Jamaica has more than twice as many holiday rental listings as Barbados. Barbados, with roughly a tenth of Jamaica’s population, earns almost as much from its listings, and it has been taxing them since 2018.
For eight years, every Barbadian host who is not registered for value added tax has been expected to add a 10 per cent Shared Economy Levy to each booking. Jamaica has charged its hosts nothing at all. That changes on April 1, 2027, when General Consumption Tax reaches short term rentals for the first time. The question now is whether Jamaica copies the island that got there first, or learns from what Barbados is still getting wrong.

Scale: one island is bigger, the other is busier
The two islands are hard to compare on raw counts, because no government in either place publishes an official tally of holiday rentals. The best consistent measure comes from AirROI, an analytics firm that tracks Airbnb listings. For the twelve months to October 2026 it counts 7,220 active listings in Jamaica across 60 markets and 2,970 in Barbados.
Jamaica’s listings sit mainly in Kingston (about 1,920), Montego Bay (980), Ocho Rios (805), Negril (463) and Portmore (439), so much of its supply serves the capital and its commuter towns rather than the beach.
Other counts run higher; reporting in July 2025 put Jamaica above 10,000 active listings. Firms define “active” differently, so we use one source for both islands. In 2016, when the Jamaica Tourist Board signed a promotion agreement with Airbnb, the company said Jamaica had about 4,000.
Adjust for size and the picture flips. Barbados has about 11 listings for every 1,000 residents; Jamaica has fewer than three. Barbados also has about four listings for every 1,000 stayover visitors it received in 2025, against fewer than three in Jamaica, a year in which Jamaica’s stopover arrivals fell 13.3 per cent to 2.49 million, with Hurricane Melissa wiping out weeks of business at the end of the year.
Edge: Jamaica on size, Barbados on intensity.
Price and performance: Barbados earns more per door
A Barbadian listing charges an average of about BDS$630 a night, roughly US$315, against J$30,500 (about US$193) in Jamaica. It is booked on 43 per cent of available nights; a Jamaican listing on 34 per cent. The result is that the average Barbadian listing takes in about US$33,800 a year in gross revenue, more than twice the Jamaican average of about US$15,600.
Multiply those averages out and the two markets turn over broadly similar sums: very roughly US$113 million a year in Jamaica and US$100 million in Barbados, on our estimate. That is well below the J$32 billion (about US$200 million) that Delano Seiveright, then a junior tourism minister, said owners had earned in 2024, a figure built on a different period and method.
The averages hide a harder reality for many Jamaican hosts. In a September 2026 analysis, Andrew Duncan of Realty One Group Titans told the Jamaica Observer that a prime one bedroom apartment in Kingston costs about J$36 million and that the strategy “is working for some people; it is just not working for most.”
Edge: Barbados.
Tax: eight years ahead
Barbados built its tax in layers. A Ministry of Tourism notice of July 2018 set a 10 per cent Shared Economy Levy on “all sharing economy platform rentals such as AirBnb, HomeAway and Vacation Rentals By Owners”, payable to the Barbados Revenue Authority. Larger operators registered for VAT instead pay a concessionary 10 per cent VAT on accommodation, raised from 7.5 per cent in January 2020. From April 2019, vacation rental properties registered with the tourism authority also became liable for a Room Rate Levy of 3.75 per cent of the nightly rate, capped at BDS$35 a bedroom.
Jamaica’s licensed tourism operators, hotels included, pay General Consumption Tax at a reduced 10 per cent, due to rise to the standard 15 per cent on April 1, 2027. Short term rentals were simply outside the net. Finance Minister Fayval Williams confirmed in the House on April 29, 2026 that the General Consumption Tax (Amendment of Schedules) Order, 2026 brings them in from the same date.
The catch is the threshold. Registration for GCT is compulsory only once annual turnover passes J$15 million, a level set from April 2025. The average Jamaican listing earns about J$2.5 million, roughly a sixth of that. Unless the Tax Administration Jamaica publishes rules that reach smaller hosts, much of the market may stay outside the tax in practice. Barbados avoided that gap by aiming its levy precisely at hosts below the VAT threshold, which itself rose from BDS$200,000 to BDS$350,000 on October 1, 2026.
| Jamaica | Barbados | |
|---|---|---|
| Small host below the VAT or GCT threshold | No tax on the booking | 10% Shared Economy Levy (since 2018) |
| Registered operator | Not covered until April 1, 2027 | 10% VAT on accommodation |
| Room levy | None for rentals | 3.75% Room Rate Levy, capped at BDS$35 a bedroom |
| Registration threshold | J$15 million (about US$95,000) | BDS$350,000 (about US$175,000) from Oct 2026 |
| Platform collects the tax? | Not yet decided | Yes, in law since January 2026 |
Edge: Barbados.
The platform as tax collector
Barbados learned that a levy on paper is not money in the bank. Small hosts had been reporting the Shared Economy Levy on VAT forms every two months. In July 2025 Ryan Straughn, a minister in the Ministry of Finance, moved the Tourism Levy (Amendment) Bill so that Airbnb, Booking.com and Expedia would collect the levy from guests and remit it straight to the Barbados Revenue Authority. The House passed it on July 29, 2025, the Senate followed on January 14, 2026, and it became law as the Tourism Levy (Amendment) Act, 2026 on January 17, 2026.
The Act adds a blunt enforcement tool: “Unpaid levies are a lien and charge against the property where the tourist accommodation is provided.” In other words, a host who fails to pay can find the debt attached to the house itself, a point any buyer of a Barbadian rental villa now needs to check. Opposition Senator Andrew Mallalieu called the measure unworkable and said such a lien had never before been used in Barbados.
