In November 2022 the Auditor General’s Department completed a report for the House of Representatives on a piece of software most Jamaicans have never heard of. AMANDA, the system the state bought to track every building and subdivision application in the island, was supposed to help local authorities decide each case within 90 days. The auditors pulled its records for January 2016 to December 2021 and found that, of 34,043 applications received by the municipal corporations, only 24,718 had ever been entered into the system. Barely half of those had been closed. Only 9,599, or 39 per cent of the applications entered, were finished inside the 90 day target.

The same report found 255 applications started and completed on the same day, 244 of them approved, and 2,437 approvals on files missing a property address, valuation number or title reference.
That audit is one page in a long file. Together, the record shows a country that keeps rewriting its laws, maps and software to approve buildings faster, with real recent gains on speed, and far less evidence of the capacity to check what is actually built after the permit is issued.
A 1957 law and a 90 day promise
The foundation is the Town and Country Planning Act, Act 42 of 1957, which came into force on 1 February 1958. Its text sets clocks throughout. Section 13(2) says that when a developer appeals a refusal, the Minister “shall make a determination within ninety days of the hearing thereof.” Section 22A lets an authority serve a stop notice lasting no more than ten days, with a fine for ignoring it of not less than J$25,000 and not more than J$1 million.
The Supreme Court file shows what happens when the clock is not kept, in the case of a proposed fuel station and convenience store at 9 Herb McKenley Drive, Kingston 6. The court record in Charley’s Windsor House Limited v Prime Minister shows that planning and building permission were refused in June and July 2019, and the company appealed on 17 July 2019. The appeal was heard on 26 November 2019 by Daryl Vaz, then the minister with responsibility. The decision dismissing it came on 25 October 2020, a gap of 334 days against a statutory 90.
In 2021 the Supreme Court granted leave for judicial review. In 2024 Justice Annmarie Nembhard quashed the October 2020 decision because no particulars of reasons were given, and sent the appeal back to be heard again within the Act’s timelines.
What the record shows: the law has always had deadlines. An owner has 14 days to appeal an enforcement notice. Here the Minister’s 90 day limit was missed by 244 days, and the Government’s answer in court was that the Act attaches no consequence to missing it.
December 2010: the audit that counted the gaps
The most detailed public examination of the system remains the Auditor General’s December 2010 performance audit of the National Environment and Planning Agency, NEPA. It found that some development orders, the legal land use maps, were up to 30 years old, and that only six parishes were fully covered by one.
Of the agency’s own special list of 243 high risk permits and licences, just 67, or 28 per cent, were monitored in 2009/10. NEPA could not produce case details for 922 enforcement actions it reported from April 2005 to March 2009.
On appeals: of 79 appeals against NEPA refusals between 2005/06 and 2009/10, ministers overturned 41, or 52 per cent. On money, NEPA incurred an estimated J$221 million in processing costs between January 2007 and March 2010 against estimated revenue of J$35.9 million, largely because planning and subdivision applications it reviewed for local authorities carried no fee.
September 2016: the follow up audit
The September 2016 follow up audit gives credit where the agency moved. Enforcement activities totalled 3,604 between April 2010 and March 2015, against 922 in the four years to March 2009, roughly three times the yearly rate. It investigated 90 per cent of public complaints.
Other findings showed continuing weaknesses. For 60 permits or licences, the gap between issue and the first monitoring visit stretched to as long as five years. Only 87 of 498 sampled monitoring reports, 17 per cent, showed any sign of having been reviewed by a supervisor. Monitoring targets had been cut by 24 per cent in 2013/14 and 11 per cent in 2014/15; actual visits then beat the reduced targets by 43 and 31 per cent. The report said plainly that “the level of fines was not a deterrent to environment breaches.”
On cost, the follow up found that fees averaged about 11.1 per cent of NEPA’s spending from 2010/11 to 2014/15, while the Government’s rules for this class of executive agency require between 40 and 90 per cent. Processing planning and subdivision applications for local authorities had cost about J$580.8 million over the period, none of it recovered. NEPA raised fees in 2015 and targeted 25 per cent recovery by 2018/19.
What the record shows: enforcement grew, but the checking of permits already issued did not keep pace, and the public paid for most of the review.
The maps that decide what you can build
In the May 2021 Sectoral Debate, Everald Warmington, then a Minister without Portfolio, told the House that the whole island was now covered by at least one provisional development order, up from about 40 per cent of the country in 2017.
