On 14 January 2025 the Auditor General’s Department published a 64 page performance audit titled Managing Government’s Social Benefit Programmes. The headlines that followed were about overlap. The more revealing page is Appendix 10, a plain table of allocations, spending and beneficiaries. It shows that from 2018/19 to 2023/24 the New Social Housing Programme, the Prime Minister’s flagship scheme to build homes for Jamaica’s poorest families, was allocated J$3.45 billion, spent J$1.59 billion and recorded 204 beneficiaries.

Divided across those six years, spending comes to about J$7.8 million for each beneficiary the table records. That is not the cost of a house. The spending includes homes still being built, tenement upgrades and administration, and the Government says delivery has since speeded up. But it is the only published figure we found that ties the programme’s total spending to its output.
Jamaica Homes News read the paper trail behind that table and the audits that came before it. Read together, they describe the same weaknesses recurring under both parties for more than two decades: programmes stacked on programmes, land bought before it was tested, and records too thin to show who was housed and at what cost.
Appendix 10: The Table That Started a Quarrel
The audit, led by Auditor General Pamela Monroe Ellis, reviewed nine non contributory programmes. Six of them pay for some form of housing, and they sit in four different places in Government: Poor Relief, run by the municipal corporations and dating from 1886; the Social Housing Programme, begun in 1969; the Rehabilitation programme of the Ministry of Labour and Social Security, from 1972; the Municipal Social Assistance Programme, from 2017; the Constituency Development Fund in the Office of the Prime Minister, from 2018; and the New Social Housing Programme, the NSHP, from 2019. The two social housing schemes are run at the same time by separate units inside the same ministry. “We found that the various social programmes had similar objectives and overlapping functions,” the report says.
The year by year detail is stark. In 2018/19 the NSHP was allocated J$565 million, spent nothing and housed no one. In 2019/20 it spent J$52.9 million and recorded two beneficiaries. Over the next four years the count was 31, 26, 77 and 68. The audit also found that NSHP applicants, like those of the municipal programme and the Constituency Development Fund, are recommended by political representatives, while the Rehabilitation programme and the original Social Housing Programme take applications directly. The older Social Housing Programme served 333 people in 2023/24 without a single social worker; the ministry told auditors its establishment “does not have a social worker classification.”
A reply from Sommerton, a hearing in Parliament
Three days after the report appeared, Prime Minister Andrew Holness answered it at a house handover in Sommerton, St James. He called the finding baseless and unfair, said the NSHP “has not spent $3.4 billion to date,” and argued that help from more than one agency is not duplication. The Government, he said, has a “very robust beneficiary identification system” that works across PATH, the NSHP, the Constituency Development Fund and local government. On the arithmetic he was right, and the report agrees: J$3.4 billion was the allocation, and Appendix 10 puts actual spending at under half of it.
The Opposition read the same table differently. Kevar Bennett, junior shadow spokesman on housing, said the programme had a mandate of 315 units a year and had produced 286 houses in nine years. On 17 June 2025 Mrs Monroe Ellis defended her work before Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee. “It is a fact that there is duplication, it is a fact that there is overlap,” she said, adding that the finding concerned how the programmes are administered, not whether a person may receive more than one benefit. Arlene Williams, Permanent Secretary in the Ministry of Economic Growth and Job Creation, told the committee that the ministry had begun a strategic review of the two housing units, mapped their processes and revised their operations manuals.
The record is narrower than either side’s rhetoric. The Auditor General never said J$3.4 billion was spent; the Prime Minister did not dispute that six schemes run in parallel, arguing instead that each has its own mandate.
A Law From 1886 and a Bill That Never Arrived
The deepest finding in the 2025 audit is legal. Jamaica still has no single social assistance law. The Poor Relief Act of 1886 remains in force, and efforts to complete the National Assistance Bill meant to replace it “did not progress,” the report says. Of 19 priority actions the Government set itself for a working social protection system, auditors found four achieved and 11 partially achieved. A national register of welfare beneficiaries is listed as not yet achieved, and parish level committees were never set up. The World Bank warned of “multiple uncoordinated programmes” as far back as 2009.
The records explain why coordination is hard. The municipal programme keeps paper files with no unique identifier for beneficiaries at all, and among the housing programmes only Rehabilitation and the NSHP use the Taxpayer Registration Number. Inside the municipal programme, auditors found that J$494.5 million of J$1.53 billion allocated from 2017/18 to 2023/24, or 32 per cent, went to administrative support for councillors. In Kingston and St Andrew, J$63.3 million was disbursed for ten indigent housing projects; four houses were traced at a cost of J$30.3 million, and auditors “couldn’t determine the beneficiaries of the remaining $33 million worth of houses.”
