- Columnist Peter Espeut argued that reparations are an established ethical and legal duty
- He pointed to the Coral Gardens settlement, which included a trust fund and a transfer of Crown land
- He insisted any reparations money must directly benefit the descendants of the enslaved
- He warned against mixing up reparations for slavery with reparations for colonialism

As the push for slavery reparations gathers pace across the Caribbean, Gleaner columnist Peter Espeut, a sociologist and Roman Catholic deacon, used his September 2026 column to ask a hard practical question: if money is paid, who should get it?
Espeut began with first principles. “It is an established principle in ethics that, when a wrong is done, there must be reparations,” he wrote, drawing on religious ideas of penance and restitution as well as international law. He cited cases where reparations have been paid, including German compensation to Holocaust survivors, payments of US$20,000 each to Japanese Americans interned during the Second World War, support for victims of apartheid in South Africa, and North Carolina’s compensation for victims of forced sterilisation.
Closer to home, he pointed to the Coral Gardens case. “The Government established a trust fund, pledged financial reparations, and transferred Crown land to the Rastafari Coral Gardens Benevolent Society to support survivors and elders,” he wrote, an example in which land itself formed part of the remedy.
His sharpest point concerned the Jamaican State. “Not one cent of Jamaican black people’s reparations money must go to the Jamaican government for them to waste it,” he wrote, adding: “Any reparations money we get must directly benefit the descendants of slaves.” He also argued that the JLP and PNP owe black Jamaicans billions for how they have squandered Independence, and he drew a clear line between two claims: “Please do not mix up reparations for slavery with reparations for colonialism.”
The column fits a wider debate in Jamaica about landlessness as a legacy of slavery, and about whether any settlement should come as cash, land or investment. For families at home and in the diaspora, Espeut’s argument raises the question of whether any money would build personal wealth, such as land and homes, or disappear into general budgets. For churches, many of which hold land and historical records dating back to the slavery era, the reparations debate may yet reach their own property and archives.