NEPA’s own register now lists 22 instruments. It includes confirmation notices for St Catherine in 2019, Kingston and St Andrew in 2023, and both Portmore and St Elizabeth in 2024, as well as new provisional orders for Manchester in 2024 and St Ann in 2025. It still carries the confirmed St Ann order of 1999.
The gap between provisional and confirmed is not academic. In June 2025 the Court of Appeal delivered a 136 page judgment on a 12 unit apartment block at 17 Birdsucker Drive, St Andrew, approved by the KSAMC in December 2017. The court held that the trial judge had been wrong to measure the project against the 2017 provisional order. The operative law was the confirmed 1966 order for Kingston and St Andrew, which the court called the only order the legislation recognised, and no breach of it had been shown. The 2017 provisional order was not confirmed until 2023. The same judgment held that enforcement against the developer, who built two units beyond the 12 approved, was mandatory, and ordered the KSAMC to enforce a stop notice served in October 2018.
What the record shows: for decades much of Jamaica was planned against old orders or none. As late as 2017 provisional orders covered about 40 per cent of the island, and even in Kingston it took the Court of Appeal to settle which map applied.
The Building Act, 2018, and the long road to it
For how buildings must be built, Jamaica relied until 2019 on the Kingston and St Andrew Building Act and the Parish Councils Building Act. In 2002 the president of the Jamaica Institution of Engineers made a national building code his project for the year. A Cabinet submission for a Building Act was promised for the first quarter of 2007 and was not completed. A bill appeared in late 2011. The Senate finally passed the Building Act on 25 January 2018 with 30 amendments, and the Ministry of Local Government announced that it came into force on 15 January 2019.
It made the municipal corporations the building authorities. A St James Municipal Corporation planning technologist set out its fixed penalties in December 2024: J$1 million for pouring a foundation without notice, J$1.5 million for ignoring a stop notice and J$2.5 million for ignoring an enforcement notice, with more possible in court.
Set against those figures, the fee for a modest home is small. Hanover’s chief engineering officer explained in April 2026 that a single family house is charged J$200 per square metre, so J$20,000 for a 100 square metre home, and that the usual penalty for building it without approval is a further 100 per cent of the fee. The fixed penalty for ignoring a stop notice is 75 times that fee. On 3 June 2026 Local Government Minister Desmond McKenzie told Parliament a revised building code would be rolled out in the 2026/27 financial year and that buildings would be required to withstand Category 5 hurricanes. He said the Finance Ministry had approved a revised staff structure allowing more building officers to be hired, without giving numbers.
What the record shows: the penalties are now severe on paper; the record does not show how often they are imposed.
November 2022: the software audit
AMANDA was meant to be the machinery of faster, traceable approvals. The November 2022 audit dates it to NEPA in 2004/05, with a 2008 decision to extend it to the municipal corporations and roll out between 2010 and 2015. Three projects from 2008 to 2021 cost J$115 million plus US$539,127.
The audit found that the system did not enforce the most basic entries. There were 6,253 applications with no taxpayer registration number and 28,320 entries made mostly of zeros. NEPA, which hosts the system, had no formal disaster recovery plan, its backup policy had not been approved and was last updated in 2015, and full backups were taken only twice a year.
Portmore entered just 5 per cent of its applications into AMANDA and closed 2 per cent there; St Catherine entered 27 per cent. Among applications that were closed, Trelawny decided 97 per cent within 90 days, Clarendon 93 per cent and St Thomas 92 per cent, but St Elizabeth managed 52 per cent, St Mary 47 per cent and Westmoreland 19 per cent.
Three years on, the minister was still pushing. Speaking to staff at the St Elizabeth Municipal Corporation on 16 January 2026, after Hurricane Melissa floodwaters damaged paper records in Black River, Mr McKenzie was reported by the Gleaner as saying that “some municipal corporations don’t want to use it” and that “almost 80 per cent of the records you have are useless.”
What the newest numbers show
In his June 2026 sectoral presentation, Mr McKenzie reported that 3,764 applications worth J$46.1 billion were submitted between January and September 2025, an 11 per cent increase; 81 per cent were approved within 90 days. He put the figure for applications after Hurricane Melissa at 78 per cent.
The Planning Institute of Jamaica’s Economic and Social Survey for 2025, as reported in July 2026, counted 4,609 applications to municipal corporations for the full year, worth about J$280.9 billion and up roughly 49.7 per cent in value on 2024. There were 3,536 approvals, about 80.5 per cent of them inside 90 days, and only six refusals. But 2,112 applications were still under review at year end, and 55.7 per cent had already passed the 90 day mark. Since approvals, refusals and pending files exceed the year’s 4,609 applications, at least 1,045 must date from earlier years.
