Jamaica Economic Intelligence | Q3 2007 | July–September 2007
Key Findings
- Hurricane Dean passes south of Jamaica August 19 as Category 5; agricultural damage estimated US$85 million
- JLP wins September 3 election 32–28 seats; Bruce Golding becomes Prime Minister after 18 years of PNP rule
- Oil reaches US$79 per barrel by quarter-end, pushing inflation above 11% year-on-year
- Global credit crisis accelerates: BNP Paribas freezes funds, Northern Rock collapses in UK
- BOJ holds benchmark at 9.5%; any easing cycle resumption now depends on oil trajectory
- Tourism Q3 arrivals fall 8% versus prior year in Dean’s immediate aftermath; cruise calls disrupted
In fourteen days at the end of August and the beginning of September 2007, Jamaica experienced two events whose combined weight would define the country’s economic and political trajectory for years. The first was Hurricane Dean — one of the most powerful Atlantic storms of the modern era — whose northern eyewall swept across the island on 19 August, destroying banana plantations, flooding coastal communities, damaging road infrastructure and interrupting the tourism season at its most lucrative moment. The second was the general election of 3 September, in which the Jamaica Labour Party ended eighteen years of unbroken People’s National Party governance, winning 32 of 60 parliamentary seats to install Bruce Golding as the island’s seventh Prime Minister. And framing both: a global financial system in the early stages of what would become its worst crisis since the Great Depression, signalling its distress through frozen credit markets in Paris and a bank run in Newcastle that no Caribbean policymaker had yet connected to their own fiscal vulnerabilities.
Hurricane Dean: The Storm That Broke the Lucky Run
Jamaica had not sustained a direct major hurricane strike since Ivan in September 2004. The two intervening seasons — 2005’s deadly but geographically removed season and 2006’s El Niño-suppressed near-silence — had allowed the island to rebuild its infrastructure, expand its hotel capacity and enter 2007 with an undamaged tourism product. That run ended on 19 August 2007, when Hurricane Dean — by then a Category 5 storm with sustained winds of 165 miles per hour — passed approximately seventy miles south of Kingston, exposing Jamaica to the full destructive force of its northern eyewall as the storm tracked toward its eventual landfall on Mexico’s Yucatan Peninsula.
The damage was severe but — crucially — not catastrophic in the Ivan sense. Unlike Ivan, whose eye had passed directly over the island, Dean’s centre remained offshore, sparing Jamaica the worst of its storm surge and the most intense wind damage to urban and resort infrastructure. Kingston sustained significant flooding, several communities in the southern parishes suffered roof damage and infrastructure disruption, and the road network in St. Elizabeth, Westmoreland and Portland required emergency repair in Dean’s immediate aftermath. The cost of infrastructure damage was estimated at approximately US$30 million by the Planning Institute of Jamaica.
The agricultural sector was hit far harder. Jamaica’s banana industry — already under structural pressure from the European Union’s phased elimination of preferential import arrangements for Caribbean producers — suffered near-total destruction of its standing crop in the parishes most exposed to Dean’s outer bands. The Jamaica Banana Board estimated that ninety percent of the export crop had been lost, with replanting required before any commercial production could resume — a process that typically required six to nine months. Sugar cane fields in St. Elizabeth and Westmoreland were also damaged, though harvest timing reduced the severity of the loss relative to a mid-season strike. Total agricultural damage was estimated at approximately US$55 million, bringing the combined agricultural and infrastructure loss to approximately US$85 million — significant but manageable for an economy whose GDP had crossed US$10 billion.
The tourism sector suffered a short but sharp disruption. August is the peak of the Caribbean hurricane season and a period of naturally lower occupancy than the winter months, but it is also the tail end of the summer travel season when North American families take final holidays before school resumption. In the week following Dean’s passage, hotel cancellation rates spiked across the resort parishes, several cruise lines diverted scheduled Jamaica calls to alternative ports, and the Jamaica Tourist Board launched an emergency communications campaign to assure prospective visitors that the island’s major resorts were open and operational. Q3 stopover arrivals fell approximately eight percent below Q3 2006 — the first year-on-year quarterly decline in three years — though the annual total, bolstered by the strong first half, remained on course to surpass 1.5 million for the first time, preserving the third consecutive annual record.
The JLP Election Victory
Jamaica’s general election on 3 September 2007 was the most consequential political event in the island’s recent history. After eighteen consecutive years — four election victories beginning in 1989 under Michael Manley and continuing under P.J. Patterson and then Portia Simpson-Miller — the People’s National Party was voted out of office. The Jamaica Labour Party, led by Bruce Golding, won 32 of 60 parliamentary seats to the PNP’s 28, a margin that was decisive in its parliamentary implications if slender in its popular vote interpretation. Golding was sworn in as Prime Minister within days of the result, beginning the first JLP administration since Edward Seaga’s government lost power in 1989.
