Jamaica Economic Intelligence | Q3 2006 | July–September 2006
Key Findings
- El Niño suppresses Atlantic hurricane season; Jamaica spared entirely
- Crude oil retreats from US$77 July peak to US$60 by late September
- Stopover arrivals track 7% above Q3 2005 toward second annual record
- Bank of Jamaica cuts benchmark rate to 10.0% as inflation eases to 9.2%
- Homicides reach 1,280 through September; full-year record now likely
- NHT mortgage approvals hit J$2.6 billion for the quarter, another high
The Atlantic hurricane season of 2006 arrived quietly and departed the same way. An El Niño event building in the Pacific suppressed storm formation across the Caribbean basin, and Jamaica — a nation that had watched Hurricane Ivan’s catastrophic passage just two years earlier — sailed through July, August and September without a named storm making landfall anywhere near its shores. The reprieve allowed the tourism sector to record its strongest third quarter in history, pushed construction higher for a third consecutive year, and gave the Bank of Jamaica the confidence to resume cutting interest rates. Oil prices, after touching a then-record US$77.05 per barrel in late July on Middle East tensions, retreated sharply through August and September, easing the inflation burden that had held monetary policy cautious since late 2004. By the close of the quarter Jamaica’s economy looked, for perhaps the first time in a decade, like one that was building genuine momentum rather than simply recovering from the last crisis.
The Hurricane That Never Came
The 2006 Atlantic hurricane season produced nine named storms, five of which reached hurricane intensity — well below the thirty-year average of twelve named storms and six hurricanes. The Colorado State University forecast issued in June 2006 had called for a below-normal season on the back of a developing El Niño, and that prediction proved accurate. For Jamaica, the implications were substantial. The 2004 season had delivered Ivan; the 2005 season had sent Katrina, Rita and Wilma through the Gulf of Mexico even as Emily grazed Jamaica’s southern coast. Two consecutive years of hurricane anxiety had dampened advance bookings, complicated insurance underwriting for the construction sector and added a weather-risk premium to any investment decision involving coastal assets.
With the 2006 season effectively a non-event, that premium unwound. Hoteliers reported that cancellation rates through August and September — traditionally the most hurricane-sensitive booking months — ran at their lowest levels since before Ivan. The Jamaica Tourist Board estimated that stopover arrivals for the July-to-September quarter reached approximately 385,000, roughly seven percent above the same period in 2005. Combined with the strong first half, the full-year stopover count appeared on track to exceed 1.45 million for the first time, surpassing the record set in 2005. Cruise passenger calls also remained elevated, with Falmouth’s new pier infrastructure and the Port of Ocho Rios handling increased traffic without the capacity bottlenecks that had constrained growth in earlier years.
The economic multiplier of an undisturbed summer was visible across the economy. Retail sales in resort towns — Montego Bay, Negril, Ocho Rios — reported double-digit year-on-year gains through August. Foreign exchange inflows from tourism tracked roughly fifteen percent above the corresponding quarter of 2004, before Ivan had reset the baseline. For a country whose debt service obligations consumed more than half of government revenues, every additional dollar of foreign exchange mattered: it supported the Bank of Jamaica’s reserve position and reduced the pressure on the Jamaica dollar, which ended the quarter holding near J$66.50 to the US dollar.
Oil’s Retreat and What It Means for Inflation
Crude oil had ended Q2 2006 near US$73 per barrel, already elevated by the Israel-Hezbollah conflict that had erupted in July. On July 14, 2006 — three days after Hezbollah captured two Israeli soldiers along the Lebanese border — Brent crude touched US$77.05 per barrel, a price that alarmed policymakers in oil-importing nations across the Caribbean. Jamaica, which imported virtually all of its petroleum, faced a direct hit: higher oil meant higher electricity tariffs from the Jamaica Public Service Company, higher transport costs across every sector of the economy, and upward pressure on the Consumer Price Index that had already run above ten percent for most of the preceding eighteen months.
Then, unexpectedly, prices fell. A ceasefire in Lebanon, rising US petroleum inventories, and early evidence of demand destruction combined to push Brent crude from its July peak back toward US$60 by late September — a decline of more than twenty percent in ten weeks. For Jamaica the relief was immediate and measurable. The Planning Institute of Jamaica estimated that the oil import bill for Q3 2006 came in below its Q2 projection by approximately US$45 million, a meaningful sum for an economy whose total imports ran at roughly US$4.5 billion annually. Consumer price inflation, which had peaked above eleven percent in early 2006, eased to an estimated 9.2% year-on-year by September — still above the Bank of Jamaica’s medium-term target range of four to six percent, but moving in the right direction.
