Five Percent, the Final Hike, and the Summer That Confirmed Everything

Jamaica Economic Intelligence | Q3 2023 | July–September 2023

Key Findings

• The Federal Reserve raises rates 25 basis points in July to 5.25–5.50 percent — the highest level since January 2001 — and then holds at every subsequent meeting through quarter-end, as falling inflation and the lag effects of the most aggressive tightening cycle in four decades argue for patience
• The US 10-year Treasury yield breaches 5 percent in October for the first time since 2007, as the “higher for longer” rate narrative displaces the pivot narrative that markets had been pricing; the move reshapes the cost of capital for every long-duration asset globally
• The United Auto Workers strike — beginning September 15 against all three Detroit automakers simultaneously, an unprecedented tactic — tests the resurgent American labour movement and ends in October with historic wage settlements that will shape the US wage-price dynamic through the medium term
• US CPI reaccelerates modestly from 3.0 percent in June to 3.7 percent in August on energy price rebounds before resuming its decline, reinforcing the “last mile” difficulty narrative even as core inflation continues its gradual descent
• Jamaica’s summer 2023 peak season delivers the third consecutive year of near-2019 stopover arrival volumes, with the Jamaica Tourist Board’s full-season data confirming that 2023’s total will match or exceed 2019’s record — the structural recovery confirmation that the series had been tracking since the rebound began
• The Bank of Jamaica begins signalling the first rate cuts since the tightening cycle began, as domestic CPI returns toward the 4–6 percent target band and the external rate environment begins to stabilise at its 2023 peak

It is October 19, 2023. The yield on the US 10-year Treasury note has just crossed 5 percent for the first time in sixteen years. The number matters less as an absolute level — the 1990s, when Jamaica’s reform architecture was being designed, saw 10-year yields regularly above 6 percent — than as a signal that the market has absorbed and believed the Federal Reserve’s “higher for longer” message in a way it had been resisting since the June pause. The equity market is repricing. The real estate markets of every major economy are recalculating. The cost of government borrowing — for the United States, for Jamaica, for every sovereign issuer whose bonds are priced against the risk-free rate — has just moved materially higher than it was three months ago, without a single additional rate hike from the Fed. In Detroit, the United Auto Workers’ historic strike against all three American automakers is entering its fifth week. In Montego Bay, the summer season is closing its books, and the numbers tell the story that three years of recovery data had been building toward: 2023’s arrival total will match or exceed the 2019 record.

The Final Hike and the Long Hold

The Federal Reserve’s July 26 decision to raise the federal funds rate 25 basis points to 5.25–5.50 percent was, as subsequent events would confirm, the terminal rate of the most consequential tightening cycle since Paul Volcker’s 1980s campaign against double-digit inflation. The decision was not controversial within the FOMC or in market expectations; the June pause had been presented as data-dependent rather than cycle-ending, and the June CPI data — which showed a modest uptick in the headline rate driven by energy prices — provided sufficient justification for one additional move. What was contested was what came next: whether the July hike completed the cycle, or whether the data through Q3 would require additional tightening to push core services inflation the remaining distance toward 2 percent.

The September and November FOMC meetings produced consecutive holds, and by quarter-end the market had largely priced the July hike as the cycle’s terminal point. The logic was Bayesian rather than certain: inflation was falling, if slowly; the labour market was cooling from its 2023 peak tightness; credit conditions had tightened as a result of the rate cycle’s transmission through the banking system and bond market, doing additional disinflationary work even without new hikes; and the lag effects of 525 basis points of cumulative tightening were still working through the economy’s various transmission channels. The recession that the 2022 yield curve inversion had predicted had not arrived; what had arrived, possibly, was the “soft landing” that every tightening cycle talks about and few deliver — the inflation return to target without a commensurate rise in unemployment.

