TRENCH TOWN, Kingston. On 10 May 2007 the Jamaica National Heritage Trust declared two addresses on Lower First Street, numbers 6 and 8, a protected national heritage site. It was the first inner city site in the country to receive the designation. What the Trust was protecting was not a great house or a fort. It was a row of rooms, each measuring ten feet by ten feet, opening onto a long shared verandah, with shared cooking and sanitary facilities around a common yard.

The rooms are famous for who lived in them. Vincent “Tata” Ford, a community leader, taught a boy named Robert Nesta Marley his first guitar chords there, and the Wailers formed in that yard. But the rooms were built for a less romantic reason. They were public housing, put up by a colonial government in the 1940s because Kingston had run out of decent places for poor people to live, and a wave of strikes and riots in 1938 gave the work new urgency.
This is the story of those rooms: how a cattle pen on the edge of the city became, in a minister’s phrase, the cradle of public housing in the Corporate Area, what the state promised and delivered there over eight decades, and why the problem the government yards were built to solve is, by official estimates, far larger today than it was when the first tenant paid twelve shillings a month for a room.
A Cattle Pen at the Edge of the City
Before it was a neighbourhood, Trench Town was Trench Pen, about 400 acres of livestock land west of the old city. It took its name from the Trench family, of Irish descent; Daniel Power Trench (1813 to 1884), the son of a wealthy plantation owner and slaveholder, held it as part of his Greenwich Park estate. By the late nineteenth century the family had abandoned the land.
Kingston grew towards it. The census of 1933 counted 73,354 people in the parish of Kingston and 60,051 in St Andrew, a combined 133,405. Ten years later the 1943 census counted 235,225, a rise of 76 per cent in a decade. Many of the newcomers were migrants from rural Jamaica, and they settled wherever there was empty ground. Trench Pen, along with Dung Hill, Back O’ Wall and Kingston Pen, had become a squatter settlement, and by the 1930s it was growing fast.
The people who settled there held no title to the land, and few of them could vote: universal adult suffrage did not come to Jamaica until 1944, so the residents of the pens had little formal means of making their conditions a political issue. In 1938 working Jamaicans found an informal one.
The Summer the Island Spoke
On 2 May 1938 the Governor of Jamaica, Sir Edward Denham, cabled London that a crowd of “fully 3,000 strikers” had demolished the company’s office at Frome, the new sugar factory Tate & Lyle had built in Westmoreland. Four workers died in the Frome unrest and more than 100 strikers were arrested. The following week the dock workers of Kingston walked out over pay. Alexander Bustamante was arrested and later bailed, and on 1 June the Colonial Secretary, Malcolm MacDonald, told the House of Commons that new pay agreements for wharf labourers and banana workers had ended the Kingston strike.
A correspondent, R. S. Peat, wrote to the Colonial Office on 13 June 1938 about the “deplorable conditions under which Jamaican labourers are forced to live and work”. Housing was among those conditions, and London responded in the way it usually did: with a Royal Commission.
The West India Royal Commission, chaired by Lord Moyne, arrived in Jamaica on 1 November 1938. Its report was so critical that the British government, by then at war, published only the recommendations in 1940 and held back the full text until 1945, after Lord Moyne agreed to cut sections the War Office regarded as dangerous, among them passages on housing. The main practical result was the Colonial Development and Welfare Act of 1940, which created a fund for the West Indies, and some of that money would go into bricks and concrete in Kingston.
In Jamaica itself the legal machinery arrived first. The Central Housing Authority had been formed in 1937 to deal with the city’s deteriorating housing, and the Slum Clearance and Housing Law of 1939 gave it statutory power to carry out housing schemes, clear slums and undertake improvement schemes “for the working classes”. Trench Pen was the obvious place to start.
Rooms Around a Yard
Between 1940 and 1949 the Central Housing Authority laid out about 200 acres of Trench Pen as a planned community. The rest of the old pen became Rose Town. The Authority built along First to Seventh Streets, between Central Road and West Road, and it did not build houses in the suburban sense. It built yards.
The Jamaica National Heritage Trust records four building types, labelled H, S, T and U. The U blocks held one or two room dwellings, each room ten feet by ten feet, reached by a long communal verandah, with shared sanitary and cooking facilities. The S units, found only between First and Second Streets, were two storey blocks of four two room flats, each with its own kitchen, sharing toilets and a courtyard. Each yard had running water and electricity.
The scheme was more ambitious than the rooms suggest. The model township included owner occupied houses as well as rental units, and space for schools, a theatre, a park, branches of the YMCA and YWCA, a health clinic and a fire station. Tenants paid twelve shillings a month, and in the 1950s and 1960s the Authority inspected the yards monthly to check that rules were kept and rent was paid. The arrangement made the state a landlord, a rent collector and a building inspector at the same time, a role it has never entirely given up in the inner city.
