Dear Editor,
I am going to say something that may upset a few people, particularly those who spend their time encouraging Jamaicans overseas to return home.
If you are at the top of your career in the United States, the United Kingdom or elsewhere, think very carefully before relocating to Jamaica. In fact, if your intention is to continue building your professional career, my advice is simple: don’t do it.
Come for retirement. Come for the sunshine. Come if you have the financial resources to establish your own business. Come if you can continue earning your income overseas.

But don’t come expecting Jamaica to recognise your professional experience, welcome your expertise or open doors because you have spent decades working your way to the top. You may be in for a very rude awakening.
I say this not as someone looking at Jamaica from a distance, but as someone who has lived here for more than six years and experienced the reality firsthand.
I am a senior management professional whose career was established in the United States. My background spans banking, portfolio management and senior-level leadership. A close friend, whose career was established in the United Kingdom, brings extensive experience in property, major business transformation and government, including work at the highest levels.
Between us, we have worked in demanding environments, managed significant responsibilities and operated in organisations where performance, accountability and results mattered.
We did not arrive in Jamaica expecting favours. We did not expect anyone to hand us a job, create a position or reward us simply because we had worked overseas. We came with experience, qualifications, established careers and, perhaps most importantly, a genuine belief that what we had learned elsewhere could be useful here.
Six years later, we have reached a rather uncomfortable conclusion: Jamaica may welcome your money, but it does not necessarily welcome your professional contribution.
There is a difference.
We frequently hear about the importance of the diaspora. We hear speeches about attracting talent, encouraging returning residents, building the economy and bringing international expertise home. It all sounds wonderful. But where are the opportunities?
Where are the transparent pathways for experienced professionals to enter senior leadership positions, contribute to public-sector transformation or bring new thinking into established institutions?
From our experience, those pathways are extraordinarily difficult to find.
There are vacancies, certainly. There are job advertisements. There are impressive titles and organisations that speak enthusiastically about modernisation, innovation and transformation. But an advertised opportunity and a genuinely accessible opportunity are not necessarily the same thing.
In too many instances, the impression one is left with is that the decision-making circles are already established, the relationships are already in place and the door is effectively closed long before an outsider gets anywhere near it.
Call it networking. Call it connections. Call it the old boys’ club. In Jamaica, there is a familiar expression: a who yuh know. Unfortunately, we have found that expression painfully relevant.
Of course, personal connections matter in the United States and the United Kingdom as well. Nobody with serious professional experience would pretend otherwise. Those countries have their own problems with favouritism, institutional politics and unequal access.
But there is something particularly discouraging about encountering these barriers in a small country where the pool of senior opportunities is already limited.
In a larger economy, if one institution does not recognise your experience, another might. There are competing employers, multiple sectors, larger markets and alternative routes forward. In Jamaica, the circle is much smaller. And when you are outside that circle, it can feel almost impossible to enter.
The irony is that Jamaica continues to lose talented people to migration while simultaneously struggling, in our experience, to create meaningful pathways for experienced professionals who might wish to return.
We tell our brightest young people to study hard, gain qualifications, work diligently and strive for excellence. Many do exactly that. Some build exceptional international careers. Then, when they contemplate returning home, they discover that the professional journey they spent decades building does not necessarily translate into an opportunity here.
What exactly are we telling them? That their experience is valuable overseas but somehow less relevant in Jamaica? That they should return with their savings, purchase property, employ local services, support relatives, invest in businesses and contribute to the economy, but abandon any expectation of having an equally meaningful professional career?
Because that is certainly how it can feel.
And I want to be clear about something else: Jamaica does not owe returning residents a job. We understand that completely.
Jamaicans already living here face their own difficulties finding employment, securing promotions, earning decent salaries and getting a fair opportunity. Many are exceptionally qualified and equally frustrated.
This is not an argument for giving returning residents preferential treatment over people who have remained and worked in Jamaica. Quite the opposite.
It is an argument for a system in which people are assessed fairly, regardless of whether they built their careers in Kingston, London, New York or elsewhere. A system in which competence matters. Experience matters. Performance matters. A system in which opportunity is not perceived to depend primarily on whose telephone number you have saved.
We should also stop pretending that returning to Jamaica is simply a matter of bringing home foreign qualifications and expecting doors to open. It isn’t.
The Jamaican economy is relatively small. Senior positions are limited. Salaries can be substantially different from those available overseas. Organisational structures and recruitment practices may be unfamiliar. These are realities that prospective returnees should understand before making life-changing decisions.
My concern, however, goes beyond economics. It is about the absence of a convincing route into professional life for people who have something to offer but are not already part of the established networks.
We often hear that Jamaica needs help, needs expertise, needs investment and needs transformation. Perhaps it does. But needing expertise and being prepared to make room for it are two very different things.
After more than six years here, I have become increasingly sceptical of the idea that professional experience alone will provide an opportunity to contribute.
So my advice to anyone who has reached a senior position overseas is straightforward.
Do not resign from a successful international career on the assumption that you will find a comparable opportunity in Jamaica. Do not sell your home, uproot your family and arrive with the belief that decades of achievement will automatically be recognised. Do not mistake invitations to invest for invitations to participate.
If you intend to retire here, that is an entirely different proposition. If you have sufficient capital to establish your own business, there may be opportunities worth exploring. If you can work remotely for an overseas organisation or maintain an international income, that may be your safest option.
And if you want to buy property, build a home, support family members or invest in Jamaica, by all means do so, provided the investment makes financial sense.
But please do not confuse those activities with the existence of a welcoming professional environment. Jamaica is quite capable of accepting your investment without providing you with an opportunity to apply the expertise that helped you earn it.
That is the uncomfortable distinction many people discover only after arriving.
I have no bitterness towards Jamaica itself. It is a country with remarkable people, considerable talent and enormous potential. And I certainly do not believe that every employer or institution operates in the same way. There will be people who have returned and successfully rebuilt their careers. Their experiences deserve to be heard too.
But our experience has been markedly different. And after more than six years, I cannot responsibly encourage another established professional to make the same decision without understanding the risks.
The Government, employers and professional institutions should ask themselves a serious question.
If Jamaica genuinely wants to benefit from the experience of its diaspora, where are the transparent, credible and accessible pathways for those professionals to contribute?
Not another conference. Not another speech about the importance of returning home. Not another photograph celebrating overseas Jamaicans and their achievements.
Actual opportunities. Fair recruitment. Open competition. Meaningful engagement. A willingness to consider people who are not already connected to established circles.
Until those things become more visible, the message to accomplished professionals overseas should be far more realistic.
Come to Jamaica if you can afford to live here without needing Jamaica to employ you.
That may sound harsh. But it is considerably kinder than encouraging someone to walk away from a successful career based on a promise of opportunity that may never materialise.
And perhaps the greatest irony of all is this: Jamaica spends so much time asking its people overseas to come home, yet some of us who have come home are still waiting to be let in.
Yours faithfully,
A Disillusioned Returning Professional

Visit our YouTube Community ↗