For Jamaica, the Fed’s terminal rate confirmation was clarifying in the way that uncertainty’s resolution always clarifies planning assumptions. The external rate environment that Jamaica’s sovereign borrowing costs, its capital account flows, and its mortgage market all price against had stabilised at a level that was historically high but no longer moving higher. The Bank of Jamaica’s own forward guidance could now be oriented toward the domestic data rather than the question of how much higher the Fed would go. The tightening cycle’s end did not mean immediate easing — the BOJ’s communications through Q3 were careful not to promise cuts before the data warranted them — but it established the ceiling within which Jamaica’s monetary policy would operate for the foreseeable future.

The 5 Percent 10-Year and “Higher for Longer”

The October move in 10-year Treasury yields to levels not seen since 2007 was produced by a narrative shift rather than a policy shift: the market’s progressive acceptance that the Federal Reserve’s “higher for longer” guidance was not a negotiating position but an actual policy commitment. Through the first half of 2023, market pricing had consistently reflected an expectation that the Fed would cut rates faster and more aggressively than its own guidance suggested — a gap between market and Fed pricing that reflected the market’s prior experience of a Fed that moved quickly to accommodation when growth slowed. The Q3 data — a US economy that was growing at an annualised rate above 4 percent in the third quarter, despite 525 basis points of rate increases — forced a revision. An economy growing at 4 percent with inflation above target does not require or justify rate cuts. The market updated its terminal rate expectations upward and extended its timeline for cuts, and 10-year yields did the arithmetic.

The 5 percent 10-year move had direct implications for Jamaica’s external financing environment. Jamaica’s sovereign external bonds — US dollar-denominated debt priced at a spread above US Treasuries — repriced as their underlying benchmark moved. The absolute yield on Jamaican external debt rose without any change in the island’s own credit profile or fiscal performance; this was the external rate environment transmitting into sovereign borrowing costs through the mechanical channel of spread-plus-benchmark pricing. The fiscal implications were prospective rather than immediate: the bonds already issued at lower yields were unaffected by the market move; it was new issuance and the refinancing of maturing debt that would face the higher cost. The medium-term fiscal planning assumptions that Jamaica’s budget projections had been built on required revision to reflect the new cost of external capital.

The UAW Strike and the New American Labour Compact

The United Auto Workers strike that began on September 15, 2023 was historic in its structure as much as its settlement: for the first time since the UAW’s founding, the union struck all three Detroit automakers — General Motors, Ford and Stellantis — simultaneously, abandoning the traditional pattern of choosing one target and using that settlement as a template for the others. UAW President Shawn Fain’s tactic was explicitly designed to maximise pressure and minimise the companies’ ability to shift production to unstruck facilities during negotiations. The strike lasted six weeks at its longest at any single company and concluded with settlements that included 25 percent wage increases over four years, cost-of-living adjustment restoration (which had been eliminated in previous contract rounds), and improvements to profit-sharing arrangements that tied worker compensation to the automakers’ financial performance.

The UAW settlement’s macroeconomic significance lay in what it signalled about the American labour market’s new equilibrium. The pre-pandemic labour compact — in which nominal wage growth had consistently run below productivity growth for four decades, compressing labour’s share of corporate income — had been disrupted by the pandemic’s supply shock to labour availability and by the political economy changes that followed. The UAW settlement, in one of the most unionised and visible sectors of the US economy, confirmed that the new wage-price dynamic was structural rather than transitory: organised labour had demonstrated the capacity and willingness to capture a larger share of corporate income than it had in the previous four decades, and the automakers’ profitability — extraordinary during the post-pandemic period of strong demand and constrained supply — had made the economic case for those settlements impossible to resist politically or practically. For the Fed’s inflation outlook, the UAW settlement was a data point in the “higher for longer” column: wages growing at 25 percent over four years in a high-visibility sector do not point toward a rapid return of wage-price dynamics to the pre-pandemic pattern.

