The Recovery Was Real. Then Omicron Landed.

Jamaica Economic Intelligence | Annual Review 2021 | January–December 2021

Key Findings

• Jamaica’s GDP grows for the first time since 2019 — the recovery that the Resilience Corridor made possible is confirmed in the annual accounts, though output remains well below pre-pandemic levels and the distance to full recovery is substantial
• Tourism arrivals reach approximately 1.5 million stopover visitors — more than three times 2020’s pandemic-floor figure and unambiguous proof that the recovery is real, even as the number remains well below the 2.68 million record of 2019
• US consumer price inflation ends the year at 7.0 percent — the highest reading since 1982, devastating the “transitory” thesis and forcing a complete reassessment of the Federal Reserve’s policy trajectory that will define global financial conditions for the next two years
• The Federal Reserve formally announces the taper at its November FOMC meeting, reducing monthly asset purchases by $15 billion per meeting; the pace is subsequently accelerated in December as inflation data continues to exceed projections
• Omicron is designated a Variant of Concern by the WHO on November 26, less than three weeks after the US formally begins withdrawing monetary accommodation; by December it is spreading faster than any previous variant and threatening the winter tourism season that Jamaica’s recovery depends on
• Remittances to Jamaica are estimated to have exceeded $3 billion for the second consecutive year — a structural transformation of the island’s external revenue mix that the pandemic revealed and that is now permanently reshaping the balance of economic power between the diaspora and the domestic tourism sector

It is the last week of November 2021. Jamaica’s winter tourism season has opened and the forward booking data is the best since 2019. The hotels that were dark for nine months before October 2020 have just completed their first genuinely successful summer season in two years and are moving into the season that will, if it holds, make 2021 the year the recovery became undeniable. In South Africa, a new variant has been identified that genomic sequencers are flagging as significantly different from Delta — more mutations on the spike protein than any previous strain. On November 26, the WHO will designate it Omicron and declare it a Variant of Concern. In Washington, Jerome Powell will stand before the Senate Banking Committee on November 30 and retire the word “transitory” — the Federal Reserve’s sustained characterisation of 2021’s inflation surge — in the most consequential walk-back in the institution’s recent history. The recovery that 2021 was supposed to be is real. The conditions under which it was going to consolidate have just been fundamentally disrupted. That is the essential character of 2021: a year in which Jamaica proved it could recover, and the world proved that recovery was not the end of the story.

The Tourism Recovery: Real, Incomplete, Proven

The 2021 tourism story for Jamaica is best understood through three numbers: approximately 500,000 stopover arrivals in 2020 (the pandemic-floor year in which the border was closed for nine months), approximately 1.5 million in 2021, and 2.68 million in 2019. The 2021 number — more than three times the 2020 figure — is the proof of concept that the Resilience Corridor was always meant to generate. The distance from 1.5 million to 2.68 million is the measure of how much recovery remains. Both facts are true simultaneously, and 2021’s primary contribution to the economic record is making them both legible in the data rather than dependent on projections.

The recovery was not uniform across quarters. Q1 2021 delivered the first meaningful stopover numbers since March 2020 — modest, early-adopter volumes from vaccinated travellers who had followed Jamaica’s protocols closely and gone first. Q2 produced the shock: a US leisure travel demand surge that drove TSA checkpoint numbers past two million passengers per day for the first time since before the pandemic and filled Jamaica’s hotels at occupancy levels that revenue management systems had not been calibrated for. Q3 survived the Delta wave’s fourth US surge — the period of maximum risk for the recovery — and emerged with arrivals substantially ahead of Q3 2020, confirming that the Resilience Corridor’s protocols were robust to a more transmissible variant in a partially vaccinated source market. Q4 opened with the strongest winter forward bookings since 2019 and encountered Omicron in its final weeks.

The structural significance of the 2021 recovery extends beyond the arrival numbers. The Jamaica Tourist Board data through the year confirmed that the Resilience Corridor’s design assumptions — pre-departure testing, on-arrival protocols, designated accommodation zones, real-time monitoring — had held under conditions their designers had not anticipated: a Delta wave, a partially vaccinated source market, a rapid increase in volume from Q2 that stressed operational capacity. The protocols were adapted in real time as variant characteristics changed and vaccination rates in source markets evolved. The adaptation worked. That institutional learning — the demonstrated ability to maintain a safe tourism corridor through a genuine pandemic threat — is a competitive asset that will persist beyond the pandemic’s acute phase.

