Jamaica Real Estate Roundup — Q4 2020: The Resilience No One Forecast

• BOJ holds at 0.50% — the emergency floor supporting the economic recovery.
• Property market closes 2020 with demand significantly above mid-year fears.
• Vaccine approvals in December open the path toward 2021 tourism recovery.
• Diaspora capital and low rates combining to fuel early residential surge.
• Tourism limited but operational; winter 2020/21 arrivals cautiously resuming.

When the COVID-19 pandemic arrived in Jamaica in March 2020 and the government closed the island’s borders to international travellers, the predictions for the property market ranged from cautious to catastrophic. A sector whose demand was, in conventional analysis, tightly linked to the employment income and foreign exchange flows generated by the tourism industry was expected to contract alongside that industry. Transactions would slow. Prices would come under pressure. Developers would pause. The housing market would wait, like so much of the economy, for the pandemic to pass.

The final quarter of 2020 is the clearest evidence available that those predictions were, in their most important dimension, wrong. The residential property market that closed the year was not the contracted, hesitant market the pessimistic forecasts had projected. It was a market showing signs of demand strength that, by December 2020, had begun to attract the attention and the capital of buyers who had been waiting for conditions to clarify — and had found, in the clarity of the pandemic’s economic and psychological effects, a set of motivations for property purchase that the pre-pandemic analysts had not modelled.

The Bank of Jamaica maintained the overnight policy rate at 0.50 per cent through the entire fourth quarter, holding the emergency floor that the Monetary Policy Committee had established during the pandemic’s acute phase to support the economic recovery. Inflation remained within the four-to-six per cent target range through the quarter, giving the BOJ no immediate inflation-management reason to disturb the accommodative stance. The GDP data confirmed that the economy had contracted significantly through 2020 — the tourism sector’s near-complete shutdown had ensured that — but the pace of contraction was moderating in Q4 as limited tourism activity resumed and the domestic economy’s service sectors stabilised. The rate floor, and the low commercial lending rates it supported, were among the most significant structural inputs to the property market’s surprising Q4 performance.

The Vaccine Turning Point

The most significant news event of Q4 2020, for Jamaica’s medium-term economic outlook and its tourism-dependent property sub-markets, was the succession of vaccine approvals that arrived in November and December. Pfizer-BioNTech’s COVID-19 vaccine received emergency use authorisation from the United States Food and Drug Administration on December 11, followed by Moderna’s authorisation on December 18. The United Kingdom had granted emergency authorisation to the Pfizer vaccine even earlier, on December 2. These approvals, and the mass vaccination rollout programmes they initiated in Jamaica’s primary tourism source markets, represented the clearest signal yet that the path toward a restoration of international travel was not merely theoretical but was now entering the practical implementation phase.

For the property market, the vaccine news had both direct and indirect effects. The direct effect was on sentiment: buyers, investors and developers who had been holding decisions pending greater clarity on the pandemic’s timeline were now operating with a visible horizon, even if the precise pace of vaccination rollout and travel protocol liberalisation was uncertain. The indirect effect was on the resort property sub-markets, whose medium-term fundamentals were directly linked to the return of tourism arrivals to pre-pandemic levels. Properties in Montego Bay, Negril and the other resort destinations that had been softening through the tourism shutdown began to attract renewed interest from buyers whose investment horizon extended beyond the pandemic’s acute phase.

Tourism: Limited but Alive

Jamaica had reopened its borders to international leisure visitors on June 15, 2020, earlier than most of its Caribbean competitors, under a COVID-19 corridor system that confined arriving visitors to resort zones and subjected them to health protocols including testing and monitoring. The October-December 2020 period was the first full quarter in which this system had operated through the winter season — traditionally Jamaica’s strongest tourism months — and the results, while far below pre-pandemic 2019 comparables, were more encouraging than the pessimistic mid-2020 projections had anticipated.

Hotel occupancy rates in the resort areas through Q4 2020 were operating at reduced levels — the combination of capacity constraints from health protocols, the hesitation of international travellers facing testing requirements and quarantine uncertainty, and the absence of the cruise passenger segment that had historically contributed significantly to the Falmouth and Kingston visitor count — but the major all-inclusive resort operators were reporting that the bubble approach was maintaining sufficient occupancy to support continued operations. The J/MMB corridor between Jamaica and source markets was establishing the island’s reputation as a responsible reopener, a credential that tourism marketers expected to translate into booking confidence as vaccination rollouts proceeded in 2021.