The World Bank’s last Doing Business report, for 2020, put Jamaica 70th for construction permits: 18 procedures and 140.5 days, against a regional average of 15.5 procedures and 191.2 days.
What the record shows: approval speed has improved, but a backlog persists beneath the headline rate.
The households the paperwork never reaches
The clearest evidence is the Jamaica Informal Building Sector Study, written by Build Change for the World Bank in September 2018. Sixty five per cent of households that built their own homes used no construction drawings. Twenty four per cent did not know what a building permit was. Only 34 per cent of builders had ever had a visit from the parish council. It concluded: “Construction activity is gradual and is frequently unpermitted.”
Hurricane Melissa tested that stock in October 2025. On 3 December 2025, ODPEM Director General Alvin Gayle told a post Cabinet briefing that about 215,000 buildings had some level of damage, including an estimated 156,000 with roof damage. Two days earlier, in a published letter, the Mayor of Montego Bay, Richard Vernon, had written that in many parishes “fewer than a dozen inspectors are expected to monitor thousands of construction sites,” without giving a source.
The municipal record since then is a record of amnesties. St Catherine offered one month from 12 February 2026 for unapproved building over the past ten years. Hanover waived breach penalties from 1 April to 31 July 2026 after serving more than 100 notices, and St Thomas was reported to be launching a three month amnesty from 1 April.
What the record shows: regularising after the fact has become a routine tool, while the inspection numbers remain unpublished.
Fast lanes for the largest projects
The newest documents add a second track. In the Budget Debate on 19 March 2026, Prime Minister Andrew Holness announced FAST Jamaica, a framework giving strategic projects of US$150 million or more accelerated approvals and dedicated facilitation teams, and said it “is not about weakening safeguards.” On 14 April he lowered the threshold to US$15 million. On 29 April the House passed the National Reconstruction and Resilience Authority Act, giving NaRRA special powers to fast track development approvals and procurement for a published list of projects for a limited period.
Supporters argue a country rebuilding after a Category 5 storm cannot wait on a patchy system, and Mr Holness has said NaRRA’s resources are additional to the regular one. Cabinet keeps oversight of final FAST agreements. The Opposition proposed sending the NaRRA Bill to a Joint Select Committee; the Government declined, citing urgency. The published documents set out eligibility and powers, not inspection staffing.
Questions the record leaves open
- How many building officers does each municipal corporation employ, and how many inspections did they make in 2025?
- How many planning appeals has the Minister decided since 2010, how many were allowed, and how many within 90 days?
- Has the Auditor General’s 2022 recommendation on AMANDA input controls and disaster recovery been implemented?
- Which parishes still operate under provisional rather than confirmed development orders?
- Will decisions and timelines for FAST Jamaica and NaRRA projects be published alongside those of ordinary applicants?
- How many structures were regularised under the 2026 municipal amnesties, and what enforcement followed?
Documents we read
- Town and Country Planning Act, 1957 (in force 1 February 1958)
- Auditor General: NEPA performance audit, December 2010; follow up audit, September 2016; AMANDA IT audit, November 2022
- Building Act, 2018 (in force 15 January 2019)
- Supreme Court, Charley’s Windsor House Limited v Prime Minister, 2021; 2024 ruling as reported
- Court of Appeal, 17 Birdsucker Drive judgment, June 2025, as reported
- NEPA register of development orders, November 2026
- Jamaica Informal Building Sector Study, World Bank and GFDRR, September 2018
- World Bank, Doing Business 2020, Jamaica profile
- Sectoral Debate presentations, May 2021 (as reported) and 3 June 2026; PIOJ Economic and Social Survey 2025
- Statements on FAST Jamaica and the NaRRA Act, March and April 2026
Method: Built from legislation, Auditor General’s reports, court records, NEPA’s register, ministerial statements and published studies. The 2024 and 2025 court rulings, the PIOJ 2025 figures, the municipal amnesties, the Building Act fixed penalties and the January 2026 ministerial remarks are taken from published reports of those documents. The 334 day gap and the penalty to fee ratio are our arithmetic. PIOJ figures do not fully reconcile because pending applications include earlier years. Town and Country Planning Act fines are from the Ministry of Justice text and may since have been amended.
Dean Jones is Director of Jamaica Homes Ltd and a Realtor.

Visit our YouTube Community ↗