Remittances: The Structural Transformation Confirmed

The 2020 annual review documented the most consequential single-year shift in Jamaica’s external revenue mix in a generation: remittances, which had historically run at approximately 70 percent of tourism earnings, surged past tourism receipts for the first time on record as the border closed and diaspora transfers accelerated. The 2021 data confirms that the 2020 episode was not an aberration caused by the complete cessation of tourism — it was the moment at which a structural trend that had been building for years became visible in a single dramatic comparison.

With tourism receipts recovering through 2021 but remaining well below 2019 levels, and with remittance flows estimated to have reached or exceeded $3 billion for the second consecutive year, the two income streams remain closer in scale than they were before the pandemic and are likely to remain so even as tourism fully recovers. The diaspora’s elevated transfer pace — sustained through their own improving economic conditions in the United States, Canada and the United Kingdom rather than being reduced as their personal finances recovered — reflects a genuine increase in the financial commitment that the Jamaican diaspora maintains to the island’s economy. Whether this reflects affective bonds strengthened by two years of separation, investment motivations accelerated by the pandemic’s demonstration that remote work permits geographic flexibility, or simply the mechanical effect of stimulus payments and strong diaspora employment — the result is the same. Jamaica enters 2022 with a more diversified external revenue base than it has had at any point in its modern economic history.

Inflation and the Fed: The “Transitory” Collapse

The intellectual history of 2021’s most consequential economic debate is a story of institutional credibility tested and, ultimately, surrendered. The Federal Reserve’s characterisation of 2021’s inflation surge as “transitory” — rooted in the genuine analytical case that supply chain disruptions and base effects from pandemic-era price collapses would resolve as the global economy normalised — was maintained through CPI readings of 4.2 percent in April, 5.0 percent in May, 5.4 percent in June, and continued through the summer’s plateau before running into November’s 6.8 percent print. The November number — the highest year-on-year CPI reading since June 1982 — followed by December’s 7.0 percent forced the retirement of the word. On November 30, testifying before the Senate Banking Committee, Jerome Powell said the word “transitory” should be “retired” from the Fed’s vocabulary. The institution that had spent a year assuring markets and policymakers that elevated inflation would resolve without aggressive policy action was now signalling that aggressive policy action was the appropriate response.

The drivers of the December 7.0 percent reading were more broadly distributed than the sector-specific disruptions that had characterised Q2’s surge. Used car prices remained elevated, but shelter costs — which move slowly through the CPI basket because they are measured through rent surveys with contractual lags — were accelerating. Food costs were up. Energy costs were up. The breadth of the December reading was what distinguished it analytically from the transitory case: a truly transitory inflation episode would have shown deceleration in the sector-specific components as supply chains normalised; the December data showed acceleration in the components that reflect sustained demand and wage dynamics. The bond market’s inflation expectations, which had been pricing a more persistent inflation environment than the Fed’s official guidance throughout the year, were vindicated.

For Jamaica, the implications of the “transitory” collapse were both immediate and structural. Immediately, the Fed’s acceleration of its taper pace — from $15 billion per meeting to $30 billion per meeting at the December FOMC, putting the purchase programme on track to reach zero by March 2022 rather than mid-2022 — pulled forward the timetable for rate increases that the Bank of Jamaica had been calibrating against. Structurally, the demonstration that a sustained inflation overshoot could occur in the post-global-financial-crisis monetary environment — contradicting two decades of central bank doctrine that had considered embedded inflation a solved problem — changed the analytical framework within which every emerging market monetary policymaker would be operating for the foreseeable future. The BOJ, which had begun its own tightening cycle in August, was not behind the curve. But the curve had moved.

