On 25 September 2020 the Court of Appeal published its written reasons in a land case from Maidstone, Portland. The record is blunt. A certificate of title to farmland there, issued by the Registrar of Titles on 18 November 2010, had been obtained by fraud: the applicant’s sworn declarations left out a competing claim he knew about, held by Iris Anderson, who had farmed the land since about 1957. The trial judge ruled for her in 2014 and the appeal was dismissed in 2017. Mrs Anderson did not live to see the appeal heard; her estate defended it.

That judgment, Anderson v Wan, is one of a stack of public documents that together describe how Jamaica protects people whose land is taken through fraud or registry error. Read together, they show a system whose central promise dates from 1889, whose compensation fund is hedged with conditions that have defeated claimants in court, and whose long promised electronic register keeps moving down the calendar.
The 1889 promise, and who it protects
Jamaica runs a Torrens system, the model that began in South Australia in 1858, in which the register is the truth. Section 68 of the Registration of Titles Act, in force since 1 October 1889, makes a certificate of title “conclusive evidence” that the person named in it owns the land. Section 70 says the registered proprietor holds the land free of other claims “except in case of fraud”. Section 71 tells anyone dealing with a registered owner that they need not look behind the register, again “except in the case of fraud”.
Section 163 shields a bona fide purchaser for value from claims based on fraud earlier in the chain of title. In Frazer v Walker (1966) the Privy Council held, under New Zealand’s Torrens law, that even a forged mortgage, once registered by an innocent lender, gives that lender good title.
A 2012 column by the attorney Gavin Goffe described land in Discovery Bay left by Mary Frankson, who died in 1968. A relative by marriage transferred it to himself in her name, took a $14 million building society mortgage and fled. The court would not void the mortgage: the building society was not required to look behind the title and was found blameless.
Sections 162 to 170: the fund, and its conditions
The Act’s answer for victims like the Frankson heirs is the Assurance Fund. It is funded by contributions when land is first brought under the Act (section 18) and invested in Government securities (section 20). Section 167 says that if the fund cannot meet a judgment, the shortfall is advanced from the Consolidated Fund. The guarantee, in other words, is ultimately the state’s.
The conditions are where the record becomes revealing. Under section 162 the remedy is an action for damages against the person who gained by the fraud or error; the fund pays only where that person is dead, bankrupt or cannot be found within the jurisdiction, with the Registrar named as nominal defendant. Improvements made after the deprivation are excluded from damages, which is why Mr Goffe wrote that the fund would cover only the unimproved value of the Discovery Bay land, most of whose worth lay in the homes built on it. Section 165 requires a written claim to the Registrar, backed by an affidavit or statutory declaration, before any lawsuit. Section 166 requires at least one month’s written notice, and a claimant who loses or discontinues pays the full costs of the defence. Section 168 sets a six year limit from the date of deprivation, extended for people under a disability but capped at thirty years. Section 170 excludes losses caused by a proprietor’s breach of trust.
Each rule has a rationale, but together they make most claims formal litigation few owners could run without a lawyer. Section 165 does allow the Registrar, with the Attorney General’s approval, to admit a claim and have it paid without trial, but none of the documents we read say how often that happens. Gabrielle Gilpin Hudson, president of the Realtors Association of Jamaica and an attorney, told a session for realtors on legal reform, the Jamaica Observer reported on 3 August 2025, that where the Titles Office was careless a claim on its indemnity fund is possible: “you can get some compensation, but it’s very hard to prove”.
What the Court of Appeal did with a claim in 2019
Tancour Construction Jamaica Ltd and others v Registrar of Titles and others, decided by Brooks JA, McDonald Bishop JA and P Williams JA after hearings in January 2019, shows how those conditions operate. The applicants had agreed to buy a lot at Pembroke Hall, St Andrew, from a company that then went defunct, leaving them without a registered title. They complained to the Registrar in about 2009 and sued in 2015; in 2017 the Registrar issued a vesting instrument entitling them to be registered.