Jamaica has not said who will collect its new tax. Hugh Thompson, president of the Jamaica Home Sharing Association, and Sherie-Ann Anderson, Airbnb’s community leader for Jamaica, have both asked for a phased start. Andrea Purkiss, the Opposition spokesperson on tourism, said the measure was passed “like a thief in the night”, and the Opposition called for a full impact assessment. Finance Minister Fayval Williams tied the package to fiscal pressures after Melissa, and supporters argue that a sector serving hundreds of thousands of guests a year can no longer be the only part of tourism outside the tax system.
Edge: Barbados.
The law: register first, license later
Neither island has finished the job. Barbados gave notice of its Tourist Accommodation Bill on July 24, 2025. It would make it an offence to “operate or advertise tourist accommodation without a tourist accommodation licence”, set licences at two years, require fire certificates, public liability insurance and a multi hazard plan, and create a public register to be gazetted every six months. The House of Assembly passed it on September 16, 2025. During the debate, Tourism Minister Ian Gooding-Edghill noted that “only hotels, apartments and guest houses” were registered, inspected and licensed. Days later the Government paused the Bill to consult vacation rental owners, and it lapsed when Parliament was dissolved in January 2026 ahead of the February election. In March 2026 the minister spoke only of continued work on a tourist accommodation bill.
Jamaica’s attempt went further back. The Jamaica Tourist Board Bill, 2025, piloted by Tourism Minister Edmund Bartlett, would have repealed the 1955 Act and required most short term rental operators to register and be licensed by the Tourist Board. Owner occupied homestays of one to nine rooms, and apartments in buildings whose strata rules ban short term letting, would only need to register. Debate was suspended on July 1, 2025 and the Bill lapsed with the end of that Parliament.
Mr Bartlett said the Bill sought “a fair, transparent system that safeguards quality, safety, security, and consistency.” Opposition Leader Mark Golding called its penalty clause a “sword of Damocles” over small entrepreneurs and said the sector was being treated more harshly than ground transport or car rental.
Edge: Barbados, narrowly; its Bill at least cleared one House.
Penalties: what counts as excessive
The Jamaican fines that caused the uproar were, by Barbadian standards, modest. Mr Golding read the Bill as setting fines of up to J$1 million for unregistered or unlicensed operations of 1 to 50 rooms and J$2 million for 51 to 100 rooms, with up to a year in prison. That is about US$6,300 and US$12,700.
The lapsed Barbados Bill set a fine of BDS$250,000, about US$125,000, for operating or advertising without a licence, and BDS$100,000 for failing to display one at a hotel, guest house or apartment. Mr Gooding-Edghill said that “the $250 000 is the ceiling, not a blanket penalty” and that “no one will be shut down without due process.” The difference is that Barbados paired its maximum with written warnings to rectify problems, notice of inspections at least seven days ahead, and a six month grace period for first time applicants.
Edge: Jamaica, for proportion.
Hotels and the all inclusive question
The two islands sell different holidays. Jamaica’s hotel offer is dominated by large all inclusive resorts, and its tourist board lists about 11,155 rooms in 23 projects in the pipeline, led by Montego Bay. In that market, a villa or apartment gives visitors something the resorts do not: a kitchen, a neighbourhood and a reason to spend money outside the gate. Delano Seiveright cited guests rising from 59,500 in 2017 to more than 800,000 in 2024, equal to roughly three in ten of that year’s stopover arrivals.
Barbados has a long villa tradition on its west coast and a smaller hotel sector; its hotels ran at 65.3 per cent occupancy in 2025, when long stay arrivals hit a record 729,310. Its Bill defines a villa as a house worth at least BDS$2 million with three bedrooms and three staff, keeping the luxury end separate from the spare room market. Hosts in both countries say the rules favour hotels; both governments say they want every property sold to visitors registered and inspected.
Edge: even.
Housing: the evidence neither island has
Cities that have restricted holiday lets, from Barcelona, which plans to end about 10,000 tourist apartment licences by November 2028 with backing from Spain’s Constitutional Court, to New York, did so to push homes back to local renters. Neither Jamaica nor Barbados has published a study measuring how many homes have moved from long lets to holiday lets, or what that has done to rents.
Barbados’s 2021 census found 8,292 of 73,571 dwellings unoccupied, about 11 per cent, without saying how many were holiday homes. Kingston, Jamaica’s biggest rental listing market, is also where young professionals compete for apartments. Without a register, neither government can see the overlap.
Edge: neither.
Three lessons for Jamaica
- Count before you charge. A light, free online register, of the kind both lapsed Bills envisaged, would give Jamaica the first official number for its holiday rental stock. Supporters say it protects guests and the national brand; hosts fear it is the first step towards licensing costs. A register with no fee for small hosts answers both concerns.
- Let the platform collect. Barbados spent seven years chasing small hosts for a levy before moving collection to the booking sites. Jamaica can start there in April 2027, with one clear rate for hosts below the J$15 million threshold. Critics warn that a 15 per cent tax could push guests to rival islands; the Government argues that tourism cannot carry a tax free segment while hotels pay.
- Keep penalties proportionate and phased. Jamaica’s 2025 fines were small by Barbadian standards, yet still stalled the Bill. Barbados’s six month grace period, written warnings to fix problems and seven days’ notice of inspections, alongside the register only track for owner occupied homestays that Jamaica’s own 2025 Bill proposed, would make a revived Jamaican law easier to pass and to enforce.
Barbados shows that taxing holiday rentals is possible; Jamaica now has five months to show it can be done without losing the hosts who made the market.

Visit our YouTube Community ↗