Jamaica’s proposed shared community legislation has raised fears that homeowners could lose their properties over unpaid maintenance fees. But Dean Jones, Founder and Director of Jamaica Homes, believes the country must confront another uncomfortable reality: communities where a minority of owners pay, neglected properties deteriorate, roads are left unrepaired and unpaid volunteers struggle to hold everything together.

KINGSTON, Jamaica — In some Jamaican housing developments, the gates were promised but never installed. The roads were built but never adopted by the local authority. Vacant lots have become overgrown, abandoned vehicles sit deteriorating in yards, and the residents who contribute towards maintenance are increasingly being asked to carry the financial responsibilities of those who do not.
For years, these problems have existed behind the attractive entrances and carefully marketed promises of modern community living.
Now, proposed legislation could fundamentally change how such developments are managed, how maintenance contributions are collected and what happens when homeowners refuse or fail to pay.
The Registration (Shared Community) Bill, 2026, currently before a parliamentary joint select committee, seeks to establish a formal regulatory framework for residential and commercial communities where property owners share responsibility for common facilities and infrastructure.
Its provisions include mandatory financial contributions, oversight of community corporations, dispute resolution mechanisms and, in specified circumstances, the possibility of recovering unpaid debts through possession proceedings or the sale of property.
The prospect of losing a home over maintenance arrears has understandably attracted concern.
But among those welcoming stronger regulation is Dean Jones, Founder and Director of Jamaica Homes, who argues that the discussion has placed considerable emphasis on the consequences of not paying, without sufficiently examining the consequences for communities when large numbers of property owners contribute nothing.
Drawing on his experience of residential developments in St Mary and St Ann, Jones describes a recurring pattern in which a relatively small group of homeowners pays for services used by an entire community.
He believes the proposed legislation, provided it incorporates appropriate safeguards, could offer a long overdue opportunity to establish accountability.
“Everybody wants to live in a well-maintained community, but the burden cannot continue to fall on the same handful of people. You cannot have a hundred property owners enjoying the benefits of a development while twenty-five are left trying to maintain it,” Jones said.
His argument raises a question that goes beyond maintenance fees.
What happens to a residential development when collective ownership exists, but collective responsibility does not?
The Gate That Never Came
Across sections of Jamaica’s north coast, residential developments have been marketed or originally conceived as gated communities, often with the expectation of controlled access, maintained roads, landscaping and shared security.
Yet some have never fully realised those ambitions.
Jones says he has encountered communities in St Mary and St Ann where the infrastructure and administrative arrangements necessary to operate as intended have never been completed.
In some cases, disputes have developed around roads and access. In others, the central difficulty has been persuading owners to contribute towards the facilities they collectively use.
A security gate requires money to install and maintain. Guards must be paid. Roads need repairs. Drainage channels must be cleared. Grass and vegetation cannot simply be allowed to overwhelm communal areas.
Even when residents agree that improvements are necessary, financing them can become a source of prolonged disagreement.
Jones recalls communities where disputes have become so entrenched that residents have found themselves divided over whether access should be restricted, how roads should be used and who should pay for the work required.
In one situation, he was nearly drawn into a community dispute as an informal mediator.
These experiences have convinced him that the absence of clear legal structures can leave homeowners trapped in disagreements that voluntary associations struggle to resolve.
The problem is not always a lack of willingness to improve a community.
Sometimes it is the absence of an effective mechanism for turning collective decisions into collective action.
When Twenty-Five Pay for a Hundred
Consider a community comprising 100 property owners, each expected to contribute J$5,000 annually towards shared maintenance.
If every owner pays, the association collects J$500,000.
If only 25 per cent contribute, the amount collected falls to J$125,000.
That leaves a shortfall of J$375,000 against the expected contribution.
In a development with 200 property owners, the same annual contribution would generate J$1 million with full participation. At a 25 per cent collection rate, the association receives only J$250,000.
The remaining J$750,000 never arrives.
These are illustrative calculations, not verified collection figures for a particular Jamaican development.
Yet Jones says low participation is a practical reality he has encountered in community management.
Even modest annual dues become difficult to administer when the majority of property owners do not contribute.
And J$5,000 per year is a relatively small amount when measured against the actual costs of maintaining roads, security systems, drainage and other infrastructure.
The arithmetic becomes particularly challenging where a community requires staffed security.
A guard positioned at an entrance around the clock requires sufficient staffing to cover shifts, rest periods, leave and other employment obligations.
A larger development with multiple entrances faces even greater expenditure.
Add lighting, maintenance, repairs and administrative costs, and a contribution system dependent on voluntary goodwill can become financially unsustainable.