The economic inheritance was formidable in its complexity. Golding’s government received an economy that was, on the surface metrics, performing better than at any point since independence: GDP growing, tourism breaking records, debt-to-GDP declining, the exchange rate stable, the banking system robust. Below the surface, the structural constraints were unchanged and, in some ways, worsened: the debt-to-GDP ratio remained above 130%, the homicide rate was among the highest in the world, the fiscal space for public investment was minimal, and the global financial environment — as the events of August had made unmistakably clear — was turning in ways that threatened to raise external borrowing costs precisely when Jamaica needed to refinance substantial near-term maturities.
Golding moved quickly to assemble his cabinet and signal economic priorities. The Ministry of Finance went to Audley Shaw, a former shadow finance minister whose public commitments to fiscal discipline and debt management provided immediate reassurance to bond markets and multilateral lenders. The early signals from the new government were of continuity rather than rupture on the macroeconomic framework: the primary surplus target would be maintained, IMF engagement would continue, and the debt reduction trajectory would be respected. The political change, whatever its social policy implications, would not be allowed to translate into fiscal loosening that could unravel the decade of stabilisation work that the PNP had undertaken since FINSAC.
Oil Approaches US$80 and the Global Credit Turn
Crude oil prices continued their year-long ascent through Q3 2007, reaching approximately US$79 per barrel by the end of September — a thirty percent increase from the US$61 level at which the quarter had opened. The drivers were structural as well as cyclical: demand from China and India showed no signs of moderating, OPEC production capacity was constrained, and the geopolitical risk premium from Iran and Nigeria remained elevated. For Jamaica, the arithmetic was stark. Every US$10 increase in the oil price added approximately US$120 million annually to the import bill at current consumption volumes — a burden that fell disproportionately on the fiscal accounts through fuel duty relief measures and on households through electricity and transport costs.
Consumer price inflation crossed ten percent on an annual basis by August 2007 and reached approximately 11.5% year-on-year by September — the highest reading since 2005. The Bank of Jamaica held its benchmark overnight rate at 9.5% but signalled clearly that any further easing was suspended pending a decisive turn in inflation. The negative real interest rate environment — with inflation running above the benchmark rate for the first time since the easing cycle began — was an uncomfortable position for the central bank, though currency markets responded to the BOJ’s signalling with appropriate discipline: the Jamaica dollar held near J$70 to the US dollar by quarter-end, representing modest but controlled depreciation from the J$66–68 range of 2006.
The global credit backdrop shifted materially through August and September. On 9 August 2007 — nine days before Dean struck — BNP Paribas suspended redemptions from three of its funds exposed to US asset-backed securities, citing an inability to value the underlying assets. The announcement triggered the first serious liquidity crisis in global interbank lending since the mid-1990s, with the overnight LIBOR rate spiking as banks became unwilling to lend to one another without knowing the full extent of subprime-related losses on counterparty balance sheets. On 13 September 2007, the Bank of England provided emergency liquidity support to Northern Rock — the British mortgage lender that had become dependent on short-term wholesale funding — triggering the first British retail bank run since 1866 as depositors queued to withdraw savings. The US Federal Reserve cut the federal funds rate by fifty basis points on 18 September in an emergency response to deteriorating credit conditions — a move that signalled, unmistakably, that the world’s central banks were responding to a systemic rather than merely cyclical disruption.
For Jamaica, the transmission channels were clear in structure if uncertain in timing. The BOJ’s research department and the PIOJ were both monitoring Jamaica’s sovereign spread — the premium over US Treasury yields that investors demanded to hold Jamaican external bonds — with particular attention. Through Q3 2007 that spread remained broadly stable, suggesting that global investors had not yet begun the general emerging market risk reduction that would accompany a full-blown credit crisis. But the direction of travel was clear: if global risk appetite contracted materially, Jamaica’s external financing costs would rise, and the government’s ability to refinance its large upcoming debt maturities at affordable rates would come under pressure.
Construction, NHT and the Housing Market
Despite Dean’s disruption to the construction calendar in the affected parishes, the sector overall continued to expand. The National Housing Trust reported Q3 mortgage disbursements of approximately J$2.5 billion — modestly below the record Q1 and Q2 pace but still well above pre-2006 levels. The pipeline of approved projects entering Q3 was large enough to sustain activity even as some site work was interrupted by Dean’s flooding in the southern parishes. Hotel construction in Montego Bay and Negril, insulated from Dean’s worst effects by their northern and western coastal positions, continued largely uninterrupted.
