- Opposition urges consultation before bill reaches Parliament
- Churches fear tithe rules could criminalise leaders
- International watchdog pressure is driving the reform
- Church land, schools and halls fall within scope
Kingston, Jamaica, 3 October 2026. Jamaica’s churches are being drawn into a debate over how the state regulates nonprofit organisations. Last week the parliamentary Opposition urged the Government to consult faith groups before tabling proposed legislation for the sector. Its concern is that provisions on the collection of tithes and offerings could expose church leaders to criminal liability. The issue matters beyond the pulpit. Churches are among Jamaica’s oldest and largest holders of land, schools, halls and community buildings, and the rules on how they handle money will shape how that property is managed, protected and developed.
What is being proposed
The bill has not yet been published. What is known is that the Government is tightening the framework for nonprofit organisations, either through new legislation or an overhaul of the Charities Act of 2013. Much of the pressure comes from the Financial Action Task Force, the international standard setter on money laundering and terrorist financing. It has pressed countries to ensure that charitable status cannot be used as cover for moving money to terrorist organisations.
In its statement the Opposition said faith leaders had been sidelined in earlier discussions on the Charities Act, and that nonprofits were already struggling under heavier compliance requirements. The Opposition Spokesperson on Social Protection and Social Transformation said legislation “of this magnitude must be shaped with the people it affects, not imposed upon them.” She added that the church “is not the enemy of good governance” but one of the country’s strongest partners, and that any response “must be proportionate and practical.” The party invited the Government to review the bill with the Jamaica Umbrella Group of Churches before it is tabled.
The Gleaner took a similar line in an editorial this week. It called for a white paper explaining the problem the law is meant to solve, frank conversations with the sector, and a joint select committee that invites public submissions. The paper noted that Jamaican charities receive more than J$40 billion each year, and warned against a single regime for every organisation that would load heavy burdens onto small community groups.
No formal Government response to the Opposition’s call had been published at the time of writing, and no date has been announced for the bill to be tabled.
Why churches are watching closely
Under the Charities Act, the advancement of religion is a recognised charitable purpose. Registered charities can qualify for relief from property tax, stamp duty, transfer tax and other charges. Separately, the Property Tax Act exempts churches, burial grounds and rectories on parcels of under one acre. For many congregations, especially small rural churches on modest lots, these arrangements are part of what keeps the doors open.
Any change to how nonprofits are registered, audited or supervised therefore touches the economics of church property. A congregation that cannot keep up with new reporting requirements could, in principle, find its registration or its exemptions harder to hold on to. Large denominations with professional administrators will probably adapt. The many small independent churches that make up much of Jamaica’s religious landscape may find the change far harder.
The property question
Churches in Jamaica hold land built up over centuries through missionary purchase, donation and trusteeship. A large part of the school system still sits on church land, with denominations owning many schools that are run in partnership with the state. After Hurricane Melissa last October, church halls served as classrooms and shelters, and the Government has said church facilities will be built into the national shelter strategy.
The past year has also brought a growing discussion about whether some church land could support housing, through long leases, joint ventures or charitable development arms. Every one of those models depends on clear governance, transparent accounts and the confidence of lenders. Proportionate regulation could strengthen that confidence. Blunt regulation could push congregations further away from formal structures at the very moment some are being encouraged to bring their land and finances into the open.
Dean Jones, founder of Jamaica Homes, said: “Churches that want a bigger role in housing will need stronger governance anyway. The question is whether the law helps them get there or pushes them away.”
A regional balancing act
The tension is not unique to Jamaica. The Cayman Islands updated its law last year to bring churches more clearly within its nonprofit rules, and governments across the Caribbean face the same international reviews. Barbados, meanwhile, is taking a different route, with its government this week urging faith organisations to apply to a dedicated grant facility for their community work. The challenge for Jamaica is to satisfy international reviewers without treating the Sunday offering plate as a financial crime risk.
What comes next
If the bill goes to a joint select committee, churches, charities and property professionals will be able to make submissions. For Jamaica’s housing and land outlook, the outcome matters more than it first appears. Churches remain among the few institutions that combine land, local trust and long time horizons. How the state chooses to regulate them will help decide whether those assets are drawn into the national effort on housing and resilience, or left idle behind a wall of paperwork.
Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomesnews Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com
Visit our YouTube Community ↗