A room of a hundred square feet holds a bed and little else, so cooking, washing, talking and music happened in the shared courtyard. It is no accident that the music came out of the yard and not out of the rooms.
Wind, Money and a Ministry
Weather kept forcing the government’s hand. A hurricane in August 1944 flattened much of Kingston and required its own relocation and rebuilding scheme. On 17 and 18 August 1951 Hurricane Charlie killed 154 people in Jamaica, 54 of them in the Corporate Area, injured about 2,000 and left more than 9,000 homeless. Relief money from Charlie, channelled through a Hurricane Housing Organisation, accelerated the housing programme across Port Royal, east Kingston and west Kingston, often as serviced lots with a basic shell house that families were expected to complete themselves.
The squatters kept coming too. By 1950 squatting at Kingston Pen, Trench Town and Dung Hill was officially described as having “assumed alarming proportions”. A scheme at Majesty Pen, completed in 1950, rehoused about 1,720 people, and in time it too became a slum as more people arrived from the countryside. By 1955, 57 housing schemes had been financed under the government’s ten year plan at a total cost of £708,822, an average of roughly £12,400 a scheme. The Housing Act of 1955 merged the hurricane organisation with the Central Housing Authority into the Department of Housing and Social Welfare.
On 20 June 1956 the Minister of Local Government and Housing, Dr Glendon Logan, opened Federal Gardens in Trench Town: 30 terraced houses and seven two storey blocks, homes for 116 families, every flat self contained with its own kitchen, toilet and bath. It cost about £61,000, roughly £526 for each family housed, with a third of the money coming from Colonial Development and Welfare funds. Chief Minister Norman Manley spoke. So did the Minister of Finance, Noel Nethersole, who spoke of the district’s place in the island’s housing story.
…Trench Town which had been the cradle of public housing in the Corporate Area.
Noel Nethersole, Minister of Finance, at the opening of Federal Gardens, 20 June 1956, as reported in the Daily Gleaner
Nethersole also said, according to the same report, that limited funds and population pressure made solving the housing problem almost impossible. The state kept building, but increasingly elsewhere: Harbour View, planned in 1959 with 1,875 homes, was billed as the largest single housing scheme ever undertaken by an organisation in the West Indies. In west Kingston, Back O’ Wall was cleared between February and July 1966, with about 2,000 people removed, to make way for later phases of Tivoli Gardens, after 932 families had been moved from the Foreshore Road area in 1963 for its first phase. A Ministry of Housing replaced the Department in 1966, and in 1976 Parliament created the National Housing Trust, funded by compulsory contributions from workers and employers, which became the main engine of housing finance for the next half century.
Historians and residents still argue about the 1960s clearances. Supporters point out that Tivoli replaced the shacks of Back O’ Wall with modern homes. Critics, among them observers who say many PNP supporters were displaced in favour of JLP supporters, and the anthropologist Deborah Thomas, describe it as a garrison community, where political support is exchanged for contracts and other social welfare benefits.
When the Streets Took Sides
In the 1970s Trench Town was split between supporters of the Jamaica Labour Party and the People’s National Party, and the yards became front lines. The fighting destroyed the two blocks of government yards between Fifth and Seventh Streets. Trench Town, Rose Town and neighbouring Jones Town were caught up in the violence around the 1976 election, and many residents fled. A truce in 1978 was celebrated with a peace dance, and the fighting resumed within months.
For housing, the cost of those years was measured in empty buildings: houses and lots stood vacant for years. The census shows the long tail of that loss. The census community of Trench Town had 7,043 residents in 2001 and 5,771 in 2011, a fall of 18 per cent, at a time when the population of Kingston and St Andrew as a whole grew by about 1.6 per cent.
Census community boundaries change between counts, and the preliminary 2022 tabulation uses a much larger area under the Trench Town name, so the latest figure cannot be compared with the earlier two.
By 2020, when Pearnel Charles Jr was installed as minister responsible for urban renewal, residents interviewed by the Gleaner described families returning, abandoned houses and vacant lots being reoccupied, and a district “developing slowly”.
Concrete, Titles and a Prince
The state returned to Trench Town in the new century with a different model. The Inner City Housing Project, launched in 2004 with the National Housing Trust as financier, set out to build 5,000 homes in degraded urban communities. On 16 August 2006 Prime Minister Portia Simpson Miller handed over 252 of them in Trench Town: 13 apartment buildings of two and four storeys, with 84 three bedroom and 168 two bedroom homes, a community centre and a day care centre, built by Ashtrom on land that had been unoccupied. She told the ceremony the project would not affect “one person making a contribution to NHT”. The programme was later suspended. When Mrs Simpson Miller, again Prime Minister, announced in her budget presentation of April 2013 that it would restart, the Jamaica Information Service listed 1,176 completed homes in six Corporate Area developments, among them 256 in Trench Town, well short of the 5,000 target.
