Dear Editor,
I understand why a successful Jamaican in Canada, Britain or the United States might feel disappointed after returning home and struggling to secure work at the level they once held. But there is another voice missing from the discussion: the professional who never left.
Some of us have spent twenty years earning qualifications, taking additional training, managing teams and carrying organisations through difficult periods. We have remained in Jamaica, paid our taxes here, raised families here and tried to build careers in an economy where a senior vacancy can attract intense competition.

We, too, know what it feels like to send applications into silence. We, too, have wondered whether promotion depended on performance or proximity to the right people. We, too, have met capable colleagues who reached a ceiling they could not explain.
When a returning executive says Jamaica has no opportunities, I hear the frustration. But I also want to ask: no opportunities for whom? And what of the people who have confronted those limitations all their working lives?
It would be a mistake to frame this debate as local professionals versus the diaspora. Neither group benefits from an appointment system that lacks transparency or from a small economy that cannot make effective use of its talent.
A foreign title should not guarantee a Jamaican leadership position. Equally, having spent an entire career within one local institution should not automatically make someone the strongest candidate. What matters is whether the person can do the job.
Jamaica needs leaders who understand its laws, communities, infrastructure, institutions and financial realities. Some of that knowledge is acquired here. Some is strengthened by working abroad. The best teams can bring those experiences together.
The conversation should therefore move beyond whether people overseas ought to return. We should ask why qualified people, wherever they are based, can struggle to see a clear route into positions of responsibility.
Are vacancies advertised widely and for long enough? Are the criteria understandable? Is there a credible selection process? Are internal candidates assessed fairly? Are applicants told why they were unsuccessful? Do employers invest in developing the talent already on their payroll?
Those questions matter more than anyone’s passport stamps.
There is a broader economic reality too. A country cannot offer unlimited senior posts. The number of executives it can employ depends on the size and productivity of its organisations, the strength of its businesses and the public resources available. We should not confuse every unsuccessful application with discrimination or nepotism.
But scarcity makes the integrity of each decision more important. When jobs are few, confidence in fair selection is essential.
I would welcome a returning Jamaican professional who can improve a hospital, modernise a ministry, strengthen a bank or help a business grow. I would expect that person to respect the expertise of the Jamaicans already doing the work. In return, local institutions should be prepared to consider what that professional brings without defensiveness or favouritism.
Both sides should reject a culture in which opportunities appear reserved for insiders. That culture, wherever it exists, harms the country more than it harms any single applicant.
If Jamaica wants to keep young talent, attract experienced returnees and reward those who stayed, the answer is not another invitation to come home. It is a credible commitment to fairness at work.
We do not need separate doors for local professionals and returning residents.
We need one door that opens on merit.
Yours faithfully,
A Jamaica-Based Professional

Visit our YouTube Community ↗