low rates are only half the story. The other half is who pays. A Ministry of Finance presentation in 2015 found that only 37 per cent of parcels were fully paid up in 2013/14. On a different measure, Mr Shaw put compliance at about 57 per cent in 2017 and arrears at about J$13.5 billion. In April 2025 the Mayor of Montego Bay, Richard Vernon, reported that St James had beaten its collection target at J$1.318 billion, yet only 44 per cent of owners in the parish had paid.
Enforcement is now sharper. Tax Administration Jamaica and the Kingston and St Andrew Municipal Corporation identified 432 properties in Half Way Tree alone owing about J$162 million, excluding the current year. In Portmore and Spanish Town, TAJ has said it is considering liens and the seizure of goods, with more than 50 owners expected in court. The law allows the state to forfeit and sell land for unpaid tax, although Mr Shaw told Parliament in 2017 that the Government had no intention of taking anyone’s property because of hardship.
There is a structural reason for the drift. The tax is collected by a national agency but spent by parishes, and a body collecting a tax has little incentive to chase it when the money goes elsewhere. CAPRI’s research adds a counterweight: administering property tax costs the Government about 0.3 per cent of the revenue raised, against 3.4 per cent for income tax.
Why There Is No Honest League Table of Land Taxes
Readers may expect a ranking of the world’s land taxes by revenue. One cannot be built honestly. OECD statistics record recurrent taxes on immovable property but do not separate land from buildings, and most countries’ systems blend the two. Denmark’s land tax sits beside a separate home value tax; Taiwan’s beside a building tax; New South Wales’ beside council rates that are themselves based on land value. Hong Kong captures land value mainly by selling leases, which appears in its books as capital revenue, not tax. Jamaica’s own figure depends on whether one counts what the parishes receive or what taxpayers owe. The comparisons in this article therefore use the broad OECD category for annual property taxes and state their basis.
What This Means for Jamaica
The new roll is coming. The National Land Agency began revaluing roughly 900,000 parcels on 1 July 2026 and expects to finish in 20 months. Finance Minister Fayval Williams has confirmed, the Jamaica Observer reported, that the results will lead to higher property taxes in the 2027/28 financial year. After Hurricane Melissa the Government has said it needs roughly J$30 billion in additional revenue. Simple arithmetic shows why economists keep pointing at land: had Jamaica raised 1 per cent of GDP from annual property tax in 2023/24, the OECD average, it would have collected about J$30 billion rather than J$9.3 billion. That is an illustration, not a forecast, and it assumes compliance no other part of the tax system achieves.
The case for leaning on land is made most forcefully by Dr Damien King, executive director of CAPRI, who told a CAPRI budget forum in March that when taxes are ranked by how distorting and how hard to administer they are, property tax rises to the top. In August he argued that land should be revalued every year and that the tax should always rest on up to date valuations. CAPRI argues that a stronger land tax would also make it costlier to sit on idle lots in a country short of housing.
The case for caution is just as real. Mr Shaw’s own statement in 2017 noted that many poor and elderly Jamaicans hold land as their only asset; a rising valuation adds nothing to a pensioner’s income. Farmers, small hotels and owners of family land with unclear title bear bills they may struggle to pay, and a tax that rises sharply after a hurricane risks falling hardest on those still rebuilding. The relief tools already exist on paper, including agricultural derating of up to 50 per cent and special discretionary relief of up to 100 per cent for hardship, but in 2017 the minister himself admitted that the relief committees had left applications pending for years.
For buyers and sellers, the practical points are plain. Unpaid property tax can lead to a lien that blocks a sale or a mortgage, so arrears tend to surface at closing. The new roll will change the cost of holding vacant lots more than the cost of owning a modest home. And any owner who believes a new valuation is wrong has 60 days from the notice to lodge an objection with the Commissioner of Land Valuations, paying 75 per cent of the tax while the objection is heard.
The Lesson From Pittsburgh
Pittsburgh did not abandon its land tax because the theory failed. It abandoned it because valuations were left stale for years and then caught up in a single countywide reassessment. Estonia and Denmark, by contrast, now publish forecasts months ahead and cap how fast bills can rise. The difference between a land tax that endures and one that provokes revolt is less about the rate than the rhythm.
Jamaica chose the economists’ favourite tax almost 70 years ago and has spent most of the time since apologising for it. The 2026 revaluation is the chance to decide whether it is a tax worth running properly: valued often, collected evenly, and tempered for those who own land but little else.
Land cannot hide and it cannot leave. The only question is whether Jamaica is willing to count it on time.
Method: Figures come from the Tax Administration Jamaica property tax schedule; the Ministry of Finance statement to Parliament of 11 April 2017; the Government of Jamaica PEFA Assessment 2024 (municipal transfers, FY2023/24, and GDP of J$2,992 billion for 2023/24 on the pre revision national accounts); OECD Revenue Statistics 2025 for annual property taxes in 2023, as compiled by Property Tax Lab; IMF research by John Norregaard (2013) and IMF Staff Papers (1967); David Sjoquist, Georgia State University (2005); CAPRI reports and commentary (2018, 2026); the Estonian Tax and Customs Board; the Danish Tax Agency; Revenue NSW and NSW Budget Papers; the Hong Kong Legislative Council Research Office; the CUNY Institute for State and Local Governance; and reporting by the Jamaica Gleaner and Jamaica Observer, attributed in the text. Jamaica’s share of GDP is a Jamaica Homes News calculation from transfers received by municipalities and may differ from amounts billed or collected. The J$30 billion comparison is illustrative arithmetic. Tax examples use bands up to J$12 million, where published schedules agree.
Dean Jones is Director of Jamaica Homes Ltd and a Realtor.

Visit our YouTube Community ↗