Residential Market: The Demand That Arrived

The residential market’s Q4 2020 performance was, by the assessment of the island’s estate agents and property practitioners, significantly stronger than what mid-year conditions had suggested was likely. The transactions that were completing in October, November and December 2020 included a substantial cohort of purchases that had been initiated earlier in the pandemic period, as buyers whose decisions had been accelerated — not deferred — by the COVID-19 experience worked through the legal and financing processes necessary to complete their purchases. The National Land Agency’s title registration queue, which had built during the period when the pandemic’s administrative disruptions had slowed conveyancing processes, was clearing in Q4, and the volume of completions that resulted gave the quarter’s data a strength that surprised observers who had been tracking conditions at the market’s active sales end.

The character of the demand was revealing. A disproportionate share of the Q4 2020 purchase activity was coming from two buyer categories that had not historically been as dominant in the island’s residential market: diaspora purchasers transacting remotely through agents and legal representatives in Jamaica, and domestic buyers whose pandemic experience had elevated the priority of homeownership in their personal financial planning. Both categories were showing a willingness to transact at price points that, in the pre-pandemic market of 2019, had been the subject of negotiation and extended marketing periods. In the Q4 2020 market, the combination of constrained supply — the pipeline of new strata completions had been delayed by the pandemic’s construction disruptions — and accumulated demand was producing a market in which sellers held more of the pricing leverage than they had in 2019.

Developer Sentiment: Cautious Optimism Returns

The development community’s response to Q4’s improving market signals was one of cautious optimism — a willingness to resume or accelerate projects that had been held pending greater demand clarity, tempered by the continued uncertainty about the pace of the broader economic recovery and the specific risks that an ongoing pandemic environment created for project timelines and construction costs. The supply chain disruptions that had characterised the global economy through 2020 — shipping delays, materials shortages, elevated import costs — were affecting construction budgets and timelines in ways that required careful financial management. But the demand signals were sufficiently strong that developers who had deferred commencement decisions were, by Q4 2020, moving back toward activation.

The strata development pipeline — the segment that would come to dominate the boom of 2021 — was being re-energised by the market signals the quarter was generating. Developers who had been tracking pre-sales enquiry volumes through the pandemic period were seeing those enquiries convert to committed reservations at a pace that justified moving from planning to launch. The structural economics of strata development — the Kingston metropolitan area’s limited land supply, the chronic shortage of quality multi-family residential product at accessible price points, and the growing population of would-be buyers whose incomes qualified them for the NHT and lower-commercial-mortgage market — had not changed. The pandemic had, if anything, intensified the demand-side dynamics while briefly constraining the supply response, and the Q4 signals were suggesting that the supply was about to begin catching up.

NHT and the Affordable Market

The National Housing Trust’s Q4 2020 activity reflected the market’s recovery from the disruption of the pandemic’s acute phase. Mortgage approvals and mortgage disbursements had been affected through the second and third quarters by the NHT’s own operational adjustments to pandemic conditions and by the broader economic uncertainty that had made some contributors hesitate before committing to a major long-term financial obligation. By Q4, those hesitations were resolving in the direction of action: the rate environment was supportive, the economic signals were improving, and the pandemic’s long duration had clarified for many contributors that waiting for a return to pre-pandemic normality was itself a form of indefinite deferral of homeownership that they were not prepared to accept.

Entering 2021: The Year of Recovery

The fourth quarter of 2020 ends with Jamaica’s property market in a position that few of the analysts who were writing their 2020 forecasts in January of that year would have predicted. The market has not contracted in the way that the tourism sector’s collapse would, in a conventional model, have implied. Instead, it has demonstrated the resilience of a sector whose demand drivers are structural and long-term — the housing deficit, the demographic aspiration, the diaspora connection — and whose exposure to the pandemic’s specific disruptions was moderated by the low rate environment and the demand-side psychology that the pandemic itself had reshaped.

The year 2021 opens with vaccine approvals in the key source markets promising a path toward tourism recovery, an accommodative monetary policy providing the financing conditions that have proven more stimulative for residential demand than the 2020 forecasters anticipated, and a development community that has processed the pandemic’s disruptions and is preparing for the supply response to a demand surge that is already underway. The Quarterly Jamaica Real Estate Roundup enters 2021 expecting this to be a recovery year. The first quarter’s data will begin to reveal whether that expectation is correct — and, if so, whether the recovery is the modest restoration of pre-pandemic norms that the cautious forecasters project, or something more consequential.

Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomesnews Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com