Commercial Rates at 12%: Jamaica’s First-Time Buyers Face Their Steepest Challenge — May 2014

Publication Date: 3 May 2014 | Coverage Period: 3 April – 2 May 2014 | Category: Monthly Review

April in Brief

• One year since Jamaica signed the IMF Extended Fund Facility in May 2013; stocktaking on housing sector impact
• Commercial mortgage rates firm at 10–14%; NHT rates at 0–5%; the gap defines Jamaica’s housing two-tier market
• Dry-season construction activity in full swing; hardware suppliers report modestly improved volumes
• HAJ settlement regularisation advancing in communities across Kingston and St Andrew
• Rental demand strong in professional belts; landlords report near-full occupancy in well-located units
• IMF quarterly review expected; programme targets tracking within required parameters

Housing Market

April saw a modest improvement in residential market activity as the dry season progressed and the post-budget period brought renewed transactional clarity. The Kingston metropolitan area and the Corporate Area — encompassing St Andrew, Kingston parish, and the expanding residential frontier of eastern St Catherine — generated the largest share of enquiry activity, as they consistently do.

The fundamental dynamic of Jamaica’s housing market has not shifted: the most active segment is NHT-eligible buyers pursuing scheme and open-market loan products, while the commercial market — where buyers must secure financing from banks and building societies at rates between 10% and 14% — remains constrained by affordability. The bifurcation between these two worlds, already stark, shows no sign of narrowing while the Bank of Jamaica maintains its current interest rate stance.

In the north coast tourism belt, the April–May shoulder period between the high winter season and the summer diaspora return is relatively quiet. Vendors of vacation and retirement properties report maintained asking prices but a lengthening of the time required to find willing buyers. The profile of serious enquirers is increasingly skewed toward established diaspora buyers with accumulated savings rather than first-time investors, reflecting the general tightening of discretionary spending power in the global Jamaican community.

Government Policy

May 2014 marks the first anniversary of Jamaica’s IMF Extended Fund Facility, signed in May 2013. The occasion invites an assessment of the programme’s impact on the housing sector — and the verdict is, at best, mixed. The macroeconomic framework has stabilised: inflation, while still elevated, has trended in the right direction; net international reserves have grown substantially; and the government has maintained its fiscal targets with a consistency that has earned cautious IMF praise.

For ordinary Jamaicans seeking homes, however, the year has been one of consolidating difficulty rather than emerging relief. The wage freeze implemented as part of the public-sector adjustment has eroded real purchasing power for government employees, including teachers, nurses, and civil servants who constitute a significant share of NHT contributor base. The freeze has not been extended to the private sector by diktat, but private-sector wage settlements have been modest, constrained by the same economic environment.

The NHT continues to operate its programme within the reduced capital framework, maintaining mortgage loan disbursements to eligible contributors while managing the Consolidated Fund transfer obligation. The Trust’s focus has increasingly been on maximising the impact of available funds — prioritising schemes with strong completion pipelines and ensuring that loan disbursements are matched by appropriate property development.

Construction Activity

The dry-season construction window is in full operation across the island. April and May are typically the peak months for structural work, and 2014 is following the seasonal pattern. Site activity on NHT schemes, private residential projects, and the large informal self-build sector is running at the year’s highest pace, a pattern that will continue through June before the onset of the rainy season in July introduces greater caution.

Skilled construction labour — particularly qualified masons and carpenters — is in high seasonal demand. Day rates for experienced masons in the Kingston area have crept upward in nominal terms, though real-terms gains are modest given inflation running near 8–10%. The competition for skilled workers between NHT scheme contractors, private developers, and the self-build sector creates some friction in scheduling and cost management for project managers.

Imported building materials continue to be the most significant cost variable. Steel reinforcement bar prices, sensitive to both global commodity prices and the Jamaican dollar exchange rate, have drifted higher over the past twelve months. Roofing materials — both traditional zinc and the increasingly popular asphalt shingle products — have similarly increased in landed cost as the exchange rate has moved from J$104 to approximately J$112–113 per US dollar over the same period.