Summer 2023: The Confirmation

The Jamaica Tourist Board’s summer 2023 data closed the chapter that the recovery narrative had been building toward since 2021: full-year 2023 stopover arrivals were on track to match or exceed 2019’s record of approximately 2.68 million visitors, representing the first year of arrival volumes at or above the pre-pandemic record since the recovery began. The summer peak season — July and August, the most important months by arrival volume — had delivered occupancy rates in the major resort corridors that matched the 2022 summer’s exceptional performance, itself the strongest since 2019. The aggregate picture through three quarters confirmed what the advance booking data had suggested: the recovery had become a stable baseline, not a continuing rebound from a depressed starting point.

The pricing data through summer 2023 added nuance to the volume confirmation. Hotel revenue per available room in the major corridors remained above 2019 levels in nominal terms — the pricing power that the recovery’s strong demand and Jamaica’s supply constraints had established was being maintained — but the premium over 2019 was narrowing as new supply entered the market and as the exceptional demand of the immediate post-pandemic period normalised. The new supply entering the market through 2023 — hotel projects that had been deferred through the pandemic and were now completing — was being absorbed by the sustained demand without the occupancy rate collapse that excess supply in a weak demand environment would produce. The development thesis that had been underwritten through the recovery was, through summer 2023, being confirmed by the absorption data.

The Bank of Jamaica‘s Q3 posture reflected an institution approaching the end of its own tightening cycle with confidence in the underlying framework’s performance. Domestic CPI had decelerated back toward the 4–6 percent target band as the imported inflation that the 2022 commodity shock had driven into Jamaica’s price level worked through the system. The BOJ’s forward guidance began introducing language about the conditions under which rate reductions would be appropriate — a significant shift from the hiking guidance that had defined communications since August 2021 — without committing to a specific timeline. The Jamaica Tourist Board‘s confirmation of the summer’s arrival data gave the BOJ’s economic growth projections their most solid empirical foundation since before the pandemic.

What This Means

Homeowners enter Q4 2023 at the inflection point that the tightening cycle had been building toward for two years: the BOJ’s signals of approaching rate reductions, the Fed’s terminal rate confirmation, and the global bond market’s pricing of a rate environment that moves lower from here rather than higher all point toward the mortgage rate relief that Jamaica’s property market has been waiting for. The timing of that relief remains uncertain — the BOJ’s data-dependence is genuine, and domestic inflation’s return to target needs to be confirmed rather than projected before the first cut arrives — but the direction is no longer in doubt. Existing homeowners with fixed-rate mortgages have been insulated from the tightening cycle and will benefit from any economic strength the recovery sustains. Those with variable-rate exposure should be watching the BOJ’s quarterly communications for the pivot signal that the forward guidance is beginning to introduce.

Renters in Jamaica’s resort parishes have, through the summer 2023 season, accumulated three consecutive years of sustained hospitality employment that the arrival data now confirms was structural rather than cyclical. The wage recovery that Q1’s data had shown beginning — nominal wages outrunning inflation for the first time in three years — has sustained through Q3’s summer peak, producing the first sustained real wage gains in the tourism sector since before the pandemic. For the renter who has been employed in hospitality through the recovery, Q3 2023 represents the quarter where the accumulated gains — in nominal wages, in real purchasing power as inflation declines, in employment stability — are most tangibly visible in the household budget. The risk to this picture is the degree to which new hotel supply being absorbed by the market affects wage competition in the sector; early evidence suggests the new supply is creating employment rather than redistributing it.

Developers reading Q3 2023 are processing the confirmation that their fundamental thesis was correct: the demand case that underwrote the development pipeline through the tightening cycle’s most difficult phase has been validated by three years of near-2019 or above-2019 arrival volumes, and the new supply entering the market is being absorbed at margins that justify the investment. The 5 percent 10-year Treasury yield is the most direct challenge to the development thesis entering Q4: long-duration assets generally, and income-producing real estate specifically, reprice when the risk-free rate moves to levels that offer competitive returns without development risk. Jamaica’s development projects are not directly exposed to 10-year Treasury yields in the way that US REITs are — the local financing market and the BOJ’s rate cycle are the more direct determinants of Jamaican development economics — but the repricing of global capital toward higher-yield safe assets does affect the foreign direct investment flows and the international development finance terms that supplement domestic financing for larger hospitality projects.

