After Michelle: Q4 2001 and the Hurricane Season That Rattled the Boom

Briefing

• Hurricane Michelle caused coastal surge damage along Jamaica’s low-lying shorelines.
• Recent resort construction in surge-prone areas scrutinised after storm impacts.
• Engineers noted inadequate setback distances at several new development sites.
• ODPEM called for updated coastal hazard mapping to inform planning decisions.
• Insurance industry adjustments to coastal property risk ratings noted post-Michelle.

Hurricane Michelle made landfall in Cuba as a major Category Four hurricane in November 2001, and while Jamaica received only the peripheral effects of the storm, the coastal surge and rainfall it generated were sufficient to cause damage along several sections of the island’s low-lying south and north coast. The damage was uneven — some recently constructed coastal properties weathered the conditions without significant impact while others sustained damage that raised questions about their siting and construction standards.

The Office of Disaster Preparedness and Emergency Management had been developing updated coastal hazard mapping that would provide more detailed storm surge inundation data for different storm intensities along Jamaica’s coast. The Michelle event provided a real-world data point against which to calibrate the mapping work, and ODPEM used it as an argument for accelerating the mapping programme’s completion. The connection between hazard mapping and development approvals — using the maps to establish setback requirements and floor elevation standards for development in hazard-prone areas — was the policy link that would make the mapping investment practically valuable, and ODPEM was pushing for that link to be formalised in the planning system.

The Insurance Signal

The insurance industry’s response to hurricane seasons in the early 2000s carried information about coastal development risk that the market was encoding more systematically than the planning system was. Insurers who had paid hurricane damage claims across the Caribbean were adjusting their risk assessments for coastal properties in ways that reflected the combination of more intensive storm seasons and expanding development in exposed coastal zones. Premium adjustments and coverage restrictions for properties below certain elevation thresholds or within certain distances of the shoreline were signals about physical risk that were legible to property investors even when the planning system’s hazard standards did not explicitly encode the same information.

The paradox that emerged in the post-Michelle period was that the insurance industry was, in some respects, doing more to communicate coastal hazard information to coastal property investors than the planning system was. The planning system was approving development in areas that the insurance industry was assigning elevated risk; the market signal of high insurance premiums or restricted coverage was reaching developers as information that the approvals process had not required them to incorporate.

Related: Property Market Analysis | ODPEM Jamaica

Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomesnews Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com