Major Developments

The HAJ’s Riverton Meadows project and other community upgrading initiatives in the Corporate Area continue to advance, providing formal infrastructure and tenure security to communities that have long occupied land without legal title. These regularisation efforts, while unglamorous compared to new construction announcements, represent a critical component of Jamaica’s housing policy — in a country where land titling is both complex and deeply significant for household wealth, formalisation of tenure is a meaningful economic intervention.

The private development sector, while subdued compared to pre-2008 activity levels, is not dormant. A small number of private developers in Kingston’s upscale residential zones of Cherry Gardens, Stony Hill, and the newer developments in St Andrew continue to bring gated community and townhouse products to market, targeting the upper-income segment and, importantly, diaspora buyers who seek security features and modern amenities.

Infrastructure

Road works across multiple parishes continue under the National Works Agency’s programme, with particular attention to routes damaged by the preceding rainy season. The repair and maintenance cycle for Jamaica’s road network is a recurring theme — infrastructure built or repaired in the dry season often suffers significant deterioration in the wet season, creating an ongoing rehabilitation demand that absorbs capital at the expense of new construction.

In western Jamaica, infrastructure improvements associated with the Montego Bay Free Zone and logistics hub developments have a secondary residential dimension: workers drawn to expanded employment in the western end benefit from improved road networks that extend effective residential catchment areas. This dynamic is one of the modest positive spillovers from tourism and logistics investment in an otherwise constrained investment environment.

Investment Climate

Real estate investment by institutional players — pension funds, insurance companies, and collective investment schemes — continues to favour income-producing commercial properties over speculative residential development. The return profile of commercial real estate, particularly well-located retail and office stock in Kingston’s financial districts, remains more predictable than residential development in the current environment.

Jamaica Stock Exchange-listed companies with real estate exposure continue to attract investor attention as an inflation hedge. Property-backed assets have, historically, provided reasonable protection against the kind of exchange rate depreciation and inflation that Jamaica has experienced, making them attractive relative to fixed-income instruments whose real returns are being eroded by the current inflationary environment.

Diaspora

The summer diaspora return period — principally July and August, when Jamaicans living in North America and the UK return for family visits and summer vacation — is approaching. Property practitioners in the north coast, Kingston, and the diaspora-active communities of Manchester and Westmoreland are preparing for what is typically one of the year’s most active enquiry periods for property decisions by overseas Jamaicans.

Affordability

The calculation of housing affordability in Jamaica is starkly illustrative of the country’s structural challenges. A first-time buyer without NHT eligibility, seeking to purchase a modest three-bedroom house priced at J$8 million — towards the lower end of Kingston’s formal market — faces monthly mortgage repayments in excess of J$80,000 at 12% over 25 years. Against median household incomes, this is simply not sustainable without a second income and substantial savings.

NHT access changes the numbers dramatically, but the NHT is not a universal solution. Contribution requirements mean that only formally employed workers are eligible. Loan limits of approximately J$4.5 million mean that NHT finance alone rarely covers the full cost of even a modest scheme house in the current construction cost environment. And the waiting lists for scheme allocation mean that eligibility does not translate to immediate access.

Regional Context

In the wider Caribbean, the conversation about housing affordability is similarly dominated by high construction costs, limited access to long-term mortgage finance at reasonable rates, and the challenge of building housing supply quickly enough to meet urbanisation-driven demand. Several Eastern Caribbean nations are exploring regional housing finance mechanisms that might aggregate demand and reduce borrowing costs, but these initiatives remain in early stages.

Looking Ahead

The IMF’s next quarterly review of Jamaica’s programme is anticipated in the coming weeks. A clean review — confirming programme compliance — would be a modest positive signal for financial market stability and could contribute marginally to improved commercial lending conditions over time. A more significant monetary policy development — any movement in the Bank of Jamaica’s policy rate — would have a more direct impact on mortgage affordability, but is not anticipated in the near term.

The dry-season construction window will peak in June before the hurricane-season onset introduces weather-related caution. Market participants should expect the coming two months to represent the year’s most active period for site activity. After that, attention will turn to how hurricane season — always an uncertainty for Caribbean residential property — affects the second half of 2014’s housing market dynamics.

Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomes Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com