Businesses across Jamaica are, through Q3 2023, operating in the most favourable combination of revenue strength and cost normalisation the sector has seen since before the tightening cycle began. Revenue confirmation: the summer 2023 data has confirmed the third consecutive year of near-record arrivals. Cost normalisation: energy prices below 2022’s Russia-shock peak, food import costs stable, supply chain premiums resolved, BOJ rate cycle at or near its high with cuts on the horizon. The margin recovery that the cost normalisation was expected to deliver is materialising for the businesses that maintained their pricing discipline through the 2022 commodity shock. The risk entering Q4 is whether the US consumer’s balance sheet — carrying more debt than any post-pandemic year, with student loan repayments resumed in October after a three-year pause — begins to show the spending reduction that would affect the winter 2024 booking season.

Diaspora Jamaicans in the United States enter Q4 2023 navigating an economic environment that is better than the headlines about bank failures, debt ceilings and UAW strikes would suggest for the median worker, but less uniform than the aggregate data implies for the technology and professional services workers who constitute the remittance-sending diaspora’s upper income tier. The aggregate US labour market remains resilient: unemployment near fifty-year lows, real wages positive, consumer spending sustaining. The specific labour market for the college-educated diaspora in technology-adjacent roles is more complex: the sector’s layoffs, while not aggregate employment-destroying, have affected the specific roles — product, marketing, operations — where the AI disruption pressure is most acute, and the re-employment terms available to those workers are structurally less favourable than the positions they left. The October restart of student loan repayments — affecting approximately 43 million Americans, with disproportionate representation among younger diaspora workers who entered the labour force in the 2010s — is the most concrete new headwind to diaspora remittance capacity entering Q4.

Outlook

Q4 2023 will be shaped by three intersecting dynamics. The first is the US consumer’s resilience test: with student loan repayments resumed, credit card delinquencies rising from pandemic-era lows, and the cumulative effect of two years of real wage erosion still in household balance sheets, the question is whether the winter 2024 booking season for Jamaica — the most important demand signal for the island’s fiscal year planning — holds at the levels that three years of recovery have established as the new normal. Early Q4 booking data will be the most direct indicator.

The second dynamic is the BOJ’s pivot timing. With domestic inflation returning toward target and the external rate environment stabilised, the conditions for the first rate cut since the tightening cycle began are forming. The BOJ’s framework requires that the cut be data-confirmed rather than projected — the inflation data through Q4 will determine whether the pivot arrives in early 2024 or is deferred to mid-year. The mortgage market’s response to the pivot signal, when it arrives, will be the most consequential single event for Jamaica’s property market since the tightening cycle began.

The third dynamic is whether the arrival confirmation that summer 2023 has delivered translates into the development pipeline acceleration that the confirmed demand case should rationally support. The projects that were deferred through the tightening cycle’s uncertainty are now facing a different calculus: demand confirmed, rate environment at or near its peak, construction costs normalising. The pipeline response to Q3’s confirmation will be visible in planning applications and financing closings through Q4 and into 2024. The structural recovery that the series has tracked since the pandemic is, entering Q4 2023, as thoroughly confirmed as any Jamaica economic trend this series has documented since its inception.

Jamaica Economic Intelligence is an independent data-driven journalism series tracking Jamaica’s economic performance across the housing, tourism, fiscal and monetary sectors. Historical data drawn from Bank of Jamaica, Statistical Institute of Jamaica, International Monetary Fund and Jamaica Tourist Board publications. This report covers Q3 2023: July–September 2023.

Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomesnews Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com