The claim was struck out in May 2018 and the Court of Appeal refused leave to appeal. Section 160 gives the Registrar immunity for acts done in good faith. The applicants had not been irrevocably deprived of the land, so they lacked standing under section 162. And they had not met sections 165 and 166: a 2009 letter of complaint was not a written claim supported by a sworn statement, and no month’s notice had been served. Costs went against them.
Seven years to undo one title
Anderson v Wan shows the other route open to a victim: proving fraud and asking the court to cancel the fraudster’s title. Talbert Anderson sold the Maidstone land around 1957 to Maxwell and Iris Anderson, who farmed it and built a house; Talbert died intestate in 1982. In 2008 his nephew, Thomas Anderson, applied for first registration in his own name. His declarations said Talbert had possessed the land until his death and did not mention Iris Anderson’s claim, although in 2007 and 2008 she had sued his brothers, whom the court treated as acting for him, for trespass.
Morrison P, with Sinclair Haynes JA and P Williams JA agreeing, applied the test from Assets Company v Mere Roihi: fraud under the Act means “actual fraud, i.e., dishonesty of some sort”. The court found the omission dishonest. It also noted something the record leaves open: neither the Act nor official guidance expressly requires an applicant for first registration to disclose adverse claims, even though the application must give the Referee enough to judge who is in possession. The title was issued in 2010 and ordered cancelled in 2014; the final written word came in 2020.
The same vulnerability surfaces in current disputes. In August 2026 the Sunday Gleaner reported several contested claims, including a St Thomas resident who found that someone had claimed in 2025, through adverse possession, a half acre he had occupied and maintained for more than 15 years. Under Jamaican law an occupier may claim private land after 12 years of undisturbed possession and Crown land after 60. The newspaper said the National Land Agency did not answer questions submitted on 29 July, including how many such applications it receives each year.
How the World Bank scored the registry
The last World Bank benchmark to score Jamaica’s land registry on its own is the Doing Business 2020 profile for Jamaica, based on 2019 data. On speed and cost Jamaica did well: 19 days and 2.8 per cent of property value to transfer a Kingston property, against a regional average of 63.7 days and 5.9 per cent. The weakness was in the quality of land administration, where Jamaica scored 14 out of 30, above the Latin American and Caribbean average of 12.0 but well short of 23.2 for high income OECD economies.
Jamaica scored zero out of eight on geographic coverage, because not all private plots are registered or mapped, and 3.5 out of eight on dispute resolution: a first instance land dispute takes more than three years, no dispute statistics are published, and there is no national identity database for the registry to check signers against.
The NLA’s own risk register
The National Land Agency’s Strategic Business Plan 2023 to 2027 is candid about the threat. Its risk register lists “receipt of fraudulent documents” as an external risk and “staff aiding in the generation of fraudulent Titles” as an internal one. It rates the residual risk as low, citing security paper, forensic training and electronic titling.
The same plan records 329,769 unregistered parcels as of November 2022, most of them rural. Official figures since then are not on the same footing. At a May 2026 launch of a Korean funded training project, Robert Montague, the minister responsible for land titling, put the island’s total at about 900,000 parcels, of which about 500,000 are titled, which implies roughly 400,000 without a title. Every one must pass through first registration, precisely where the Maidstone fraud happened.
The plan’s output figures show the scale of the task. It reports 5,948 titles in 2021/22 and, for 2022/23, against a target of 10,000, 4,678 titles year to date (one table prints the total as 4,078, though its own components add to 4,678). On 30 September 2026 Cheriese Walcott, the NLA’s chief executive and Commissioner of Lands, told Parliament’s Public Administration and Appropriations Committee, as reported by the Jamaica Observer, that the Survey Division has about 150 staff but only about eight commissioned land surveyors, and that systematic registration has cost about $134,000 a parcel since 2021.