The BOJ’s First Year of Formal Inflation Targeting

The Bank of Jamaica’s formal inflation targeting framework — established by the BOJ Amendment Act and operationalised through the Monetary Policy Committee structure — completed its first full year under the new mandate in 2021, and did so in the most challenging external environment that a newly adopted inflation targeting framework could have encountered. Domestic inflation exceeded the 4–6 percent target range through the year, driven by global commodity price increases and supply chain cost pass-through, and the MPC responded with the August rate increase that began the tightening cycle. The decision was consistent with the framework’s logic: an inflation overshoot driven by external cost pressures still requires a monetary policy response to prevent inflation expectations from becoming dislodged, even when the domestic demand conditions generating the overshoot are partially imported rather than endogenous.

The BOJ’s management of the exchange rate through 2021’s global rate repricing — the dollar strengthened significantly following the Fed’s June taper signals and subsequent tightening trajectory — demonstrated the institutional capability that the reform period had been building since 2013. The Jamaican dollar, which had been managed through a combination of foreign exchange interventions and accumulated reserve buffers, moved in an orderly fashion through a global environment that produced disorderly moves in less well-positioned emerging market currencies. The currency management framework, combined with the fiscal architecture that the reform period had established and the debt reduction that had reduced Jamaica’s vulnerability to external financing shocks, produced a 2021 external sector outcome that the island’s 2013 position would not have permitted. The reform period’s investment was paying a return in the first year the investment was genuinely tested.

Omicron: The Year Ends on a Familiar Cliffhanger

The identification of the Omicron variant in Botswana and South Africa in mid-November 2021, and its WHO Variant of Concern designation on November 26, produced in its first days the most acute market reaction to a variant announcement since the original pandemic shock. The reasons were legible in the genomic data: Omicron carried more mutations on the spike protein than any previously identified variant, mutations that laboratory analysis suggested might significantly erode the protection that existing vaccines had been providing against infection. The US recorded its first confirmed Omicron case on December 1. By mid-December, Omicron was the dominant strain in South Africa; epidemiologists were projecting it would become dominant in the United States and Europe within weeks.

For Jamaica, the timing was the cruelest irony the pandemic had yet produced. The winter season — historically the island’s strongest quarter, the period that generates the revenue and employment that sustains the annual economic baseline — had opened with the best forward booking data since 2019. The Resilience Corridor had survived Delta. The vaccination rate, which had climbed through the year as COVAX deliveries accelerated and domestic hesitancy was worked through, was higher than at any previous point. The sector that had proved its resilience through four waves was entering its most important quarter when the fifth wave arrived. Whether Omicron’s severity profile — which early South African data was suggesting might be significantly milder than Delta’s despite its greater transmissibility — would permit the winter season to proceed, and whether vaccinated tourists would continue to fly into a destination during a new variant surge, were questions that the year would end having asked but not answered.

What This Means

Homeowners close 2021 in a property market that has recovered more durably than the depth of 2020’s damage had suggested was likely. The employment recovery that the tourism season delivered translated into expanded buyer pools in the parishes and communities most directly connected to the hospitality economy — Montego Bay’s residential market, Negril’s environs, the Saint Ann communities that service the north coast hotel strip. The BOJ’s tightening cycle has begun, but the first rate increases are modest and the NHT mortgage rate environment remains historically supportive. Supply chain disruptions in construction materials — elevated costs for cement, steel, lumber — are limiting new supply at precisely the moment when recovering demand would otherwise incentivise construction. The scarcity that characterises the affordable segment of the market is not diminishing. For homeowners, 2021 is the year the pandemic’s damage to their asset’s value was definitively limited.

Renters have recovered the employment base that the pandemic eliminated. The summer season delivered full-time hours, tips, overtime — the texture of a functioning hospitality economy rather than the bridge payments that the CARE programme had provided in 2020. But the employment recovery has collided with a housing supply gap that two years of suppressed construction activity has widened. Workers whose incomes have recovered are searching for accommodation options that the structural undersupply has not created. Rents in the parishes most affected by the tourism recovery have risen as returning workers compete for a fixed or shrinking stock of affordable units. The employment recovery, for renters, has arrived without the housing security that would make it fully transformative. That gap — between labour market recovery and housing market accessibility — is the unresolved structural challenge that 2022 will inherit from 2021.