The residents who pay may see little improvement, while those who refuse continue using the shared facilities.
Over time, that imbalance can create resentment, undermine community relationships and discourage even conscientious owners from contributing.
A functioning system eventually becomes a failing one.
The Overseas Owner Problem
Another difficulty identified by Jones concerns properties whose owners live overseas.
Across Jamaica, residential lots and houses are owned by members of the diaspora who may visit infrequently or hold land for future retirement, family use or investment.
Many maintain their properties responsibly.
Others, however, allow land to become overgrown or buildings to deteriorate.
Jones says he has encountered communities where absent owners leave neighbouring residents to deal with vegetation, boundary concerns and the visual impact of neglected properties.
He has personally undertaken maintenance around land that does not belong to him.
For the conscientious neighbour, the choice can become frustratingly simple: clear the vegetation or live beside it.
The financial and physical burden is transferred informally to somebody who has no ownership interest in the neglected property.
“I have found myself maintaining land that is not mine because somebody else has allowed it to become a problem. That cannot be the foundation of community management. Ownership brings rights, but it must also bring responsibility,” Jones said.
The distinction between ownership and occupation matters.
A person does not cease to benefit from maintained community infrastructure simply because they reside in another country.
Roads remain available. Drainage continues protecting properties. Common areas still require maintenance.
The proposed legislation seeks to place financial obligations on proprietors within qualifying shared communities, rather than relying solely on whether they occupy their properties.
However, there is an important legal distinction.
The Bill’s provisions concerning common property and maintenance contributions do not automatically create a general power to force every landowner in Jamaica to clear an overgrown private lot, remove abandoned vehicles or renovate a deteriorating house.
Such matters may also involve applicable municipal laws, public health requirements, planning controls, property rights and enforceable community bylaws.
The legislation could strengthen governance in qualifying communities, but its precise scope and enforcement powers will depend on the final provisions enacted.
That distinction is essential if residents are to understand what the new framework can realistically achieve.
The Roads Nobody Owns Up To
Perhaps one of the most difficult issues concerns roads.
In some housing developments, roads are constructed by developers but are not subsequently taken over for maintenance by the relevant public authority.
Until responsibility is formally transferred, those roads may remain private infrastructure, with maintenance obligations determined by the legal arrangements governing the development.
Residents can discover that a road they assumed would be maintained through public resources is instead their collective financial responsibility.
The consequences become particularly apparent when potholes develop, drains fail or resurfacing becomes necessary.
Patching sections of roadway may provide temporary relief, but major repairs can involve substantial expenditure.
For a community association collecting only a fraction of its expected contributions, even basic maintenance can become difficult.
Jones says he has witnessed communities attempting repeated small repairs because they lack the funds to carry out comprehensive work.
He has also encountered disputes over roads and access routes that residents say have been blocked or absorbed into adjoining private properties.
Such situations can become legally complex, particularly where ownership, rights of way or the original subdivision arrangements are disputed.
A shared community corporation cannot simply reclaim land or demolish an obstruction because residents believe a road has been unlawfully occupied.
Those matters require proper examination of registered titles, survey plans, access rights and the applicable legal processes.
Nevertheless, a properly constituted community corporation may be better equipped to maintain records, obtain professional advice and pursue lawful remedies than an informal association operating without sufficient authority or resources.
The difference could be significant.
Without clear ownership and governance arrangements, disputes can continue for years while the physical condition of the development deteriorates.
The Unpaid Job Nobody Wants
Behind many Jamaican community associations is another overlooked reality.
The work is frequently undertaken by residents who receive no salary.
A president or committee member may already have full time employment, family commitments and personal financial obligations.
Yet the role can involve collecting dues, arranging contractors, monitoring security, responding to complaints, negotiating disputes, managing accounts and repeatedly pursuing owners who have failed to pay.
The position can become an unpaid second occupation.
Jones believes this dependence on goodwill is one reason community governance can become unstable.
The same small group of individuals may carry the administrative responsibility for years, sometimes facing criticism from residents who have contributed neither money nor time.
When disagreements become personal, volunteers can resign, leaving the community without effective leadership.
The proposed legislation would create formal community corporations, with defined responsibilities for managing shared infrastructure, collecting contributions and maintaining financial records.
Oversight would fall to the Real Estate Board, with arrangements for regulatory supervision and dispute resolution.
For Jones, this could represent an important shift from informal arrangements towards professional accountability.
But establishing a corporation does not eliminate the need for capable management.
Community officers would still require training, appropriate financial controls, transparent procurement procedures and meaningful participation by property owners.
A legal framework may create authority.
It cannot create good judgment automatically.
