Restoring Negril’s Famous Beach Would Cost $54 Million. A Critic Says That’s Not Enough

• Negril loses roughly one to two metres of beach a year
• A restoration study put the cost at US$54 million
• An environmentalist says the town has exceeded its carrying capacity
• She warns the same erosion will simply return if root causes go unaddressed

Negril’s Seven Mile Beach has been eroding at a rate of one to two metres a year, according to a year-long study by coastal engineering firm Smith Warner, which put the cost of a full restoration programme at roughly US$54 million. Jamaica Environment Trust CEO Diana McCaulay welcomed the study’s findings while warning that money spent on physical restoration alone would not fix the underlying problem.

McCaulay’s core argument is that Negril has surpassed its own carrying capacity, and that a list of long-standing environmental issues, poor water quality, seagrass bed removal, agricultural and urban runoff, has never actually been addressed even as beach nourishment gets proposed as the visible fix. If you don’t address all the problems that were listed as factors of beach erosion in the first place, she said, the beach will erode just like the previous one, a warning that a restored beach without underlying environmental correction is simply a temporary reset rather than a real solution.

She placed direct blame on the regulatory system rather than only on natural or climate factors: improper planning and poor regulation by the responsible enforcement agencies have contributed to the erosion, she said, describing the regulatory framework for Jamaica’s environmental laws as appalling, and specifically noting hotel construction permits had been granted without Negril’s carrying capacity ever being properly considered first.

The Smith Warner study’s own findings back up McCaulay’s multi-cause framing: storms, unplanned seagrass removal, sea level rise, poor water quality, tourism pressure, overfishing, agricultural runoff and coral die-off were all identified as contributing factors, with coral reef health and fish populations already in measurable decline and natural sand production running at just 200 to 2,000 cubic metres annually, far below what would be needed to naturally replace what the beach loses each year. A $54 million restoration figure addresses the visible symptom; McCaulay’s warning is that without also fixing the list of causes behind it, Negril will simply be paying to restore the same beach again within a matter of years.

Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomesnews Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com