Developers exit 2021 with the most favourable fundamental thesis for residential development the island has presented since before the pandemic. The supply gap is wide. The buyer pool has recovered. The tourism employment base — the primary income source for the affordable segment’s buyers — is generating income again at scale. Against those positives, construction cost inflation driven by supply chain disruptions has changed the arithmetic for projects that were underwritten at 2019 material prices. The BOJ’s tightening cycle is beginning to move the cost of development financing. Omicron’s arrival at the winter season’s start introduces uncertainty about the employment recovery’s durability. The opportunity is intact and the demand case is strong. The execution environment is more complex than the thesis. The developers who navigate that complexity successfully in 2022 will be operating in the most favourable demand environment the affordable residential market has presented since before the 2019 record tourism peak.

Businesses across Jamaica end 2021 in stronger competitive positions than they entered the year. The weaker operators who did not survive 2020 have left market share available for those who did. The summer season delivered the operating volumes that sustained cash flow and rebuilt the revenue bases that the pandemic had depleted. Input costs — construction materials, imported consumer goods, shipping — are elevated, and the supply chain environment that drove those costs higher shows no sign of resolving in early 2022. The BOJ’s tightening cycle adds incrementally to working capital costs. Omicron’s arrival at the moment of the winter season’s opening is the variable that the 2022 planning cycle cannot resolve until January’s booking and arrival data begin to arrive. Businesses that navigated 2020 and 2021 successfully have earned the operational resilience to navigate whatever Omicron produces. They also know what a closed border costs.

Diaspora Jamaicans close 2021 having sustained — and, in the aggregate, increased — their financial commitment to the island through the second year of a pandemic that their home country weathered with less institutional damage than many had feared was possible. The remittance flows that hit record levels in 2020 appear to have remained elevated or grown further in 2021, in an environment where the diaspora’s own economic position was recovering strongly. Those who visited Jamaica this year — and the booking data suggests many did — found a functioning tourism infrastructure, a stable political environment, and an island that was recognisably the place they had left, rather than the diminished shadow that two years of closed-border journalism had sometimes projected. The confidence the diaspora expresses in Jamaica through its financial flows reflects something more than sentiment. It reflects an assessment that the reform period’s investments were real, that the institutional architecture holds, and that the property and community ties that remittances sustain are worth sustaining.

Outlook for 2022

2022 will be defined by two questions whose answers are not yet available as this review is written. The first is whether Omicron’s severity profile is mild enough — and the vaccinated traveller’s confidence resilient enough — to permit the winter season to proceed without the disruption that previous variant surges had threatened but not delivered. The early South African data is suggestive of a milder disease course in vaccinated populations; whether that finding translates to Jamaica’s source market populations and to the booking and cancellation behaviour of people planning Caribbean holidays is a data question that January will begin to answer.

The second question is the pace of the Federal Reserve’s subsequent tightening cycle. The December FOMC’s acceleration of the taper pace — putting zero asset purchases on track for March 2022 rather than mid-year — sets up a first rate increase as early as March 2022. The inflation data that arrives through Q1 2022 will determine whether the Fed moves aggressively or continues the measured pace that its November guidance had implied. For Jamaica, the sovereign financing cost implications of a faster-than-expected US tightening cycle are real: the spread on Jamaican external bonds, the cost of rolling over maturing obligations, and the investment environment for the foreign direct investment that the tourism sector’s expansion requires are all affected by the level and trajectory of US interest rates. The BOJ has been calibrating its own tightening cycle against the Fed’s expected path. If the Fed’s path accelerates, the BOJ’s calibration will need to be revisited.

What 2021 has established, against those uncertainties, is that the foundations are sound. Jamaica proved it could reopen safely and recover meaningfully in the same year that it began its first formal inflation targeting cycle, survived a fourth COVID-19 wave, managed a dollar strengthening episode without a currency crisis, and absorbed the supply chain disruptions that raised costs for every import-dependent economy in the world. The recovery is real. The conditions under which it continues are more complex than the conditions under which it began. That has been true every year since the reform period started. It remains true entering 2022.

Jamaica Economic Intelligence is an independent data-driven journalism series tracking Jamaica’s economic performance across the housing, tourism, fiscal and monetary sectors. Historical data drawn from Bank of Jamaica, Statistical Institute of Jamaica, International Monetary Fund and Jamaica Tourist Board publications. This report covers the full year 2021: January–December 2021.

Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomesnews Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com