Jamaica’s PetroCaribe arrangement with Venezuela, which had come into force in September 2005, continued to provide a structural cushion. Under the agreement, Jamaica paid approximately sixty percent of the invoice value of its Venezuelan crude purchases on delivery, with the remaining forty percent financed over seventeen years at two percent interest. The PetroCaribe Fund — the vehicle through which the deferred payment proceeds were channelled into social and economic investment — was accumulating capital steadily. By the end of Q3 2006 the fund had disbursed modest amounts toward road maintenance, agricultural development and social housing, though the scale of the programme remained small relative to the economy’s infrastructure needs. The Ministry of Finance was simultaneously managing the fiscal implications carefully: PetroCaribe’s deferred obligations were counted as government debt, and any expansion of the programme required balancing the development benefit against the long-term liability it created.
The Bank of Jamaica Moves
With inflation declining and foreign exchange reserves stable, the Bank of Jamaica’s Monetary Policy Committee delivered what markets had anticipated: a twenty-five basis point reduction in the benchmark rate, bringing it from 10.5% to 10.0%. The cut — the second of the current easing cycle after a pause through Q2 — was announced in September 2006 and took effect immediately for overnight instruments. Governor Derick Latibeaudière noted in his statement that the decision reflected confidence in the inflation trend but cautioned that the central bank stood ready to reverse course if oil prices rebounded or if fiscal dynamics deteriorated unexpectedly.
For the commercial banking sector the cut had a lagged but visible effect. The average weighted lending rate in Jamaica had declined from its post-FINSAC peak above twenty percent to approximately eighteen percent by Q3 2006 — still high by international standards but lower than at any point since the mid-1990s. The National Housing Trust, which lent at rates set administratively rather than by the interbank market, held its standard mortgage rate at seven percent for qualifying contributors, maintaining its position as the lowest-cost formal mortgage product available in the island. NHT loan approvals for the quarter were estimated at J$2.6 billion — a quarterly record — driven by continued strong demand from first-time buyers in the greater Kingston area and in the western parishes surrounding Montego Bay. The construction sector, which had expanded continuously since Ivan’s reconstruction impetus began in late 2004, showed no sign of fatigue: cement imports remained elevated and the number of building permits issued by parish councils in Q3 2006 ran approximately twelve percent above Q3 2005.
Bauxite, Remittances and the Fiscal Position
Jamaica’s bauxite and alumina sector contributed approximately US$150 million in export earnings for the quarter, broadly in line with Q2 levels. Aluminium prices on the London Metal Exchange held relatively steady through the period, and the three major producers — Alcan’s Kirkvine and Ewarton works, and the Alpart plant in Nain — operated at or near capacity. The Jamaican government’s bauxite levy, tied to aluminium prices under the 1974 Mining Act formula, generated consistent revenue that flowed to the Jamaica Bauxite Institute and from there into the consolidated fund.
Remittance flows from the Jamaican diaspora — a constituency that Prime Minister Portia Simpson-Miller had made a signature priority — reached an estimated US$480 million for the quarter, on track for an annual total above US$1.9 billion. The United States remained the dominant source, with the United Kingdom and Canada also significant. The Bank of Jamaica monitored remittance flows closely as both a macroeconomic stabiliser and an indicator of diaspora confidence. The slight acceleration in Q3 2006 remittances, compared to Q3 2005, suggested that the diaspora’s view of Jamaica’s prospects remained constructive despite the crime situation.
The central government’s fiscal position improved marginally in Q3 on the back of stronger-than-projected tax revenues. The General Consumption Tax — Jamaica’s VAT equivalent — returned higher-than-budgeted receipts as consumer spending held firm, and income tax collections from the expanding formal employment base in the tourism and construction sectors exceeded projections. The primary surplus — the measure that excludes interest payments and that the International Monetary Fund used as the headline fiscal target — held near the 12% of GDP range that the government had committed to maintaining. Debt-to-GDP continued its gradual decline, estimated by the PIOJ at approximately 137% at the end of September, down from approximately 139% at year-end 2005. The improvement was real but incremental: at current growth rates and interest rate levels it would take many years to bring the ratio to levels that international lenders considered sustainable.
Crime: The Persistent Constraint
Jamaica’s homicide count reached 1,280 through the end of September 2006, putting the island on pace to surpass 1,700 for the full year — a new record. The Jamaica Constabulary Force attributed the continued rise to garrison politics, the narcotics trade, and what investigators described as a worsening cycle of retaliatory violence in West Kingston and sections of Spanish Town. The government’s Community Renewal Programme, launched earlier in the year under the Simpson-Miller administration, was beginning to deploy resources in some of the most affected communities, but community workers and social scientists were cautious about projecting its impact on homicide rates within the short term.