| Programme | Began | Run by | How people get in | Beneficiary ID |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Poor Relief | 1886 | Municipal corporations | Not stated in audit | Beneficiary number |
| Social Housing Programme | 1969 | Economic Growth and Job Creation | Direct application | Name and address |
| Rehabilitation | 1972 | Labour and Social Security | Direct application | TRN |
| Municipal Social Assistance | 2017 | Local Government | Councillor recommendation | None |
| Constituency Development Fund | 2018 | Office of the Prime Minister | MP recommendation | Not stated in audit |
| New Social Housing Programme | 2019 | Economic Growth and Job Creation | Political representative | TRN |
Operation PRIDE and the Angus Commission, 2002
The pattern is older than the NSHP. In May 1994 the Patterson administration launched Operation PRIDE, the Programme for Resettlement and Integrated Development Enterprise, to sell regularised land to low income families through provident societies. In 1998 its projects passed to the National Housing Development Corporation, and in February 2002 a commission under the retired civil servant Erwin Angus was appointed to examine it.
It found ministerial interference, cronyism and poor management, and said corruption was possible. It counted cost overruns of J$928.25 million across 21 sample projects and a further J$113.7 million on five abandoned schemes, well below a leaked consultants’ estimate of more than J$5 billion, and called for a forensic audit of Morant Farms, St Benedicts and Melbrook. Karl Blythe, the minister responsible, resigned from the Cabinet in April 2002 and maintained that there had been no widespread corruption, while accepting some weaknesses in financial management. A later review by Dr Kenneth Rattray disputed the commission’s methods.
The bill outlived the programme. The Auditor General’s 2015 audit of the Housing Agency of Jamaica, the corporation’s successor, recorded a provision to write off J$1 billion that PRIDE beneficiaries had not paid. On 30 September 2026 the Housing Agency’s managing director, Doreen Prendergast, told Parliament’s Public Administration and Appropriations Committee, which was examining the agency’s management of Operation PRIDE communities, that occupants of its schemes owe more than J$2.3 billion. The agency distributed 1,378 titles from 2020 to 2026; others are held back for reasons that include estate matters, disputes and unpaid balances. An amnesty allows balances of up to J$150,000 to be written off case by case. The chairman, Peter Bunting, urged making titling “as easy as possible”; Marisa Dalrymple Philibert, MP for Trelawny Southern, replied that “if you have an obligation, you should try to keep it.”
The Housing Agency Audit, November 2015
The Housing Agency audit, published on 2 November 2015, turned on the Jamaica Economic Housing Project. It was financed by a RMB 487 million concessional loan from the Export Import Bank of China, signed in February 2010 under the Golding administration according to Ministry of Finance records, and built by the Chinese state contractor COMPLANT. Auditors valued the contract at J$8.6 billion, about US$71.2 million. It provided for 937 housing units and 2,517 serviced lots. By August 2015 the full contract sum had been paid, including a J$600 million advance. At that point 70 units were complete and 80 in progress, while 1,980 lots were finished.
No feasibility study was done before the contract was signed, the report says, and the agency did not tell Cabinet of its plans to rescope the project; Cabinet ratified the changes in July 2015, more than two years after the board approved them. At Hills of Boscobel the project was 856 days late by February 2015 and J$519 million over budget, with a projected loss of at least J$318 million. Luana IV in St Elizabeth was cut from 828 solutions to 96. Mount Edgecombe V was abandoned as unsuitable after J$28.66 million had been spent on site preparation and initial works. The agency lost J$539 million in 2014/15, carried accumulated deficits of J$2.2 billion, and owed J$3.4 billion in loans, 92 per cent of it to the National Housing Trust.
The Trust’s Land Purchases, April 2015
Seven months earlier the Auditor General had examined how the National Housing Trust chose land. The best known case is Outameni. In December 2012 the Trust’s board approved buying a J$180 million loan in exchange for the Outameni Experience attraction in Trelawny. A technical report to the board in January 2013 found the property “more suited for recreational/ heritage type facility,” yet the sale was completed on 27 May 2013. The purchase was made under the Simpson Miller administration, which, after public protest in 2014, reconstituted the board, keeping four members. By August 2023 the Trust’s total outlay on the property stood at J$337.2 million and it had not been sold, according to the Jamaica Accountability Meter Portal, which tracks audit compliance.
Outameni was not the largest item. The audit found the Trust had paid J$342.6 million for six parcels that needed rezoning from agricultural use before any homes could be built, and that the planning agency and the Ministry of Agriculture had advised against rezoning two of them. At Enfield Meadows, 166 acres bought for J$105 million, a Mines and Geology inspection six months after purchase found the land could flood to 8.5 metres, with water taking nine months to subside. Separately, the Trust paid J$1.07 billion to the National Housing Development Corporation for land at Point in Hanover and Ironshore in St James. It bought the wrong Ironshore parcel because verification was not completed, both sites were steep, and the Trust told auditors the purpose was to boost the corporation’s liquidity. One public housing body was keeping another solvent through land deals.