Should a Home Be Sold Over Fees?
The most controversial aspect of the Bill concerns enforcement.
The proposed legislation contains 60 sections and three schedules. Sections 23 to 31 address contributions and recovery of money, while sections 32 to 40 deal with possession and powers of sale.
One proposed procedure would allow a community corporation to seek a court order for possession in particular circumstances involving contributions outstanding for more than 60 days, unsuccessful efforts to locate the owner and an intention to rent the property to recover the debt.
Other provisions contemplate a power of sale, subject to statutory procedures, authorisation and valuation requirements.
These measures would not allow a community association automatically to seize or sell a house whenever a homeowner misses a payment.
Nor has the legislation become law.
Nevertheless, the powers under consideration are serious.
For Jones, the existence of enforceable obligations is not inherently objectionable.
He believes accountability is necessary where owners repeatedly decline to contribute towards expenses that benefit their properties.
But there must be a distinction between deliberate nonpayment and genuine financial difficulty.
A pensioner struggling with increased contributions is not necessarily in the same position as an investor who owns several properties and simply refuses to respond to demands for payment.
An owner disputing an incorrect charge should not automatically be treated as somebody intentionally avoiding obligations.
A proportionate enforcement system should provide clear notices, opportunities to challenge charges, reasonable repayment arrangements and independent oversight before the most severe remedies are considered.
The possibility of losing a home must remain a matter of exceptional seriousness.
Jones’s position is that stronger enforcement and stronger homeowner protection can coexist.
The two are not mutually exclusive.
Standards Must Apply to Everyone
The proposed legislation is also forcing a wider conversation about residential standards.
Jones argues that communities cannot maintain their long term attractiveness if property owners are permitted to disregard the condition of their homes and surrounding land.
He points to neglected houses, discarded materials, abandoned vehicles and vacant properties that become eyesores for neighbouring residents.
A badly maintained property may affect more than appearances.
Overgrown land can create pest and drainage problems. Abandoned vehicles may attract illegal dumping. Deteriorating buildings can raise safety concerns.
Where such conditions persist, the consequences are often experienced most directly by neighbouring households.
But the legal responsibility for dealing with these problems must be carefully distinguished from the collection of maintenance contributions.
Shared community bylaws may be capable of addressing certain standards where lawfully authorised, but the proposed Act should not be represented as a universal solution to every neglected property.
There must also be safeguards against arbitrary rules, discriminatory enforcement or unreasonable demands that owners spend money on cosmetic improvements they cannot afford.
The objective should be the proper maintenance of safe, healthy and functional communities, rather than imposing uniform standards of wealth or appearance.
There is a considerable difference between requiring somebody to remove a genuine hazard and demanding that every garden look like a landscaped resort.
Good regulation must recognise that distinction.
Neglect and the Risk of Occupation
Jones also believes that long term neglect can expose owners to additional property risks.
Vacant land and abandoned buildings may attract unlawful occupation, dumping or disputes over boundaries and access.
These problems are particularly relevant where owners live overseas and have limited arrangements for inspecting or maintaining their properties.
However, the legal position requires care.
Neglect alone does not transfer ownership of land to another person.
Questions involving squatting, adverse possession, trespass or disputed boundaries are governed by separate legal principles, and the outcome depends on the facts and applicable law.
The proposed shared community legislation does not abolish those legal requirements.
What stronger community governance may achieve is earlier identification of neglected properties, more reliable contact with absent owners and better record keeping.
That could help prevent some problems from escalating.
The emphasis should be on responsible ownership and early intervention rather than suggesting that a community corporation would automatically acquire powers to remove occupiers or resolve ownership disputes.
Developers Must Answer Too
Homeowners are not the only parties whose responsibilities deserve scrutiny.
The proposed legislation also raises important questions about developers who establish residential communities and subsequently transfer their management to purchasers.
Some developments are marketed with the promise of roads, gates, drainage systems, lighting and other communal facilities.
But what happens if those facilities are incomplete when residents begin taking responsibility?
What happens when shared land remains registered in the developer’s name, or when inadequate infrastructure creates expensive repair obligations?
The proposed framework seeks more formal arrangements for the ownership and management of common property, including governance and maintenance planning.
Developers would face requirements concerning community registration and the arrangements necessary for future management.
These provisions could help prevent situations in which residents inherit responsibilities without appropriate legal structures or financial information.
But strong enforcement against homeowners must be matched by strong accountability for developers.
Residents should not be expected to fund the correction of construction defects or incomplete infrastructure without appropriate legal protections and avenues for redress.
A functioning community begins with good development practice.
It cannot be created solely by compelling residents to pay fees after the houses have been sold.