The economic cost of crime was increasingly well-documented. World Bank analyses estimated that Jamaica’s homicide rate — which had now risen to approximately sixty-four per 100,000 population, among the highest in the world — imposed a GDP drag of between three and five percentage points annually through reduced foreign direct investment, diverted public resources toward security spending, higher private security costs borne by businesses, and disruption to the normal functioning of communities where economic activity was concentrated. For every investor persuaded by Jamaica’s tourism performance and its improving macroeconomic trajectory, another was deterred by crime statistics that appeared routinely in international business media. The IDB’s country strategy for Jamaica for 2006–2009 explicitly identified crime reduction as a prerequisite for sustained growth above three percent, a target Jamaica had not hit since the early 1990s.
What This Means
Homeowners and prospective buyers are in the most favourable borrowing environment since before FINSAC. The BOJ’s cut to 10.0% will filter through to commercial lending rates over the coming months, and the NHT continues to offer seven percent mortgages to qualifying contributors. Property values in resort-adjacent communities — Port Antonio, Runaway Bay, Negril — are rising on the back of tourism’s third-quarter strength, making the calculus of buying now versus waiting a genuinely close call.
Renters face continued upward pressure on accommodation costs in Kingston and the resort towns as housing demand outpaces supply. The NHT’s record lending is creating new homeowners, which removes units from the rental pool even as internal migration toward economic centres continues. Renters in garrison-adjacent communities face the additional burden of elevated security costs and limited mobility that crime imposes on household decision-making.
Developers and contractors are operating in a sweet spot: construction costs have risen with cement and steel prices but revenue from completed projects — particularly in the hotel and residential sectors — has risen faster. The absence of a hurricane this season means that there will be no Ivan-style interruptions to project timelines, and the pipeline of approved building permits entering Q4 is the strongest in at least a decade. The risk to watch is labour cost inflation as skilled tradespeople find alternatives in the growing formal economy.
Businesses across sectors will welcome the oil price retreat, which reduces transport and electricity costs directly. The JPS tariff mechanism will lag the oil price decline by one to two quarters, meaning the full benefit of the US$60 crude price will not appear on electricity bills until early 2007. Crime remains the dominant cost that no rate cut or oil price decline can offset: private security, losses to theft, and the productivity drag of employee anxiety in affected communities continue to consume margins that would otherwise fund expansion.
Diaspora investors watching the Jamaica market from North America and the United Kingdom will see a Q3 2006 picture that is better than almost any quarter since the mid-1990s: inflation declining, rates falling, tourism booming, no hurricane damage. The exchange rate near J$66.50 means that US or UK dollar holdings convert to meaningful Jamaican purchasing power. Real estate investment from the diaspora — already significant in Mandeville, Portmore and the resort communities — is likely to accelerate if the macroeconomic trend holds through year-end.
Outlook
Jamaica enters the final quarter of 2006 with genuine momentum that would have been difficult to predict twelve months ago. The hurricane season’s failure to materialise has removed the single largest external risk that threatened the economic narrative. Oil below US$65 — where futures markets suggest it will remain through early 2007 — will continue to ease inflation and give the Bank of Jamaica room for at least one more rate reduction before year-end, likely to 9.75%. Full-year stopover arrivals above 1.45 million now appear probable, which would make 2006 the second consecutive record year for tourism and the first time in the industry’s history that records were broken in back-to-back years.
The risks are crime, debt and the possibility of an external shock. Jamaica’s homicide trajectory is on course for a new annual record that will make international headlines at year-end and complicate the tourism marketing narrative for 2007. The debt-to-GDP ratio, while declining, remains at levels that leave the government with little fiscal room to respond to shocks: a single large hurricane, a sharp commodity price reversal, or a tightening of global credit conditions could quickly unwind the progress of the past two years. The IMF’s Article IV consultation for 2006, expected to be published in early 2007, will assess the sustainability of the current fiscal path and is unlikely to give an unqualified endorsement until debt dynamics improve more decisively.
For now, however, the evidence favours cautious optimism. Jamaica’s economy in Q3 2006 looks like an economy that has earned — through disciplined fiscal management, a favourable external environment and a remarkable run of luck with the weather — a moment of genuine, if fragile, confidence.
Jamaica Economic Intelligence is an independent data-driven journalism series published by Jamaica Homes News. Every article is grounded in official publications from the Bank of Jamaica, the Planning Institute of Jamaica, the Statistical Institute of Jamaica, the Ministry of Finance, and multilateral sources including the IMF, World Bank and IDB. No article constitutes financial, legal or investment advice.
Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomesnews Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com
Visit our YouTube Community ↗