Oil peaks at US$147 a barrel in July then collapses as global recession arrives; Tropical Storm Gustav floods farms in August; and Lehman Brothers files for bankruptcy on 15 September — a quarter that delivers three successive shocks and leaves Jamaica’s property market facing conditions it has no recent precedent to navigate.
Highlights
- Oil reaches US$147 a barrel in July, then begins a historic collapse toward US$40
- Tropical Storm Gustav makes landfall in August, disrupting agriculture and transport
- Lehman Brothers bankruptcy on 15 September triggers a global credit freeze
- US construction employment begins its steepest contraction in postwar history
- Jamaica dollar holds near J$72 per US dollar but pressure builds as reserves are tested
- Commercial property and residential volumes fall sharply; NHT lending becomes the primary market
For the first three weeks of September 2008, Jamaica was watching two crises unfold simultaneously. The first was meteorological and familiar: Tropical Storm Gustav, which had already devastated crops and disrupted infrastructure when it made landfall in August, had now passed — but it had left behind flooded cane fields in St Elizabeth, damaged banana farms in St Mary, and the lingering cost of emergency agricultural support at a moment when the Treasury had no surplus to absorb it. The second crisis was financial and without modern precedent. On 15 September, Lehman Brothers Holdings filed for bankruptcy in New York, triggering a global credit market seizure that within seventy-two hours had frozen interbank lending rates across Europe, shuttered money market funds in the United States, and delivered to every small open economy in the Caribbean a blunt message: the external financing environment had changed, and no one could say for how long.
The oil market provided its own surreal coda. After peaking at a record US$147.27 a barrel on 11 July, crude prices had begun falling with the same velocity they had risen — the futures market brutally adjusting to the realisation that a global recession was not a tail risk but an emerging reality. By the time Lehman fell, Brent crude was already below US$100. By year-end it would approach US$40. For Jamaica, this reversal was bittersweet: the energy import bill that had driven inflation to 24 per cent annually would ease, but the conditions that caused the oil collapse — collapsing global demand, mass unemployment in the United States, a credit market that had stopped functioning normally — would damage the island’s economy through channels far more consequential than energy costs.
The most important of those channels was the remittance wire transfer. Jamaica’s diaspora — concentrated in the Miami construction trades, the New York service sector, the Hartford insurance back offices, the Toronto cleaning and hospitality industries — had sent home roughly US$2 billion annually in the peak years of the mid-decade boom. A disproportionate share of that sum had been earned in the United States construction sector, which employed more Jamaican-born workers than any other single industry. When US housing starts, which had already fallen from their 2005 peak of 2.07 million to under 1.1 million, fell further toward the 500,000 annual rate they would reach in 2009, the layoffs cascaded. Construction contractors, cement pourers, roofers, electricians, and drywall finishers across Florida and New York who had maintained monthly wire transfers to Kingston, Montego Bay, and rural parishes began missing payments or reducing amounts. The aggregate impact would only be fully visible in the remittance statistics a quarter later — but the early signals were arriving in September.
For the property market, this convergence of shocks produced a specific and troubling pattern. The buyers who depended on commercial bank mortgages at sixteen to seventeen per cent were already largely absent from the market — they had been priced out through the rate cycle of 2007 and 2008. The buyers who depended on remittance income to service NHT mortgages were about to see their income streams disrupted. That left, as the functioning mortgage market, only those NHT contributors with secure formal-sector employment, and those buyers in the upper end of the market who could transact without leverage. Neither segment was large enough to sustain transaction volumes at levels that developers and real estate agents had come to expect.
Commercial property felt the Lehman shock immediately in sentiment if not yet in transactions. Offshore investors who had been exploring Kingston’s New Kingston commercial district, the Montego Bay free zone, and resort-adjacent land along the north coast had relied on access to global capital markets to finance their interests. The sudden tightening of credit internationally meant that projects requiring offshore funding either paused or were abandoned. A number of larger mixed-use proposals that had circulated in planning offices over the previous two years — hotel expansions, condominium towers targeting expatriate buyers, marina developments — went quiet in the weeks following 15 September.
The Bank of Jamaica faced an impossible immediate choice. The global financial shock called for interest rate cuts to support economic activity — every major central bank was moving in that direction. But Jamaica’s inflation, while falling from its June peak as oil prices retreated, remained elevated, and cutting rates prematurely risked triggering a run on the Jamaica dollar precisely when investor confidence was most fragile. The exchange rate had held near J$72 per United States dollar through most of the quarter, but the BOJ’s reserves — US$2.2 billion at end-June — were being watched by every offshore creditor and investor as the marginal indicator of Jamaica’s ability to service its external obligations. The bank chose to hold, watching oil prices, watching the dollar, watching the Fed’s emergency moves in New York, and waiting for clarity that would not arrive quickly.
Within the domestic property industry, the quarter produced an important structural development that would shape the market through the years ahead. NHT, as the institution least exposed to the offshore funding channels that Lehman had frozen, and whose contribution base was insulated from the immediate shock by Jamaica’s relatively stable formal employment in the public sector, emerged as the market’s primary functioning lender. For properties priced within NHT eligibility limits, the trust remained willing and able to lend. For properties above those thresholds, the market was effectively on hold. This bifurcation — an active affordable segment and a suspended higher-value segment — would define the landscape for the next two years.
What This Means
Lehman’s collapse on 15 September 2008 is not primarily a financial markets event for Jamaica — it is a remittances event, a tourism demand event, and a property financing event. The six to eighteen month outlook is the most concerning Jamaica has faced since the FINSAC crisis of 1997-99. Remittance flows, which underpin a significant fraction of both NHT contributions and informal property transactions, will fall as US unemployment rises. Tourism earnings, already contracting in the second half of 2008, will decline further as American and European discretionary spending collapses. The exchange rate, which the BOJ has worked to hold stable, will come under sustained downward pressure as foreign exchange inflows decline across all channels simultaneously. For those tracking the property market, the relevant indicator is no longer listing prices — which will take many months to adjust downward as sellers resist acknowledging losses — but the rate of NHT mortgage approvals and the volume of titles transferred at the National Land Agency. Both are heading lower.
Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomesnews Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com
Visit our YouTube Community ↗