Who Protects the Homeowner?
The Bill’s insurance provisions have also attracted parliamentary scrutiny.
Clause 15 proposes insurance obligations relating to common property and building elements, including protection against specified risks such as fire, earthquakes and hurricanes, unless owners unanimously decide otherwise.
The intention is to reduce the financial vulnerability of communities where multiple property owners rely on shared infrastructure.
But compulsory insurance can increase maintenance contributions.
Government Senator Sherene Golding Campbell has questioned how the requirements might affect residents already facing financial pressure.
Lawmakers have also considered what remedies should be available when a community corporation fails to maintain infrastructure properly and homeowners suffer losses.
These issues go directly to fairness.
If owners are legally compelled to contribute, they must have meaningful rights to inspect accounts, question expenditure, challenge mismanagement and pursue remedies when the corporation fails to perform its duties.
A corporation should not enjoy strong powers against homeowners while remaining weakly accountable to them.
Nor should unpaid contributions become a convenient way to overlook poor governance.
Jones’s support for stronger regulation rests on the expectation that standards and accountability must apply in both directions.
A Law Jamaica Needs to Get Right
The parliamentary committee examining the legislation has agreed to seek public submissions, facilitate physical and online engagement and visit an existing shared community.
That process matters.
The experiences of residents in St Mary, St Ann, Kingston, St Catherine and elsewhere may differ considerably.
Some developments have professional management and relatively high compliance with maintenance obligations.
Others are older communities with voluntary associations, contested infrastructure arrangements and limited financial resources.
A single regulatory framework will need to account for those differences without creating unnecessary complexity.
It will also need to clarify which existing developments qualify as shared communities, what transitional arrangements apply and how owners will be informed of their obligations.
Not every neighbourhood association should automatically be treated as a statutory community corporation.
And not every road, boundary dispute or neglected lot will fall within the proposed law’s powers.
But the underlying need for clearer management and accountability is difficult to dismiss.
For too long, some Jamaican communities have depended on goodwill, voluntary contributions and the determination of a small number of residents to perform functions that require substantial funding and ongoing administration.
When that goodwill is exhausted, everybody pays a price.
The roads deteriorate. Security arrangements fail. Communal land becomes neglected. Property values may suffer.
And the individuals who attempted to keep the development functioning are left wondering why responsibility was never shared more fairly.
The Right to Own. The Duty to Maintain.
For Jones, the debate should not be reduced to whether community corporations should have the power to pursue unpaid maintenance fees.
The larger issue is whether Jamaica is prepared to establish a culture of responsibility within the residential developments it continues to build.
Property ownership is an important right.
But in a shared community, the decisions of one owner can affect dozens or hundreds of others.
A household that maintains its property, contributes towards common infrastructure and participates in community decisions should not be perpetually disadvantaged because neighbouring owners decline to do the same.
Equally, residents should not face disproportionate financial penalties, arbitrary charges or the loss of their homes without proper legal protection.
The challenge is to balance both interests.
Done properly, the Registration (Shared Community) Bill could strengthen property rights rather than weaken them, by ensuring that the infrastructure supporting those properties is maintained and the organisations responsible for managing it are accountable.
Done poorly, it could introduce new financial pressures and legal disputes into communities already struggling with affordability.
That is why the detail matters.
Jones sees the proposed legislation as a positive development, not because he believes homeowners should be punished, but because he has seen what happens when communities cannot organise, collect sufficient contributions or enforce reasonable standards.
The problem is not confined to developments with swimming pools and expensive security gates.
It can be found wherever property owners share responsibilities but lack the willingness or effective structures to meet them.
The gate that was never installed, the road that remains broken, the vacant lot that nobody clears and the volunteer committee member chasing unpaid dues are all expressions of the same underlying difficulty.
A community cannot function indefinitely when responsibility is voluntary for some but unavoidable for others.
Jamaica must therefore decide not simply how much authority its community corporations should possess, but what standards of fairness, transparency and accountability must accompany that authority.
The proposed legislation offers an opportunity to address problems that have been left unresolved for years.
For ordinary homeowners, that could mean a better maintained environment, more predictable community management and stronger protection for the value of their property.
But it must also mean clear rights, affordable obligations and safeguards against excessive enforcement.
Owning a house should provide security.
Living in a shared community should provide collective benefit.
Neither objective should come at the expense of the other.
The real test of this legislation will not be how easily a community corporation can pursue a homeowner who fails to pay.
It will be whether the law creates communities in which everybody understands their responsibilities, everybody has a voice, and nobody is left carrying an unfair share of the burden.

Visit our YouTube Community ↗