The Policy That Took Nearly Four Years to Finish
The Government’s own diagnosis is in the National Housing Policy, tabled in draft form as a Green Paper in 2019. It says Jamaica must build at least 15,000 new homes a year to 2030, against estimated output of about 11,152, and must replace about 2,400 substandard units a year, a net annual shortfall of 6,248. It cites a 2008 study that put one in five Jamaicans in squatter settlements, and census figures showing that 23.6 per cent of households lived in a single room in 2011. It defines social housing and calls for a framework “particularly for the vulnerable and disadvantaged,” but the policy text we read sets no numeric social housing target.
In May 2021 the then housing minister, Pearnel Charles Jr, told the House the final version would be tabled as a White Paper before the end of that fiscal year. The Cabinet Office’s policy register records the National Housing Policy and Implementation Plan as tabled in both Houses on 28 February 2023, almost four years after the draft.
After Melissa, a Seventh Channel
Hurricane Melissa, which struck on 28 October 2025, added another programme. The Fiscal Policy Paper for 2026/27 records J$10 billion for the Restoration of Owner or Occupant Family Shelter programme, ROOFS, a one off housing grant run by the Ministry of Labour and Social Security. Grants are J$75,000 for minor damage, J$200,000 for major damage and J$500,000 for severe damage, with most of the larger grants restricted to repairing or rebuilding the home. On 28 October 2026 the Labour Minister, Pearnel Charles Jr, said more than 49,000 of 106,350 eligible beneficiaries had been served, and Prime Minister Holness announced a further J$9.65 billion. A cash grant, in other words, can reach tens of thousands of households in a year. Yet the Auditor General’s real time audit of hurricane donations, tabled in May 2026, found the familiar gap in records: J$34 million of roofing materials delivered to army locations had no signed receipt, and J$141.1 million of roofing contract commitments lacked confirmed payment documents at 31 March 2026.
The NSHP, meanwhile, has grown. The Government reported 304 completed units in October 2025, 341 units with 901 rooms across 57 constituencies in July 2026, and 358 units last month, against a stated target of 6,000 with no date attached. Mr Holness has said land is the binding constraint, “The availability of land is indeed the constraint preventing the programme from expanding rapidly,” and that 2,000 imported modular units will be placed in the hurricane parishes. In July 2026 the Opposition’s Angela Brown Burke criticised plaques bearing the Prime Minister’s name on NSHP homes. Mr Holness replied that “the indignity is that they didn’t have the house.”
Questions the Record Leaves Open
- Where is the follow up audit of the National Housing Trust? The Auditor General’s annual report for 2025 lists a performance audit of the Trust’s management of investment and development lands at the reporting stage, with completion expected in March 2026. As of mid November 2026 it does not appear among the department’s published performance audits.
- What does an NSHP house cost? No published statement gives a unit cost. The audit’s figures imply about J$7.8 million spent per recorded beneficiary from 2018 to 2024, a number that mixes finished and unfinished work. The one project costed in public, the East Palms complex, was put at over J$62 million for 12 bedrooms.
- How many people has the NSHP housed? Official statements said more than 1,500 people in October 2025, 1,652 in July 2026 and almost 1,300 in October 2026, with no reconciliation published.
- Has the central beneficiary database the Auditor General asked for been built, and does it include the municipal programme, which had no identifier at all?
- Who lives in the J$33 million of Kingston and St Andrew indigent housing that auditors could not trace?
- What became of Enfield Meadows, Unity Farm and the other parcels the Trust could not develop? The last public status update, obtained by the Jamaica Accountability Meter Portal, dates from 2020.
- How many Housing Agency titles are being held back, and how much of the more than J$2.3 billion owed falls under the amnesty?
Documents We Read
- Auditor General’s Department, Managing Government’s Social Benefit Programmes, performance audit, 14 January 2025
- Auditor General’s Department, Performance Audit of the National Housing Trust, April 2015, and the related compliance records of the Jamaica Accountability Meter Portal, last assessed 2018 to 2023
- Auditor General’s Department, Activity Based Audit Report, Housing Agency of Jamaica, November 2015
- Auditor General’s Department, Annual Report, December 2025, and list of published performance audits, November 2026
- Auditor General’s Department, real time compliance audit of Hurricane Melissa donations, tabled May 2026
- Report of the commission of inquiry into Operation PRIDE (Angus Commission), April 2002, as reported at the time
- Ministry of Economic Growth and Job Creation, Draft National Housing Policy, July 2019; Cabinet Office, Government of Jamaica Policy Register, update to 31 December 2024
- Ministry of Finance and the Public Service, Fiscal Policy Paper 2026/27
- Public Accounts Committee hearing, 17 June 2025, and Public Administration and Appropriations Committee hearing, 30 September 2026, as reported
- Office of the Prime Minister and Jamaica Information Service statements on the NSHP, February 2025 to October 2026

Visit our YouTube Community ↗