Next door, in Rose Town, the approach was smaller and slower. The Prince’s Foundation, the built environment charity of the then Prince of Wales, began working there in 2004, ran a five day design workshop with about 300 participants in 2006, and drew up a master plan for affordable housing in a traditional Jamaican style. The Prince visited in March 2008 and opened a library. In 2013 the British High Commission reported that a grant of more than £90,000 from the Department for International Development had helped more than 80 Rose Town residents obtain titles to land their families already occupied.
Eighty titles is a small number, but a title lets a family connect utilities in its own name, borrow against a house and pass it on. The two approaches on either side of the old Trench Pen boundary, new apartments built by the state and paper titles for homes people already have, frame the choice that every Jamaican government since 1939 has faced.
The Problem That Outgrew the Pen
Today’s figures dwarf those of the 1930s. Government estimates cited by the Gleaner in an editorial in September 2026 put the number of Jamaicans living in squatter or irregular settlements at between 750,000 and 900,000, up to a third of the population, and the government reports a backlog of about 150,000 homes. A national survey of informal settlements, launched in 2019, was complete in 13 of the 14 parishes by September 2026, according to Authrine Scarlett, the ministry’s Chief Technical Director for Housing, Urban Renewal and Projects, who said she hoped it would give the government “concrete evidence based information on which to plan”.
Kingston and St Andrew now hold about 673,000 people according to the preliminary 2022 count, roughly five times the population of 1933.
There are two serious arguments about what the government yards teach. The first holds that the state built well when it built: the yards had water and light when the surrounding pens had neither, Federal Gardens gave every family its own bathroom in 1956, and the Trench Town apartments of 2006 replaced vacant land with homes. On this view the failure was not public housing but too little of it, starved of maintenance and then captured by party politics. The second argument holds that the state is a poor landlord, that rented public housing in Kingston became an instrument of patronage, and that the durable gains came from giving people titles, serviced lots and mortgages so they could own and improve their own homes. The Hurricane Charlie shell houses, the National Housing Trust and the Rose Town titles all point that way.
The record supports parts of both. What it does not support is the idea that the problem fixes itself. Where the state stepped back in Trench Town, overcrowding, informal building and, in the worst years, political gunmen filled the gap.
Back on First Street
The Culture Yard at 6 and 8 Lower First Street opened to visitors in 2000 and is run by residents. The 1940s buildings have been restored. Visitors can see a small museum with belongings of Tata Ford, Bob Marley, Peter Tosh and Bunny Wailer, the remains of the band’s old van, a guitar and a bed. When the yard was set up, those involved, including Rita Marley, chose not to call it the Bob Marley Culture Yard, so that it would also stand for the other musicians who came out of the district.
The yard is a shrine to musicians. It is also a record of a public decision. In 1939 a colonial government, pressed by riots and a Royal Commission, decided that the poor of Kingston should have water, light and a roof, and that the state would supply them. The rooms it built were small, the rent was twelve shillings, and the yard outside was shared. Eight decades on, the rooms are protected by law, and the question they were built to answer is still open on the streets around them.
Method: This account draws on the Jamaica National Heritage Trust’s record of the Trench Town Culture Yard; UK National Archives material on the 1938 unrest (CO 137/826 and CO 137/827) and the Hansard record of 1 June 1938; the published history of the West India Royal Commission; Jacquiann Lawton’s study of public housing in Kingston; Jamaican Family Search’s history of Kingston; the University of the West Indies disaster management archive on Hurricane Charlie; STATIN census data for 1960 to 2022 (the 2022 figures are preliminary, and community boundaries change between censuses); Jamaica Information Service reports of 17 August 2006 and 30 April 2013; the National Housing Trust’s description of the Inner City Housing Project; the British High Commission statement of 3 May 2013; the Congress for the New Urbanism’s account of the Rose Town project; and reports in the Daily Gleaner of 21 June 1956, 15 September 2020, 27 September 2026 and its editorial of 2 September 2026. The Federal Gardens quotation is as reported by the Gleaner. Cost per family and growth rates were calculated by Jamaica Homes News. Estimates of the number of people in informal settlements are government estimates as reported, not census counts. Sterling sums from the 1940s and 1950s have not been converted into today’s money.
Dean Jones is Director of Jamaica Homes Ltd and a Realtor.

Visit our YouTube Community ↗