Publication Date: October 3, 2013 | Coverage Period: September 3 – October 2, 2013 | Category: Monthly Review
Month in Brief
- NHT loan limits of J$4.5 million face renewed criticism as construction costs continue to climb.
- JLP opposition intensifies attacks on NHT Consolidated Fund transfer ahead of second IMF review.
- Commercial mortgage originations remain depressed; banks report continued softness in housing demand.
- Exchange rate nudges toward J$107 per US dollar; import cost pressures rise for building materials.
- GDP growth projected at under 1% for fiscal year; construction sector among hardest hit.
- NHT scheme completions in St Catherine continue at reduced but steady pace.
Housing Market Overview
September 2013 crystallised what has become the defining characteristic of Jamaica’s housing market under the IMF Extended Fund Facility: a structural squeeze in which high commercial financing costs, constrained NHT output and stagnant real incomes combine to suppress transaction activity across all but the most insulated market segments.
Commercial banks continue to report low mortgage origination volumes. The prevailing rate environment — with most institutions pricing mortgage products between 11 and 14 per cent per annum — is simply prohibitive for the majority of working Jamaicans. Monthly debt service obligations on a J$10 million mortgage at 13 per cent over 25 years represent a burden that few households earning median incomes can sustain, particularly when those incomes have been frozen or reduced in real terms.
The NHT, with its dramatically lower rates, remains the institution around which the market pivots. But the Trust’s delivery capacity is under sustained pressure. The statutory transfer to the Consolidated Fund has reduced the resources available for scheme construction and loan disbursement, and the pace of housing solution delivery is running below what the Trust’s waiting lists would require to make a meaningful dent in Jamaica’s estimated housing deficit of 100,000 to 120,000 units.
Government Policy
The government of Prime Minister Portia Simpson Miller continues to defend the NHT transfer framework while simultaneously seeking to project a credible commitment to housing delivery. The political tension is palpable. The EFF’s conditionality requires fiscal consolidation that constrains public housing investment; the administration’s political base expects tangible progress on affordable homeownership.
Officials have been at pains to point out that the IMF programme is not solely about austerity, but about creating the conditions — lower interest rates, stable inflation, restored creditworthiness — under which the housing market can eventually recover. The argument is credible as economic logic but difficult to communicate to NHT contributors who are watching the annual transfer proceed while their scheme applications sit on waiting lists.
NHT Loan Limits Debate
The adequacy of NHT loan limits has re-emerged as a focal point of housing sector advocacy in September. With limits set at approximately J$4.5 million, the Trust is increasingly out of step with actual construction costs, which have risen with both inflation and the depreciation of the Jamaican dollar — the latter raising the cost of imported construction materials significantly.
Developers and housing advocates have renewed calls for an upward revision, arguing that unchanged loan limits in an inflationary environment represent a real-terms reduction in the Trust’s value to contributors. The NHT has not publicly committed to a near-term adjustment. Any increase in loan limits, while welcome for contributors, would also place additional demands on the Trust’s capital at a time when the Consolidated Fund transfer is already constraining its resources.
Construction Sector
The construction sector experienced no material improvement in September. Building permit applications in the Kingston Metropolitan Area remain at levels consistent with the depressed environment of recent months. Contractors in the residential segment report that project pipelines for the fourth quarter of 2013 are thin, with few new private starts expected.
NHT scheme construction in St Catherine is the primary source of activity in the affordable segment. The Trust’s contractor management processes are functioning, but the scale of output remains modest relative to demand. Industry participants note that for every unit the NHT completes, multiple qualified contributors remain on waiting lists without access to the scheme housing they have been contributing toward for years.
Major Developments
There has been continued engagement between the Ministry of Housing and international development partners on social housing and community upgrading initiatives. Whilst detailed announcements have been limited, the IDB and other multilateral institutions remain engaged with Jamaica’s social housing agenda as part of the broader IMF programme support framework. Concessional financing for housing-adjacent infrastructure — water, roads, utilities in scheme areas — represents a potential complement to the NHT’s own capital programme.
Infrastructure
The National Water Commission has been under renewed scrutiny over service reliability in peri-urban development areas. NWC water supply constraints in communities adjacent to NHT scheme sites in St Catherine have created practical difficulties for both construction and occupancy. The NWC’s own capital investment programme is constrained by fiscal conditions similar to those affecting the housing sector, creating a compounding effect on residential development timelines.
Investment Climate
The investment climate across Jamaica’s broader economy has been incrementally improving as the IMF programme demonstrates its durability. Foreign exchange reserves have been stabilising, the current account deficit is narrowing, and the government has managed its fiscal position broadly in line with programme targets. These macro improvements create the foundation for eventual improvement in private sector investment, including in residential development.
For property investors, the current market offers opportunities in specific niches. The north coast luxury and retirement market continues to offer value relative to comparable Caribbean destinations. Investors with patient capital and access to hard currency are finding selective opportunities among vendors motivated to sell in a sluggish market.
Diaspora and Remittance Activity
Remittance flows in September remained consistent with the US$1.9–2.0 billion annual run rate. The continued strength of remittances — despite global economic headwinds — reflects the deep structural ties between Jamaica and its diaspora communities. For the housing sector, remittances serve as both a direct source of housing investment capital and an indirect prop to household consumption that underpins the broader economy.
Affordability
Affordability conditions in October are marginally worse than at the start of the year, when measured in real terms. Inflation has eroded the purchasing power of nominal incomes, NHT loan limits have not kept pace with construction cost inflation, and commercial rates remain elevated. The BOJ’s nascent easing cycle offers a medium-term pathway to improvement, but the near-term picture for housing affordability is one of continued strain.
Regional Context
Jamaica is navigating its housing challenge within a Caribbean context in which access to affordable finance is a near-universal constraint. The gap between the rates available through state housing institutions and the commercial rate environment is a feature of most Caribbean housing markets, though Jamaica’s gap — driven by the unique combination of NHT rates and commercial bank pricing — is particularly marked. Regional peers are watching Jamaica’s IMF programme closely, as it represents a potential model for fiscal adjustment in small island developing states.
Looking Ahead
November will bring the approach of the second IMF quarterly review, with the government needing to demonstrate continued adherence to primary surplus targets and the public sector wage freeze. The housing sector’s trajectory over the next quarter will be heavily influenced by the programme’s performance. Any slippage would likely trigger a tightening of financial conditions that would be particularly damaging to the already-stressed mortgage market. Conversely, a clean second review would strengthen the foundation for the gradual rate easing that the housing sector urgently needs.
Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomesnews Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com
Visit our YouTube Community ↗