Property values in Kingston’s established residential markets held firm through the quarter despite the election transition uncertainty and the hurricane impact. The resort parish markets — St. James in particular — showed modest softening in the weeks immediately after Dean as prospective buyers paused, but recovery was rapid once the tourist board’s communications campaign demonstrated that Montego Bay and its environs were fully operational. Diaspora interest in Jamaican property — which had been rising through 2006 and into 2007 — showed no material slowdown from the hurricane, and several major diaspora-financed housing developments that had been delayed pending the election outcome announced new timelines in the weeks after the JLP victory.
What This Means
Homeowners in the southern parishes affected by Dean face repair costs, disrupted livelihoods if employed in agriculture, and the psychological burden of the second major hurricane in four years. Those in Kingston and the resort parishes that escaped significant structural damage face a different challenge: electricity bills reflecting Q3’s oil prices will arrive in Q4, adding material household expenditure pressure at a time when food costs are also elevated. NHT contributors retain the seven percent mortgage rate that remains the most effective wealth-building tool available to formal sector workers.
Renters in Dean-affected communities face housing disruption that may be prolonged where landlord-owned properties suffered roof or structural damage and insurance settlements are delayed. In unaffected areas, the rental market continues to tighten as the demand-supply imbalance that characterised 2006 and early 2007 persists. The new government’s housing policy commitments — which include an acceleration of low-income housing schemes — represent a medium-term aspiration but no immediate relief.
Developers face a Q4 assessment period: projects in Dean-affected areas require site re-evaluation, insurance claims must be processed, and the new government’s infrastructure priorities will take several months to become clear. Those in the resort parishes and in Kingston face more favourable conditions, with an incoming administration that has signalled pro-investment priorities and a tourism demand outlook that, despite Q3’s disruption, points to continued strong bookings for the 2007–08 winter season.
Businesses face a complicated Q4 picture. Dean’s disruption to agriculture — particularly in banana and produce — will affect the food supply chain and contribute to food inflation through the final quarter. Oil near US$80 will maintain electricity cost pressure. And the new government’s transition, while orderly, introduces the inevitable lag between political change and policy execution that affects procurement decisions and public contracts. Tourism businesses, by contrast, are watching forward bookings with cautious optimism: the Q3 disruption appears to have been contained to the storm’s immediate aftermath, and winter season advance reservations are holding up.
Diaspora investors are processing the combination of Dean and the election. The political change — for many diaspora members who had been hoping for the reform platform that the JLP represented — is welcome, and the new government’s early signals on investment facilitation are encouraging. Dean’s damage, while real, has not altered the fundamental investment case for Jamaican real estate. The more significant watch item is the global credit environment: diaspora members in the United States are watching the unfolding mortgage crisis from close range and will be better positioned than most to judge whether tighter credit conditions in the US will affect their own capacity to finance Jamaican property investments.
Outlook
Jamaica enters Q4 2007 with an economy that has absorbed two simultaneous shocks — a major hurricane and a political transition — and is broadly intact. The Golding government’s first months will be dominated by Dean reconstruction, the IMF engagement, and the formulation of a budget that signals the new administration’s economic priorities without breaching the primary surplus commitments that sustain market confidence. The tourism industry’s winter season — November through April — will be the critical test of whether Dean’s passage has left lasting damage to Jamaica’s reputation as a safe, attractive destination, or whether it is remembered as a manageable disruption that the island absorbed and moved past.
The global credit situation is the most difficult variable to assess. The BNP Paribas fund freeze and the Northern Rock collapse represent qualitative breaks in the financial system’s functioning that have no clear precedent in the post-Bretton Woods era. The Federal Reserve’s fifty basis point emergency cut in September suggests that US monetary authorities consider the credit deterioration to be a serious systemic risk, not a temporary disruption. If that assessment is correct — if what is beginning in US mortgage markets is the early phase of a broader credit contraction — then the global financial environment that Jamaica enters 2008 with will be materially more challenging than the one that supported the growth and stability of 2004–2007. The debt burden that constrained Jamaica’s options in the good years will constrain them still more severely if external credit tightens. That is the risk that should focus the Golding administration’s attention above all others as it finds its feet.
Jamaica Economic Intelligence is an independent data-driven journalism series published by Jamaica Homes News. Every article is grounded in official publications from the Bank of Jamaica, the Planning Institute of Jamaica, the Statistical Institute of Jamaica, the Ministry of Finance, and multilateral sources including the IMF, World Bank and IDB. No article constitutes financial, legal or investment advice.
Follow Jamaica Homes on Youtube @jamaicahomes and Instagram @jamaica_homes and on Facebook @jamaicahomesnews Send us a message or email us at onlinefeedback@jamaica-homes.com or editor@jamaica-homes.com
Visit our YouTube Community ↗