Spared But Not Untouched: Jamaica’s Housing Market After the Caribbean’s Most Devastating Hurricane Season

Jamaica Homes Housing Affordability & Cost of Living Review — January 2018

• Jamaica escaped the catastrophic direct hits of Hurricanes Irma and Maria in September 2017, but the regional devastation has reshaped the Caribbean property landscape
• Puerto Rico, the British Virgin Islands and several Eastern Caribbean islands suffered civilisation-level damage, creating temporary migration flows that touch Jamaica
• Jamaica’s construction sector and tourism industry emerge from 2017 in a stronger position than the regional context might suggest, aided by geography and preparedness
• Bank of Jamaica cuts policy rate further in 2017, bringing mortgage conditions to the most accommodative in the institution’s modern history
• Regional insurance market disruption following Irma and Maria is expected to push property insurance costs higher across the Caribbean, including Jamaica
• Jamaican property market begins 2018 with the strongest macro fundamentals in over a decade and an improving investor confidence picture

The autumn of 2017 was, for the Caribbean, a season of catastrophic reckoning. Hurricanes Irma and Maria — following paths through the island arc with a ferocity that meteorologists will be studying for decades — delivered destruction on a scale that erased entire communities, collapsed infrastructure systems and left hundreds of thousands of Caribbean residents without shelter, power or clean water for months. Puerto Rico, which Maria struck as a Category 4 on September 20, suffered damage estimated by the US Army Corps of Engineers at over USD$90 billion. The British Virgin Islands, Dominica and several of the Leeward Islands were similarly devastated by Irma. The scenes were among the most severe the Caribbean had witnessed since Hurricane Mitch tore through Central America in 1998.

Jamaica, by the particular grace of geography, was largely spared. Irma passed to the north and Maria to the south; both storms delivered tropical storm-force winds and heavy rainfall to parts of the island, but nothing approaching the catastrophic impact that the same storms delivered elsewhere in the region. Jamaica’s housing stock was not materially damaged. Construction activity, which had begun to gather momentum under the JLP government’s growth agenda, continued through the season. Tourism, after a brief period of regional uncertainty, returned to strong booking patterns as Jamaica’s intact facilities and accessible air links became a refuge for travellers who might otherwise have visited the devastated islands.

The Regional Context and Its Local Implications

The devastation of Jamaica’s Caribbean neighbours has implications for the island’s property market that are both immediate and structural. In the immediate term, temporary migration flows from the most severely affected islands — primarily Puerto Ricans with existing family connections in the United States, but also displaced residents of smaller Eastern Caribbean islands without similar migration safety valves — have increased awareness of Caribbean regional vulnerability among the international investor community. That awareness, paradoxically, has tended to direct more rather than less international property investment toward Jamaica, which is perceived as having demonstrated its resilience by surviving the 2017 season relatively intact.

The structural implication that the Jamaican housing market must take more seriously is insurance. The regional reinsurance market’s exposure to the 2017 hurricane season was enormous; preliminary estimates suggest insured losses across the Caribbean of over USD$60 billion. The consequence will be higher reinsurance costs across the region, which will filter through to property insurance premiums in Jamaica over the next one to two years. For mortgage holders — for whom property insurance is a mandatory condition of their loan — higher insurance premiums represent a real increase in the cost of homeownership that is not captured by the interest rate environment that currently looks so favourable.

The BOJ’s Rate Cuts and Their Mortgage Market Effect

The Bank of Jamaica reduced its policy rate through 2017 to levels that have created a mortgage market environment with few historical precedents. NHT mortgage rates, already below commercial levels, are accessible to qualified contributors at rates that make the monthly payment on a JM$10 million loan genuinely manageable for a middle-income formal sector worker. Commercial lenders, competing actively for a mortgage book that the economic recovery has made more creditworthy, have brought their rates closer to the NHT’s than at any point in the post-independence era.

The beneficiaries of this rate environment are, of course, the formally employed with established NHT contributions and available deposits. The substantial portion of the Jamaican working population that is informally employed, self-employed in the cash economy, or occupying untitled land continues to be essentially beyond the reach of any formal mortgage product regardless of the rate environment. The rate cuts have made homeownership more affordable for those who can qualify; they have done nothing for those who cannot. This distinction matters for understanding who the housing market improvement of the past two years has actually served.

Tourism and Its Housing Market Halo

Jamaica’s tourism sector performed strongly in 2017, recording another year of arrival growth and spend improvement. The storm season created a brief pause in bookings — the regional images of devastation temporarily suppressed Caribbean interest among US and European travel markets — but Jamaica’s accessibility, its intact infrastructure and its geographic distance from the worst-affected areas allowed it to recover bookings quickly and to capture some demand that had been redirected from the devastated Eastern Caribbean islands. The year ended with tourism metrics that exceeded pre-storm projections.

The tourism halo on Jamaica’s property market operates through familiar channels: employment income in resort communities, investor interest in short-term rental capacity, and the general confidence effect of an economy whose primary export sector is performing well. All three channels are functioning positively in January 2018. The resort communities of St. James, Westmoreland and St. Ann enter the new year with stronger property market fundamentals than they have had in several years.

What This Means

For buyers, January 2018 is an objectively favourable moment. Rates are excellent. Employment is growing. The macro is stable. Jamaica has just demonstrated its resilience through the region’s worst hurricane season in a decade, and international perception of the island as a credible long-term investment destination has been reinforced by the contrast with its less fortunate neighbours. The principal actionable consideration is to factor the insurance cost outlook into any purchase decision. Post-2017 property insurance costs are moving upward across the Caribbean; buyers should obtain current insurance quotes rather than relying on historical cost assumptions in their affordability calculations.

For property investors, Jamaica’s demonstrated hurricane resilience relative to its competitors is a genuine commercial differentiator. The island’s property market — particularly in the resort segment — should benefit from redirected investor interest from the more seriously exposed Eastern Caribbean markets.

The Outlook: A Fortunate Start to the Year

Jamaica begins 2018 in a position of relative fortune. The macro environment is the best in a decade. The regional competitive position has been enhanced, however tragically, by the suffering of neighbours. The rate environment is at its most accommodative. The construction sector has momentum. What must not be allowed to happen is complacency: the assumption that Jamaica’s good fortune in the 2017 season reduces the island’s long-term hurricane vulnerability, or that the current macroeconomic conditions will persist without the deliberate policy work that sustains them. The year begins well. Keeping it that way requires attention to both the structural work of housing supply and the resilience investment that every Caribbean island owes its housing stock.

This review is produced for informational and journalistic purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal or investment advice.

Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomes Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com