An electronic register that keeps moving down the calendar
The NLA plan and a 2021 ministerial statement both present electronic titling as a defence against fraud. The record of when it will arrive is a sequence of moving dates. The Cabinet Office’s Priority Legislation Programme 2020/21 listed a Registration of Titles (Amendment) Bill and a Strata Titles amendment “To provide for the implementation of an electronic system of Land Title Registration” under Cabinet approval of drafting instructions. In May 2021 Everald Warmington, then minister without portfolio, told the House the project would be implemented three years after a vendor was chosen, and listed a “reduction in the potential incidents of land fraud” among its benefits.
The NLA’s 2023 to 2027 plan set electronic titling “by 2025”, with an evaluation of the implemented system planned for October 2026. In a release dated 27 August 2025 the ministry announced it had signed a contract worth just over US$34 million with Fujitsu Caribbean (Jamaica) Limited, fully funded from the budget, with full adoption expected in 2027 to 2028, after amendments to the Registration of Titles Act. Measured against the 2021 formula, that date is on time; it is the choice of vendor, four years later, and the NLA’s 2025 target that slipped. The Act still has to change before the electronic register can carry legal weight.
What the auditors found inside the agency
The Auditor General’s Annual Report published in December 2025, covering work from December 2024 to November 2025, includes a review of the National Land Agency’s financial statements for 2011/12, a year more than a decade earlier. Auditors found that bank reconciliation statements for five accounts had been delayed by up to 92 months, nearly eight years, in breach of the Financial Instructions, and that three statements were undated, so review and approval could not be confirmed. They warned of “heightened risks of undetected discrepancies, financial errors, and potential fraud”.
It also found about $10.6 million of acquisitions missing from a $93.4 million asset inventory. Management replied that it was automating reconciliations, with a target of March 2027. The NLA section of the report does not mention the Assurance Fund, which under section 20 sits in an account of the Accountant General rather than in the agency’s own books; the Minister may move surplus to the Consolidated Fund so long as it never falls below $30,000. None of the public documents read for this article state its current balance or how many claims it has paid.
How other registries count their losses
Other title registries publish exactly that. HM Land Registry for England and Wales reports indemnity claims by cause every year. In 2024/25 it paid out £1,623,932 gross on 745 claims, and recovered £399,185 from wrongdoers. Fraud and forgery accounted for four of those claims and £398,964, about a quarter of the money. The registry says it identified 86 applications as fraudulent out of 4,429,092 applications to change the register, about 0.0019 per cent, and offers owners a free Property Alert email service.
Ontario legislated after its Court of Appeal held in late 2005 that a mortgage signed under a forged power of attorney bound an innocent homeowner. Its Consumer Protection and Service Modernization Act, 2006 kept owners from losing property to a fraudulent sale or mortgage, let victims claim on the assurance fund without first exhausting other remedies, and raised fines for real estate fraud from C$1,000 to C$50,000. The consolidated Jamaican Act published on the NLA’s website still sets the penalty for fraudulently procuring a certificate at J$1,000, or up to two years in prison, under section 178. Other criminal laws can also apply.
There is a fair case for Jamaica’s design: protecting innocent buyers and lenders keeps mortgage credit flowing and transfers fast, and a fund open to every complaint would invite fraud of its own. The counterargument, implicit in the realtors’ association president’s warning that compensation is hard to prove and in Ontario’s reforms, is that when the protection depends on suing a fraudster who has usually vanished, it protects the system more than the owner.
Questions the record leaves open
- What is the current balance of the Assurance Fund, and how much has it paid out in each of the last ten years?
- How many written claims under section 165 has the Registrar received, admitted or rejected?
- How many applications for first registration based on possession does the NLA receive each year, and how many are later challenged or cancelled for fraud?
- Will the amendments that give legal force to electronic titles also update the penalties in section 178, require disclosure of adverse claims, and add an alert service for registered owners?
- When will the NLA’s accounts be audited up to date?

Visit our YouTube Community ↗