A Reader Asked If They Could Deduct a Gardener’s Pay From Their Own Strata Fee. Here’s the Legal Answer

• 85% of residents in one strata complex weren’t paying fees
• A paying resident asked about hiring and deducting for a gardener
• Land surveyor Craig Francis answered in his Gleaner column
• The gap between individual initiative and collective governance was the real issue

A reader wrote to land surveyor Craig Francis’s Gleaner column describing a strata complex where the management committee was struggling to collect fees, with 85 percent of residents behind on payment and the resulting maintenance decline visible across the property, despite the reader’s own account being fully paid up. Her specific question: could she legally hire a gardener herself and deduct the cost from her own monthly maintenance fee, with a receipt sent to the management committee as proof?

The question captures a genuine tension this publication has documented repeatedly in Jamaican strata disputes: an individual owner who has met every obligation watching common-area upkeep deteriorate anyway, because the collective mechanism meant to fund it has broken down, and looking for some unilateral fix within their own control rather than waiting on a management committee that, as this publication has separately reported, has historically been reluctant to actually pursue delinquent neighbours through the courts.

The practical difficulty with a self-help deduction, whatever the legal answer to the specific question, is structural rather than personal: strata fees fund shared obligations, common-area maintenance, utilities, insurance, collectively rather than individually, and a single owner unilaterally redirecting her own contribution toward one specific task, however reasonable, sidesteps rather than solves the underlying 85 percent non-payment rate driving the broader decline.

The case sits alongside the historical pattern this publication has traced through Jamaica’s strata governance, from the 1969 Act’s collapse into widespread dormancy through to more recent disputes at properties like Sunshine Village in Negril: individual owners with genuinely limited options when a collective governance structure fails, whether that failure stems from director reluctance to sue, unexplained missing funds, or, in this reader’s case, simple non-payment at a rate that has already visibly degraded the property she is paying in full to maintain.

Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomesnews Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com